Anne Hathaway & Jake Gyllenhaal’s on-screen chemistry: icky or hot?

love

Above is the new poster for Love and Other Drugs, the film that will be coming out shortly, this fall sometime. Jake Gyllenhaal plays a pharmaceutical rep/salesman who ends up promoting the best-selling drug in the world: Viagra. Anne Hathaway plays the girl Jake meets and falls for, even though she’s intense and his career is taking off and he could bone every nurse he wanted. The trailer came out last month, and I watched it, expecting to hate it. I didn’t. And now I’m ashamed:

Okay, here’s my question: does anyone else remember the stories about Jake and Anne hating each other? They previously worked on Brokeback Mountain together, and I have strong memories of Jake insinuating that he thought Anne was a major a–hole. Am I hallucinating? If they did (do) hate each other, then I guess their acting is a lot better than you would think – they do seem to have some kind of chemistry together, and it’s good to see them both in these kinds of roles. Will this just be another interchangeable rom-com? Eh. There is something icky about it though – they both trying to seem so wholesome.

wenn298256

Jake: “This bitch.”

wenn298255

Poster courtesy of HuffPo. Anne & Jake promoting Brokeback in 2005, credit: WENN.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

58 Responses to “Anne Hathaway & Jake Gyllenhaal’s on-screen chemistry: icky or hot?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. hay says:

    Icky. She’s just not pretty.

  2. mercy says:

    He has gotten sooooo sexy hot. He used to be kind of goofy cute, but he is truly hot now. I hardly noticed her watching the trailer … but upon rewatching it to check her out, she is definitely gorgeous but he outshines her by far. They’re not believable together though.

  3. LOVE ANGELINA says:

    Uhhh I don’t see much chemistry. Some.

  4. Oi says:

    I seem to remember that too, Kaiser. But then again, Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer hated (and I mean despised) each other and West Side Story didn’t suffer at all.

    This looks really dumb, tbh.

  5. Cath says:

    This movie sounds even stupider than the Baster, and that’s saying something.

  6. Kate says:

    Saw the preview. It creeped me out. Not seeing it. I have a hard time seeing either one of them in a romantic role. Jake, because, well, I still think he is gay, and Anne, because, well, there is just something off about her.

  7. Katie says:

    I never heard anything about them hating each other on Brokeback but I’d like to hear about it now. Any links?

  8. Kaboom says:

    I’m always on the fence about whether she’s pretty or not, she moves back and forth across the line from still photo to still photo. However once in motion she undeniably has “it”.

  9. Leticia says:

    I don’t think that she has sex appeal, although she is very pretty.

  10. Fluffy Kitten Tail says:

    Hmm, well I guess I am the lone poster who actually wants to see this movie. Of course I will wait until it’s on HBO, but I will watch it.

    I like both Jake and Anne. I find her to be a good actress, and I really liked her in Rachel Getting Married and The Devil Wears Prada. I liked her more than Kate H in The Bride Wars. I have love for Jake since the the Donnie Darko days. Bubble Boy was great, The Good Girl and I adored him in Jarhead!

  11. jen says:

    Laverne & Shirley hated each other too, but they made it work!

  12. Iggles says:

    Omg, they were married in brokeback mountain! I just remembered that..

    I’m meh about this movie. Not gonna see it.

  13. Melissa says:

    Geez – she looks terrible on that poster!

  14. K-MAC says:

    I think they are super hot together!!!! I cannot wait to see this film!

  15. Julie says:

    The promo for this movie is so weird. They keep selling it as some fluffy rom-com, even though Anne’s character has a terrible disease (not a spoiler).

    Also, I just don’t like Jake much as a romantic lead.

  16. mln says:

    I have to confess this is the kind of rom-com I enjoy but I wouldn’t pay to see it I’ll wait for cable.

  17. Samantha says:

    @Julie – Didn’t realize she had a disease. Sounds a little like a sluttier version of Sweet November now.

  18. iKat says:

    She looks like a cat.
    He is BEAUTIFUL!! Yum

  19. LindyLou says:

    Hate is a very passionate emotion – makes for great sex. Or so I hear!!

  20. Solveig says:

    I like them both, but I’m not sure about the chemistry, probably because I always get the gay vibe from him.
    The movie doens’t look bad, the trailer made me smile a couple of times, althought I’m not into rom-coms enough to enjoy them from the beginning to the end.

  21. Amy says:

    What is with you and your thing with celebrities appearing “wholesome?” This seems to come up a lot with Anne Hathaway and Jennifer Garner! So they aren’t crazy like other celebs… that’s a bad thing?

  22. Lisa S. says:

    I just dont get into him at all..

  23. moo says:

    I still think Jake is gay, and Anne is just so desperate…. weird combo!

  24. Delta Juliet says:

    I’m with LindyLou

    There is a thin line between love and hate for sure! I’ve experienced it! LOL

  25. Maritza says:

    Awww,the movie seems sweet and they look so cute together. I’ll definitely watch this one.

  26. Cam says:

    Am I the only one who thinks she’s really talented and he’s hot as hell? not sure about the chemistry though, but im definitely seeing this movie.

  27. Dorothy says:

    Jake Gyllenhaal is so f*ucking HOT!!!! I will see anything that he is in and I also happen to think this looks great.

  28. linds says:

    how is she not pretty? she has soft feminine features and a great smile as well as great hair. she looks natural. people are wayyyy tooooo picky these days. it’s because of women who put other women down for the most picky reasons that we are so stereotypically and unrealistically portrayed and represented in magazines and media. we say men are mean or sexist when they say we should be a certain weight or when they push their own thoughts of what ‘pretty’ is down our throats, but women are way worse and do it to each other when we should stand behind each others differences and flaws because that’s what makes each of us uniquely beautiful. society will never follow if we can’t even set a good example ourselves for how to treat women, and we are women!

  29. Bunny says:

    It looks really odd, of course I will see it just for Jake.

  30. iKat says:

    #29 – I wouldn’t describe her features as ‘soft and feminine’. Everything on her face looks really… big. She has BIG eyes, BIG lips and, yes it’s nice, but a BIG nose. All fitted on a small face.

    Reminds me of a cat.

  31. Kate says:

    GREAT chemistry considering Jake Gyllenhaal is gay.

  32. Kate says:

    “Am I the only one who thinks she’s really talented and he’s hot as hell”
    OF COURSE NOT 🙂

  33. Bodhi says:

    See, I think she looks like a squirrel.

  34. johnny says:

    Anne Hathaway’s good girl image makes me nauseous. I love Jake but the screenplay seems lame. Great…another chick flick to add to the list. (barfs)

  35. bb says:

    @29, I agree, Anne is very pretty and feminine looking.

    Jake though…fug.

  36. Nicky says:

    Anne’s features are more overwhelming than soft and feminine. She’s one of those actresses who is as much disliked as she is liked. I’m not hugely keen on her, mainly because I think she overacts her roles. It’s almost like she’s trying too hard to prove something, or maybe it’s because I don’t think she’s as good of an actress as most people say she is.

  37. Crash2GO2 says:

    @linds: Well said.

    Anne herself has said she thinks her features are too big for her small head, so it just goes to show that we are all too hard on ourselves already. No need for others to pile it on as well. She really is quite beautiful.

    And Jake is soooooooo delicious. I don’t get these ‘gay vibe’ers at ALL. I love his wolfish smile. *rar*

  38. OPrime says:

    I don’t like Hathaway and am heartened to hear that others feel the same — I thought it was just me. There’s just something about her… her ears? nose? or is it her “acting”?? Whatever it is, it rubs me the wrong way… blech.

  39. cantbelievethis says:

    @Crash2Go2 ITA about Jake G.

    I like the trailer and the movie has gotten really good reviews so far (on IMDb).

  40. lala from nYc says:

    Jake doesn’t look right. Like he’s depressed or down.

    Someone get that boy a cupcake!

  41. Erin says:

    @linds
    Right on. I think she’s lovely in an elegant, classic way. I get it when women don’t like plastic, artificial women, but when people are hating on someone who is very pretty in a natural way, I just feel like it’s jealousy. Or stupidity…I don’t see the need to knock women down like that.

  42. belle Epoch says:

    So surprised that people find Jake hot. I think he is totally gay, which makes it awkward (tho not impossible) to be a romantic lead. He looks like a clown to me.

  43. Camille says:

    I think it looks awful, yet kind of cute at the same time and I will more than likely end up renting it when it comes out.
    I love Jake and I don’t mind Anne, they kind of work well together from what I can see in the trailer.
    I also like how they did Anne’s hair in the movie, very cute. She looks much better when she has her hair down.

  44. CB Rawks says:

    I don’t come close to understanding the Jake Gyllenhaal thing. His face is wonky and crooked and his eyes are too close together. It’s a stumper.

  45. viv says:

    Jake is SO HOT, SEXY and talented.And I don’t hate Anne.I want to see this film.This is the first time Jake play a rom-com lead.I believe he will do a good job.
    I heard before that Anne wasn’t nice when filming LAOD but Jake on the other hand was so sweet and funny. Idk….

  46. Lisa Turtle says:

    The thing about Anne Hathaway, and the character that she plays is that she is neither charming nor endearing, nor particularly attractive. She just does not have the movie star factor that makes you want to watch and adore someone. Anne could be a great character actress, she was at her prime in Rachel Getting Married. However, in this film, to convince the audience that Jake Gyllenhaal has given up womanizing, she needs to really charm, and she just does not. Jake is charming, but its hard to see the attraction to her on his part.

  47. Saoirse says:

    Loved her in Alice In Wonderland as the White Queen.
    @Crash2GO2: I completely agree. She is a very beautiful woman.
    As far as Jake goes, he’s a wonderful actor but he’s just not the kind of guy I’m normally attracted to. I’ll probably see this after it comes out on DVD.

  48. rammzoo says:

    It’s not what you don’t know that hurts you so much…But what you are so sure of, that ain’t so (Will Rogers quote) If the worst thing you can think of to say about Jake is that he is gay….then he is doing O.K. Some pretty ignorant folks (OUT THERE)

  49. normade says:

    She is photogenic, but weird looking

  50. Mags says:

    Jake is hot and Anne her features are so big i think she’s ok looking not pretty though

  51. I Choose Me says:

    Don’t get why people keep insisting Jake is gay without anything concrete to back up this claim but whatever. I like them both, I like them together and I’ll probably give this movie a look when it comes out.

  52. Seeer says:

    Love Jake. Love Ann. Don’t love them together though.

  53. Anti-icon says:

    I am torn as well. I like Anne Hathaway as an actress and she gets really good roles and does well with them. I don’t know what that whole scandal was about and how deeply she was/was not involved, but it went all the way to Rome and the pope (he was a high level financial con man). So, I’ll admit it, that colors my perception of her. Other actresses should get roles who are talented (Michelle Williams, for example) who haven’t been involved in an international financial scandal.

  54. original kate says:

    she has shark eyes, dead and lifeless.

  55. Mika says:

    Ugghhh…. I like Anne Hathaway, but just because the movie is set in 1995, doesn’t mean you have to do a Julie Louise Dryfuss impression.

    Listen to her say “You’re Guuuud…” ahh ELAINE!

  56. neil says:

    he is really hot when he makes out with dudes.

  57. I thought Love & Other Drugs was a romcom but I was disappointed as the movie was depressing. The only good thing was that Jake was an eyecandy. -Riza Hollister