A 34 year-old transgender man, who was born a woman and still has the necessary parts, made the difficult decision to bear a child after his wife had a hysterectomy due to severe endometriosis. Thomas Beatie wrote an article for The Advocate in which he detailed the difficult and often humiliating process of trying to bear a child for his wife, during which doctors shunned him and his family discouraged him.
Beatie underwent breast reduction surgery and took testosterone for years to reassign his gender, but was not sterilized. He is legally a man and has all the benefits of marriage with his female wife. They live in Bend, Oregon and run a screen printing business.
When the couple made the decision that Beatie would bear their child after his wife’s hysterectomy, he stopped taking testosterone, and consulted many doctors about the decision, but did not take fertility drugs. Ultimately he chose to be artificially inseminated through a sperm bank, and the insemination was performed at home to save costs.
Beatie’s first pregnancy was ectopic and life-threatening, but his second is successful and he says he’s due in July:
He decided to carry a baby for his wife, Nancy, because she had a hysterectomy years ago. He was able to get pregnant because he kept his female organs when he switched genders.
“Sterilisation is not a requirement for sex reassignment, so I decided to have chest reconstruction and testosterone therapy but kept my reproductive rights,” he writes. “Wanting to have a biological child is neither a male nor female desire but a human desire.” The couple, who have been together for ten years, run a custom screenprinting business in Bend, Oregon, where neighbours do not know that Mr Beatie was once a woman.
“Our desire to work hard, buy our first home and start a family was nothing out of the ordinary. That is, until we decided that I would carry our child,” he wrote.
Before becoming pregnant, Mr Beatie stopped the testosterone injections he was receiving as part of his gender reassignment. “It had been roughly eight years since I had my last menstrual cycle so this wasn’t a decision that I took lightly. My body regulated itself after about four months and I didn’t have to take any exogenous oestrogen, progesterone or fertility drugs to aid my pregnancy,” he wrote.
The couple bought donor vials from a cryogenic sperm bank and, facing resistance and prejudice from doctors, resorted to home insemination. “Doctors have discriminated against us, turning us away due to their religious beliefs. Healthcare professionals have refused to call me by a male pronoun or recognise Nancy as my wife. Receptionists have laughed at us. Friends and family have been unsupportive; most of Nancy’s family doesn’t even know I’m transgender,” he said.
Mr Beatie’s first successful insemination ended in a life-threatening ectopic pregnancy with triplets that required surgery, resulting in the loss of all his embryos and his right Fallopian tube. “When my brother found out about my loss, he said, ‘It’s a good thing that happened. Who knows what kind of monster it would have been?’,” he wrote.
The second pregnancy resulted in a baby girl who is due to be born on July 3. “I will be my daughter’s father, and Nancy will be her mother. We will be a family,” he wrote.
[From Timesonline.co.uk]
Beatie’s neighbors only know him as a man and don’t really believe he’s pregnant. This is likely not the first pregnancy in a transgendered male, according to medical experts. Beatie says he still feels like a man and that being pregnant has not changed his gender identity.
At first I was kind of shocked to see this picture and thought it was some kind of hoax, but it’s perfectly natural when you think about it. It’s someone who made the decision to bear a child when his wife was unable to. He just happened to have the parts for it when most dads don’t. Congratulations to him and his wife.
What a terrific guy he is! I hope everything goes well and they have their happy family.
yah i think this is awesome too. probably really hard for right-wingers to swallow, but i agree that gender has nothing to do with desire to have a child. he is very brave.
This is just another form of surrogate child bearing. He gave his body to carry the child and also a part of the genetic pool (which is rather great since he couldn’t have been the sperm donor for his wife could she have been the biological mother of their child).
The picture, however, does leave me with doubts. Why does there seem to be this difference of skin colour between the upper part of his body and the rest from just under his nipples (it seems more orange-like, less white)?
I’m simply going to assume it’s a little technical error or so.
I guess I’m one of those right wingers who thinks this is a little twisted……
Oregon=red state. That’s so lame doctors would treat them that way.
I’m a little disturbed by the pic. Not in the sense that I think it’s been manipulated or anything (is that waht you’re saying, bellatrix?), just the pose. I don’t know why. Other than that, great, hope it all works out for them.
I hope everything turns out well for them
wow. talk about brave. I truly hope that this family gets the happy family life that they want.
You would think right wingers would be happy to see a biological female carrying a child. I don’t see what the big deal is.
to tell the truth i don’t care at all about this – BUT – i am bothered that this “man” is clearly still a woman (HELLO, he can bear a child!) and he is married to another woman. so what, if my girlfriend changes her name to a male name we can legally marry? it doesn’t seem fair to me. >:[
Bless! (reajillian, marriage should be available to any two people in a loving and committed relationship)
A lot of people don’t understand transgendered so they might mis interpret this story.
Many transgendered people say they don’t really identify with being male OR female. They don’t want to have to fit into a gender box. They may want different things at different times in their lives.
I wish the family nothing but the best & hope every turns out well!
Welcome into the XXIst century!
We are living in an amazing age where choice we never thought possible will be able to be taken.Of course, Ethics will have to follow but I believe that the incoming wonders will vastly compensate the headaches.
Cut it out, Lisa!
Lisa’s comments would be more effective if she could spell.
I have to share this. I wasn’t going to, but if it gives someone a laugh, then it’s worth my embarrassment.
I am a Sims 2 addict. I play it on weekends, long marathon sessions, and even belong to several forums that do nothing but talk about the game and share links and hints and help. OK, I’ll admit it, I even HAVE a forum that does all that.
In that game, if a male sim is abducted, he will come home the next day pregnant with an alien baby.
And my first reaction, when I saw this post on here, was “So what? Sims do it all the time.”
Ok. I’m going to go out on a limb here and please help me understand this.
What I keep thinking of is the child. This child is going to grow up with kids teasing her relentlessly b/c her dad gave birth to her. As a person who has a very slight – although very obvious to other children when I was a child – physical difference, I know what it’s like to be on that receiving end. It was torture some days.
I guess my problem is that any child who is even a tiny bit “different” from her peers will be teased, and I think this child will be born with a disadvantage.
Am I wrong in thinking that? That was my first reaction in reading this story.
noble and kind, but disgusting as well.
Carrie – how would the kids – or even their parents – necessarily know? the parents are a loving, two-gender couple straight out of saturday evening post.
rae – i would expect more understanding of genderqueer people from a lesbian. beatie is a man. he just happens to have some girl parts. your girlfriend has all her girl parts and WANTS TO BE A GIRL. the check F box for gender is prt of who she is. vice versa for him.
Thats pretty damn funny Syko!
Lol syko, great response! So wonderfully mundane and matter of fact.
I just hope that the testosterone that he *was* taking doesn’t adversely affect the baby.
I’m still hung up on the fact that he’s married, yet kept his organs. How does this work…? Unless his engorged clitoris allows for a normal sex life?
What’s the diff. The kid doesn’t have to know the details about her/his birth for many years. And this is the 21st century, where families consist of many different combinations. The main thing by far is that they are good parents. Really, bottom line – what else matters than that the child is raised in a loving home.
Ok…new life, happy couple, a new scientific exploration going on out there. Well, I am happy
for them and wish them all the best. If you think this kid is going to be messed up b/c of the birthing situation, well, you better talk to the kids who have two mommies and two daddies…better make sure they aren’t messed up either. While we are at it, talk to the single mothers, single fathers, granparents raising their kids. If you discriminate against one, you discriminate against them all.
Screw the negativity and just be supportive of two people brave enough to take on parenthood.
P.S. Morning all 🙂
@RC – seriously?? In the age of the Internet you ask how will they know?? How could you possibly keep that from anyone? You’ve got some zealots out there who will froth at the mouth over this. And tell me the media will let them live their lives in peace. I just don’t think that’ll happen.
I guess since I know what I went through, I’m seeing it from an angle not necessarily everyone would look at this situation from.
Best wishes to all of them. We will never know what its like to walk in his shoes. But my hat is off to him and his wife to take such a brave
path.
Just wondering if the right to lifers would want them to abort. Interesting question.
@cc. You are 100% correct. But that’s not what this article is about. It’s about a father giving birth to his daughter. Period.
Please don’t misinterpret what I’m trying to say.
well i think its frankly disgusting..first SHE thinks she should of been a man..so SHE has her operation..SHE is pregnant supposedly as a MAN..but feels natural about it? well is she felt so natural in this state maybe she should of stayed a woman..sad, pathetic and disgusting..
AND I’m out. You’ve done it teri. (and it is “should have” not “should of”) You are so judgmental and offensive – I’m only reading the delightful Celebitchy posts from now on and sparing myself from encountering such hatred. Ciao comments.
Carrie, children are less understanding of another child who doesn’t look like they do, however the fact that someone has alternative family arrangements usually doesn’t come into question until they are older. I think you may be confusing the situtations because of what happened to you. I am still scarred from high school and there was nothing wrong with me. Children are cruel because they have to learn to censor themselves. The LGBT has more supoort now compared to when you were in school. It is nice to think of the child, but unless you are in an “alternative” family, you really don’t know how people usually react to you. I have friends in a similar situation and there has been nothing but love and support for them. I think that when the child is old enough to understand, then the conversation can veer in the direction of what happens now? That question is for the parents to decide and us to support. They don’t need naysayers right now. They need to know that their friends and family love them, support them. Not people they don’t know trashing them.
Also, your comments leads me to think you have a problem with the man having the baby and minimal concern for the child involved.
I don’t think it’s justified to say that he shouldn’t have a baby because it would suffer discrimination. That’s like saying that no babies should ever be born unless life is going to be all roses for them. In that case, I guess black people should never have kids? I understand wanting to protect a kid from suffering of that nature, but life sucks, and sometimes going through hard times can make you a better person for it, even if it seems crappy at the time.
I have to say I don’t really understand this whole thing. I don’t understand wanting to be a man so badly that you will reconstruct your body to be as much like a man as possible – BUT you keep your reproductive organs. In a way, functioning breasts are reproductive organs too. I’m not saying there should be laws that transgender people should be sterilized. That’s draconian. I’m just saying, on a personal level, I don’t get it. It’s ok, I just don’t get it.
Also, I have no problem with gay marriage or the fact that transgender people can legally marry. But then again, I’m Canadian, and gay marriage has been legal here for years, so maybe I’m just more accustomed to this issue.
A person that chopped her breasts, takes testosteron, thinks she’s a man but is still willing and able to get pregnant is still a WOMAN in my book.
Not shocking or heroic, just silly.
@cc. I have to disagree with your last comment. Please don’t over-analyze what I’m trying to say and presume you’ve got me all figured out with my two or three comments on this post. I’ve never really given much thought to a male giving birth, but I can assure you I have no issues with it whatsoever.
All I wanted was a different point of view on this story. So thank you and urgh (who I feel more closely hit the nail on the proverbial head). We all have our crosses to bear and it’s how we deal with them that makes us who we become.
RC, I think rae’s point is that she feels it’s unfair for all the others that cannot marry due to gender than he can just call himself a man and whammo bammo, marry another woman.
I know it’s more complex than calling yourself a man but I think you get my point.
EW! FUBAR!!!!! I don’t know weither to puke or to puke! I couldnt finish the article… what has teh world become?! I dont know weither women should feel violated and betrayed or weither men should feel even more violated!
I dont have a prob with lesbians, honestly. But this is just downright FUBAR. Is there evena line anymore?!
Carrie, I do agree Urgh said it the best. I guess our last comments could have been misinterperted. :p
Wait’ll the Pope hears about this….
I guess breast-feeding’s out, huh?
@cc, That’s all I wanted….a different opinion from my take on it. Thanks for not totally raking me over the coals. 🙂
I’m so encouraged by your take on this story and by many of the comments on this page!
Sure it was a bit strange to read at first, but out of curiosity as to how it happened (on purpose or accidentaly) rather than disgust.
It’s a loving couple having a baby! Congratulations to them and best of luck.
ummmm……it’s not real. no way. don’t you think if it were real every medical journal in the world would be talking about it? i have two words for you guys: APRIL FOOL’S!
oh please the media and all need to stop making a big deal about this WOMAN having a baby. she has all the female organs just not boobs. transgender my behind that is woman who wants to be a man and is now going to give birth just like we woman are suppose to when we get knocked up. this story was on 20/20 last night under the headline medical mysteries. what is the mystery?? a woman got knocked up. big deal. happens everyday and night. my thing is the kids will see this and think dudes can give birth. get the hell outta here. tell the kids the truth do not have them confused. a man having a baby, stop all this madness for real.
God bless them! That being said eeeww!!
So? He used to be a woman. How is anyone shocked from this? I’m all for the right to be whoever you wish, but.. it’s not as if a natural man got pregnant. I don’t see how this is such a big “shock”, when it all makes perfect sense. His female organs were still there, so why not?
How much you wanna bet this isn’t the first case?
I am a newly recent first time mom here in Bend, and I hope this community will embrace this loving couple. Love knows no color or gender, and everyone has the right to equality and happiness. I will be teaching my son tolerance, and I hope this community will join me through their actions and support.
I’m pretty damn liberal, but even I think this is sick. 21st century my ass. This is sick and selfish. The poor child, being born to a family of freaks. God help them.
Disgusting. There are no words.
I think for Thomas to become pregnant and admit to the world is one great love for his beloved wife. Period!
I heard that the first man who gets pregnant gets disney land/world… everything to do with disney, does that count for him?
No, he doesn’t count because the Disney thing is an urban legend – it’s not true.
I’d DO HIM HARD!!! 😛
Yes he was a surrogate, but I feel childbirth is something special and beautiful to womanhood. Ok,so he was once a woman, but she chose to have a sex change operation and become a man.
Although he as the ability to carry a child the idea of man having a baby is twisted and bizarre. Poor kids.
This might come a little late, seeing as the story has been out for a while, and I could receive comments from both sides of the spectrum, but I am transgender as well, female to male. Thomas is a male mentally, not physically. So yes, naturally, he is a woman who can give birth to children given that he still has his reproductive organs. But if you think about it, he would have never given thought to child birthing had his wife not had the medical complications. He had no preliminary desire to give birth, it simply happened that way. Some would say he’s only enforcing his birth gender back in to play on himself, others will say he did a brave thing for doing this for his wife and their future family. I think it’s complicated like that in both ways. I have never wanted to give birth to children, but that does not mean I don’t want children. I’m still undecided, but if I married someone who could not give birth, and there was no other way, I might consider it. Adoption is also an option. I have to wonder, maybe they didn’t go with adoption because that would also enforce the gender on Thomas. Two genetic males cannot have children, so they would adopt. Two genetic females could not bear children together, and would need artificial insemination or adoption. Both adoption and giving birth himself have their pros and cons, but I think they did what they could with what they had and are making the best of it. That’s what being a family is about, isn’t it? Not whether you were born by your mother, adopted, or if the sperm that brought you in to existence is from your father’s DNA or not. Being a family is about protection, care, support, and love. And in that sense, anyone can be family, no matter the gender, race, heritage, orientation, etc.
I support the couple not because I am transgender, I support the couple for taking on the roles of parents at many costs and risks, and for living their life to their best, even if it doesn’t agree with everyone else’s beliefs or political standings. It’s their life and their family, and while they are hanging together and remain strong, who’s place is it to judge them?
Your blog is very informative, keep up the good work!!!!