Gwyneth Paltrow devoted her weekly Goop-letter to her efforts with the Food Stamp Challenge this week. Even though this comes after several days of abuse hurled at Gwyneth for “poverty tourism” and peasant-lies, I kind of think this was probably her goal from the start. She didn’t dedicate herself to the challenge of trying to live on $29 a week (for food) but she always planned on writing about it for Goop. You could even say that she half-assed it for a greater purpose: to make a larger statement about how we eat, the food we buy and how women need equal pay. You can read her whole Goop-post here.
Last week, chef (and great man) Mario Batali challenged me to raise awareness and money for the NYC Food Bank by trying to live on $29 dollars for the week (what low income families on SNAP are trying to survive on). Dubious that I could complete the week, I donated to the Food Bank at the outset, and all of us at the goop office began the challenge.
As I suspected, we only made it through about four days, when I personally broke and had some chicken and fresh vegetables (and in full transparency, half a bag of black licorice). My perspective has been forever altered by how difficult it was to eat wholesome, nutritious food on that budget, even for just a few days—a challenge that 47 million Americans face every day, week, and year. A few takeaways from the week were that vegetarian staples liked dried beans and rice go a long way—and we were able to come up with a few recipes on a super tight budget.
After trying to complete this challenge (I would give myself a C-), I am even more outraged that there is still not equal pay in the workplace. Sorry to go on a tangent, but many hardworking mothers are being asked to do the impossible: Feed their families on a budget which can only support food businesses that provide low-quality food. The food system in our beautiful country needs to be subjected to a heavy revision—it is a cyclical problem, with repercussions that we all feel. I’m not suggesting everyone eat organic food from some high horse in the sky. I’m saying everyone should be able to afford fresh, real food. And if women were paid an equal wage, families might have more of a choice in the grocery aisles, not to mention in the rest of their lives.
…I know hunger doesn’t always touch us all directly—but it does touch us all indirectly. After this week, I am even more grateful that I am able to provide high-quality food for my kids. Let’s all do what we can to make this a basic human right and not a privilege.
A C-minus? I guess the only thing Gwyneth can NOT do well is pretend to be poor.
Gwyneth also cites statistics about equal pay and she literally types “hats off to Patricia Arquette” for drawing attention to the issue. Real question: do some people think that Arquette was, like, the first person arguing for equal pay? As for the correlation Gwyneth draws between equal pay and food insecurity, as much as I want to nitpick her to death, if we’re looking at the realpolitik, she’s right. Food insecurity is linked to women’s pay and more often than not, it falls on mothers to care about food and what their children eat. Is that the way it SHOULD be? Of course not. In a perfect world, women and men would have equal pay for equal work and men and women would have equal interest in ensuring food security for their children.
But yes, Gwyneth did half-ass this challenge. She only stuck with it long enough to have her Goop staff come up with some recipes involving eggs and rice. Guess what she used all those limes for? Zest and garnish. Classic.
Photos courtesy of Goop, WENN.
Yes, her intention all along was to fail. She wanted to bring attention to how hard those in poverty (read: statistically, women and children) have it in America.
She’s been supporting feeding the poor in NYC for YEARS. This is not a new cause for her.
It might have helped if she mentioned that instead of deferring to Arquette.
KIDDO, I completely agree with you; the Arquette mention was random.
Also, her publicist Huvane doesn’t seem worth his rates sometimes.
If she had mentioned that, she would have been castigated as patting herself on the back.
Carol, she didn’t have to say what she did with the organization, she could have mentioned the work they are doing and why.
So instead of putting herself in people’s shoes and using her immense platform to really educate her ‘fanbase’ on what goes into the mental strain of actually living like this she planned to fail, bought bullsht, and then quit 4 days later?
Fck her.
Gwyneth…Rally the politicians, use your celebrity to help enact legislation to bring about real changes, not just pretty Instagram pics and water cooler talk that is forgotten until the next viral topic comes along. DO more, do better.
I give Gwyneth an “F” for this challenge, but as one on foodstamps myself, I appreciate her acknowlegement that she failed. She at least succeeded in one respect – by highlighting how effin hard it is to live on so very little.
C- isn’t a fail. She gets an F for incomplete. FAIL
Yeah, but she did go to schools where grades weren’t as important as sparkling and uniqueness, right? She probably doesn’t understand that you have to at least complete the task.
LOL, that reminds me of Arrested Development where Maybe’s school gave her a Crocodile in Spelling.
She’s a piece of work.
“Beautiful country” hahhaah: oh Gwynnie we know you think Murica is for peasants.
Seriously though, I am glad that she did this and talked about it because food deserts are very real and low income families getting nutritious foods in some areas is next to impossible. So I’ll give her a C+ for shedding a tiny bit of her goop shine on this topic that needs to be inspected closer.
I dont think It was Hurling abuse for people to publicly call out this for what it was: Let’s Play Pretend Poor for a few days You Guys
Yup yup. Was she even trying with those abundance of limes people were rightfully calling her out on?
Amy don’t be obtuse. you know us peasants and poors love us some lime organic lemonade to go with our fresh poverty, Gwynnie just wasnt sure cause.. Acting
She could have bought like 2 rotisserie chickens for the price of those dang limes!
She could have bought like 2 rotisserie chickens for the price of those dang limes!
QQ, I wish you would stop projecting your own issues onto the pristine blank canvas that la Goop, okay ? I mean, she may understand that it’s really only yourself you hate, but it’s still sad to read. Sheesh.
Blythe Danner is gonna name check you now.
Sure, Gwyneth, Patricia Arquette brought this to our attention. Lilly Ledbetter, her Supreme Court case, and her struggle against the GOP in Congress did absolutely nothing to bring this to our attention.
Amen!
Ha! I’m sure she was name-checking her as a celebrity who was also criticized recently on social media more than on her message.
Kind of odd that her publicist said she completed it a week ago then, huh?
I’m glad she supported her local food bank, and I do hope even in this limited experience, she did gain some insight. Maybe it’ll make her think twice before she sells the next $800 juice cleanse.
Agree. I think that stating that she supports the food bank and the issues is important. And acknowledging the issue of income inequity and how it impacts the ability to feed your family (but again, in Hollywood, the inequity is between getting $2 million or 5, so it is hard to feel sorry for them).
BUT, she only admitted to her inability to complete the very difficult task because she got caught in a lie. Where is her acknowledgement of this!?! Her publicist said she completed it, then she came out with the lime and cilantro photo. Her cluelessness continues with this editorial. The internet does not erase itself so folks can look up the brag from her publicist. If she wants to come clean, she should come completely clean, then she would get more than what should be a failing grade.
Excellent observation on the earlier PR bs. This one can never do anything right. Thinks we’re all daft like her
I thought her publicist released a statement saying she had already completed the challenge before she posted the picture? Maybe I’m misremembering. I give myself a B-.
I give you an A+ for being commander of the internet links. It must be difficult to remember what each one said.
Yes he said that after she got caught eating out the first time and was called out and Goop made a statement after she got caught the second timr funny how that works.
Anything to keep her falling star in the news. She’s brainless and irrelevant.
I’m not a huge fan of the music, okay maybe a few songs now that I’ve seen what he has done, but Bon Jovi has actually put his money where is mouth is: http://www.jbjsoulkitchen.org/en
http://www.thepeoplespantry.org/, http://www.bonjovi.com/news/116399185037/the-foodbank-of-monmouth-and-ocean-counties-the
I’m glad that at least Goop admits her inability to sustain such a difficult task, but I think she also dropped the ball, by only quoting platitudes from another famous rich person, and giving up ‘the game’ altogether. Even if she isn’t as mega-wealthy as Bon Jovi, she seems to have plenty of connections, at least with people who buy ridic expensive items on her site. Just sayin’.
She was caught so she threw a distraction post at us. I’m not fooled because I’m the knower of all things and the poster of all links.
Also
Shot through the heart and you’re to blame
Kiddo you give comments…A pretty ok name.
Jon Bon Jovi walks the walk for sure.
Yeah, the pay equality stuff, while relevant and important, had a hint of deflection in it.
JBJ’s new center is just north of me, he’s awesome for doing that. There’s a lot of people still struggling after Hurricane Sandy, and he’s been very involved in helping a lot of people.
Helps out the people who’ve got their six string in hock, or are working the diner all day…
Helps out the people who’ve got their six string in hock, or are working the diner all day…
Wait, does that translate into ‘he’s not really helping anyone’? I really don’t know.
Woah, we’re half way there
Woah, living on our hair!
Now I gotta go look up songs. *So far I can’t find any that I know, dammit.
Come on. I’ve seen a million faces, AND IVE ROCKED THEM ALL!
Where’s blue marie? She would absolutely destroy this challenge.
I know there was something I thought was decent, but I resorted to the greatest hits playlist and nothing is ringing a bell.
F for Fired. I kind of only want to talk to you in Bon Jovi lyrics now.
I won’t bother to leave much of a comment because I would have said what you said, Kaiser. Food is a feminist issue!
As impractical as her choices were and as oblivious as she can be about how most people live, she tried to raise awareness about an issue that a growing number of people face. And while she didn’t follow all the way though, she admitted that fact and essentially admitted that she was privileged enough to be able to be able to back out of the challenge when she didn’t feel like going through with it anymore. I can’t hate on her for that.
…were people really not aware the majority of our country is starving and struggling or was that the folks in Gwyn’s la la land?
Awareness only does so much.
You’d be surprised at how many people are in their own little bubbles – and these are people who aren’t anywhere near Paltrow’s income/net worth. There’s a lot of misinformation and assumptions as to how much people can get from benefits. Given the current political environment of slashing these benefits, I don’t think there’s anything negative about what Paltrow is trying to do.
IMO, I don’t get why she’s getting so much hate for this. Plenty of other celebrities – including (nearly) everyone’s beloved Hiddleston – did some variation of this challenge and they get praised for doing so.
( IMO, I don’t get why she’s getting so much hate for this. Plenty of other celebrities – including (nearly) everyone’s beloved Hiddleston – did some variation of this challenge and they get praised for doing so. )
Will for one her whole $29 budget Meal was a joke from the beginning. Her PR her person said she finished the challenge last Thursday so why did it take her 5 days to make this statement and after the media caught eating out twice? She only saving face now by making a comment because she got bad publicity from it.
There are pictures of Goop earing out last week also and Hiddleston got some hate too.
The thing is -Did she not do any planning? Was it done on a whim -like Oooh, is that the new thing, taking the SNAP challenge?
If she had taken a week to talk to a nutritionist and planned out her meals and budget -she could have met the challenge while sharing the information she had received and talking about the difficulties. She went about this in a very Marie-Antoinette-pretending-to-be-a-milkmaid sort of way. She had a chance to make a difference and she didn’t take it.
Exactly.
As far as I can see the amount of work done for this challenge was this: Someone buys food that could never produce a meal. Someone takes a picture of food. Someone posts picture and tweet.
Done. Well sound the alarm! Bring the trumpeters!
She was caught failing within days which makes me believe she didn’t even try for maybe more than a meal if that.
I agree. She is still a snob in my book but I’d rather have more people talk about the fact that many Americans struggle to put food on the table than have nobody talk about it. Who cares what her real intentions were.
The only reason she “admitted” to failing the challenge is because she was caught having lunch at a restaurant.
But I find it hilarious that her PR agent Huvane already released a statement stating that she completed the task. Seriously Huvane and his clients (Gwyneth, Reese, Chelsea, Jennifer Aniston etc) are the biggest liars, hypocritical mean girl celebs in Hollywood. They constantly say one thing and then do something else, they lie to the public and yet really don’t get crusified by the media because Huvane has been known to threatened them.
I’m surprised that he still gets work, frankly. He seems to be more of a liability in his PR releases, a hindrance, instead of help, in his messages.
I don’t think you have an understanding about how PR works.
billy, maybe not. I would have thought it an advantage, or a promotion, not a detriment; making you look bad.
LOL Huvane is probably disgusted by his own clients who probably keep him hopping with their antics. How can that not leak through, eventually?
Ugh. There are some valid points somewhere in there but they get lost in the goop.
P.S. I hate dresses with one sleeve. Are your arms going to the same party?
@ GNAT, lol, the obsessive compulsive part of me always wants to “fix” those dresses.
LOL! I think of those sleeves as the dress equivalent of the way I like to sleep with one leg sticking out of the covers.
Can’t she just lie (like everybody in Hollywood) and say that she did it? She already has bad PR. Maybe now since she shares a husband (ex-husband?) with JLaw, they can also share her PR team. Those people can do magic.
Actually, the main generator of poverty is low pay across the board, not unequal pay for women – if you pay your workers the minimum wage, and it costs more than that to eat properly where they live, then making sure that male and female employees get the same pay doesn’t change anything aside from creating equal exploitation. But I wouldn’t expect Goop to take the time to work that out…
Do men on benefits get a higher rate than women anyway?
In Australia (where I live) the unemployment benefit is the same whether you’re male or female.
What I don’t get about the SNAP benefit is- do you get another, separate payment to pay for things like toilet paper, soap, shampoo, deodorant, toothpaste, etc? Because if not $29 per person per week won’t go far AT ALL.
She did the food equivalent of slumming it. Slum sociable.
Also, I thought the food stamp challenge as 29 bucks for an entire family?
Uhm, making it 4/7 days is only 57% – call that a fail. Next time don’t do the challenge.
@ swack: That’s right. 57% is a fail.
Why did she think she deserved a C minus?
She did bring attention to the issue though. I had no clue what snap gives, and it was a shock to me. It would definitely be hard to survive on that little amount of grocery money a week. I think she deserves credit here. She took the challenge, brought attention to the issue, and admitted she failed.
I agree with you, cari, the alternative would have been to turn it down and have no spotlight on it. She brought attention to it and I think her column on this is thoughtfully written. I think failing the challenge and admitting to it says just as much as to the point being made. Even if it’s slings and arrows, people are talking about the issue at hand.
I give her credit too.
This. Idk why her haters keep trying to find something here. There is nothing to see here, folks. She brought the cause a lot of press & made quite a few peeps think. That’s a success in my book.
This woman!!! Like she can’t live on that food for a week yet she routinely subjects herself to UNHEALTHY juice fasts while overexercising? What she eats on a normal day is probably less than what she would eat on the challenge anyway, this should have been a breeze for her.
She KNOWS how to deprive herself for weeks just so she could lose the 2 pounds she gained from her Christmas meal yet dedicating herself to a good cause is too much for her? Being/getting thin is a better motivator than doing something for charity? Basically Gwyneth is more important to Gwyneth than thinking about other people just for one week.
Let’s not forget that she promotes the Tracy Anderson method which is basically eating 1 carrot and some soup so what is her problem with her ‘poor man’s food’? Like come on, this bull is too much. Even for her this is pretty ‘rich’, pun non intended.
Basically, this is typical Hollywood behavior and has got nothing to do with the things she is trying to deflect to. Having discipline for things that only concern her. Bye, BYE…she’s disgusting.
But I would say that her inability to complete the challenge works in her favor. If she’s disciplined enough to deprive herself generally but couldn’t complete this challenge, what does it say about the difficulties that people who have no choice but to live on that amount have to face? The point of the challenge isn’t whether or not she can do it – it’s not like she’s training for a marathon for charity, decided it was too hard and dropped out – the point of the challenge is to show how difficult it is to live on SNAP benefits.
Goop has put more time and energy in her cleaning by posting tweets, newsletters, posting recipes and giving updates on her progress then she did with this Food Stamp challenge.
So what did Goop posting one picture really do? Got some attention yes but what did it really do for the cause?
What do you want her to do (or to have done)?
From other comments she given money to supporting feeding the poor in NYC for yeas. If that is true then I expected her to take this seriously, I expected her to put more time and energy into this challenge that she supports then she does into her cleaneses and a I expected her to do more then to just post a picture and hashtag it.
Nothing because she couldn’t be bothered to properly explain what she was eating and how much so how do we know that she really felt deprived? I would say she was fine but preferred to eat whatever she wanted because it wasn’t about her. Like KellyBee says, she explains her cleanses thoroughly ad nauseum. She has an eating disorder imo which makes her choices even more jarring, it was like she just couidn’t help herself but not give a damn.
You cannot tell me that rice and beans ( a nice complete-ish meal that will keep you full) is depriving yourself like plain veg and fruit juice which is a crash diet. There’s more variety and healthy options in that picture than in a general Goop ‘cleanse’.
@Artemis: +1000
1000 pts to Artemis and Kellybee
It crossed my mind she may have thought it was too many calories to eat the rice and beans…
But it worked. In criticizing GOOP for being out of touch, we have discussed the issues. This post is pointing out the gender disparity, and I’ve seen other articles picking apart her choices, talking about how the under-privileged can’t afford to choose more than processed food.
GOOP isn’t out of touch. She’s smart. She knows that people watch her site to scorn and put herself in the firing line, and the by-product is dialogue. I think she gets credit for this.
I doubt she thought that far ahead. IMO she rubber stamped the challenge, gave instructions to an assistant to buy and take the pic of the food, and didn’t give it another thought as she went on about her daily lunches and dinners out, until the blacklash hit. “What, they expected me to do that? I let them use my name!” Someone far more intelligent and PR savvy was told to write that GOOP newsletter. She just isn’t that smart and I doubt she cares what the peons think about her anyway.
I thought starving herself wpuld be easy for her?!
+1!!!
If I could do a water fast for two weeks and pretend as I did that it was for Hollywood weight loss and health (not because I was actually so broke, I couldn’t even afford a $1 bag of pasta), then surely Gwynnie could, too?
This seriously makes me so mad! My husband lost his job back in feb and I applied for SNAP benefits then because we are very broke. SNAP just got back to use on weds to say we finally got benefits and we still have yet to receive them almost two months later. Only way we’ve made it by is help from family friends!
Must be so nice to be GOOP and just get to pretend while some of us are just barely getting by and skipping meals so my child can eat!
I’d love to shove those lemons straight up her pretentious butt!
I’d love to shove those lemons up her pretentious arse on your behalf. I hope things get better for you.
I hope things turn around for you soon.
Moec23, I feel for you because I went through a similar experience getting SNAP.
Here in California, I had to be very persistent, calling constantly even when no one answered the phone, asking to speak to anyone and everyone, complaining if necessary, going online and uploading whatever proof was needed. It also took me 6-8 weeks to get my benefits, and in that time, I continued visiting the local food pantry and otherwise asking family for money to buy food.
It’s humiliating enough to have to beg in this way just to get something so many people take for granted, but it also made me wonder about those who do not have their wits about them, so to speak, how do they wade through all of these hurdles?
You have be pretty sane, not easy when you’re actually REALLY starving, kind of a Catch-22 if you will.
ah i see she took lessons from Taylor Swift how to use feminism as a shield against valid criticism. seriously Goop, you cheating on something a lot people suffer through has NOTHING to do with equal pay. its just in the news right now and you are actually using that to deflect from being a terrible person.
You notice that too huh? lol.
@Kara – I agree.
Why did she go off on a “tangent” and admit to it when the criticism wasn’t about wage inequality? Deflection, like you said.
Per Moec23:
This is why it passes me off when people rant and rave about people mooching off public aid.
if they knew how abject poor you have to be to get any aid and how little you get they woukdnt spout off on such Republican sponsored foolishness
I got into it once with some Duck Dynasty fan on this topic. She was ranting about some people (im guessing she meant black) getting by on benefits but was complaining about how she couldn’t get benefits after she lost her job.
I asked if she was married and if her spouse had a kob. She said yes to both and then I rolled my eyes like “Duh?? Of course you didn’t get aid..you have a working spouse and no children. If you aren’t disabled or don’t have kids you have a 90 percent chance of being rejected for benefits. And to apply with a working spouse? Girl, bye!”
She was legit shocked that benefits were actually hard to get. Whoda thunk???
Shit..I was homeless once. HOMELESS. And I think at the time I was getting 125 in food stamps and zero welfare.
In an aside…it must have been some personal transformation for Brad to from being with women like Gwen and Jenn only to end up with Angelina. Like,, seriously.
Smh, so between Patricia Arquette schooling us on feminism and Goop introducing the issues of SNAP benefits for the first time the world is truly so much the better. I can see clearly now the rain is gone you guys.
No. She didn’t raise awareness. She didn’t use her platform to really talk and explore the issue. She posted a picture online and failed her publicity challenge. How does what she did translate into actually feeding children???
I’m seriously so mad I’m shaking. There are so many news articles about how children basically starve during Christmas break because they’re no longer provided school foods to subsidize their parents benefits and I’m supposed to pat this woman on the back for using their burden for Twitter points?
Fck her. She’ll never know or appreciate their suffering.
Totally agree with you. But I just can’t even with any celebrity now spewing out “words of wisdom” – whether it’s about poverty, feminism or parenting. I mean, come on, these people are total twats and the only thing they are concerned with is themselves. Period.
Yeah, I am on a celebrity gossip site, but I guess I only enjoy the celebrities when they are gussied up on the red carpet or being papped coming out of a Starbucks. It’s when they open their mouths and bloody pontificate about things they know nothing about (hello – Gwyneth and poverty) that I really feel the need to punch someone (read: the celebrity) in the throat.
+1
Everyone gets a gold star for trying. Yeah, no.
If kids are going hungry over Xmas then there bigger problem is bad parents over lack of money. I would sell everything I own, do anything, beg, before it would let my child go days without food.
Ok I know she is insufferable but she isn’t wrong. You can’t eat healthy with what we give people on snap, the program is a joke that ends up causing lasting health problems that cost more then if we just gave people the money they needed to buy healthy food.
The fact that there are hungry people in this country is deplorable.
When I read that Gwyneth was going to do this, I decided I would do the same. I knew she would fail, but I knew I could do it – having recalled my time back in the early 80’s when I got my first job and first apartment and could only allot myself $25 per week for food. I was able to do it, though granted (and this still remains the problem) – I didn’t eat the healthiest food.
So off I went to Publix last week with $29 cash in hand. Taking advantage of their usual BOGO sales, I was able to come up with a week’s worth of food. Of course, except for the salad bags, it was mainly processed food. Soups, mac n’ cheese, etc…. So one can definitely get by on $29 per week in food. But there is a price to be paid….unhealthful food. And THAT is the problem.
Everybody should be able to afford a healthy diet and she’s right that the food industry needs to be changed to allow that to be available to low income families. There’s no shame in admitting she failed, better than lying and pretending she did fantastically so no excuse for all those ‘poor people’.
She didn’t strike me as playing let’s pretend, rather she was making the point that $29 isn’t enough to feed a single person, let alone a family. Too many limes? Yes, but even if we exchanged them for something else, you *still* wouldn’t be able to feed your family on it. That is why, throughout the U.S., so many children rely on school breakfast and lunch programs to fill the gap, and why summer recess is hard for these kids.
I dunno Laurieh…you have to know how to shop
For instance yiu can get expensive spices dirt cheap at ethnic grocery stores. I can get a lb bag of cumin for 3 bucks at the Indian spot. A fraction of hat woukd be like 7 dollars at the grocery store.
I go to Asian, Indian or Hispanic stores and you can get like a 10 lb bag of rice dirt cheap. Under 10 bucks.
So for me..I’d have gone to an ethnic spot and gotten cheap rice. Then hit up Aldi’s for dry beans ( a 1 lb bag of dry beans makes 3 lbs of cooked beans and most are around a dollar) pinto, black, red kidney etc. I also would get the big 28 Oz cans of diced and crushed tomatoes..and bout .89 a can. Get a 5 lb bag of onions for a buck or 2. Get 3 bulbs of garlic for a dollar. Get a 3 lb log of ground beef for like 7 or 8 bucks.
so recap
Rice-8 bucks
2 bags dry beans-2.50
2 cans crushed tomatoes, diced tomato, I can of tomato paste-2.75
Onions-2 bucks
Garlic-1
Ground beef-8.
24 bucks spent with 5 leftover to by milk or juice or packets of Kool aid and sugar. And enough to make 2 batches of chili. Enough food for one person for maybe a week and a half.
Does the store accept SNAP? How far of a distance is it from you?
Cost of food is one part of the issue, I feel like someone with Gwyn’s money and time could have been thoroughly researched as to the many struggles people on SNAP benefits face.
Some of them don’t have adequate food storage, appliances, or refrigeration.
Many of them don’t have vehicles and can’t purchase more food than can be carried on public transportation.
Still others won’t have the time to really cook and plan multiple meals when they’re working and caring for a child.
Amy, exactly!
It’s not just about what you buy or where you shop but having access to these places and which stores accept SNAP. For those in low-income areas where they may only have convenience stores, processed foods are it.
And for those of us who walk everywhere, can’t afford car or even bus, I only buy what I can carry home. I live in a rent-controlled place in a decent area, but there aren’t inexpensive ethnic markets or bulk places like Costco.
So Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods are my options, good for fresh produce and bulk, but obviously I have to be very watchful of prices and buying what’s sustainable.
Otherwise, one might end up buying, oh, a bunch of limes.
and what you wrote write here does more for educating people than what she did and she HAS A TEAM helping her.
she could have easily taken the time, with her team, and come up with alternatives (not everyone is lucky enough to live in ethnically diverse areas with cheaper options for staples) in addition to your great suggestions, like maybe how to make the budget work when you only can cook once or twice a week, how to make the processed food choices healthier, a menu for seniors or folks that have mobility issues (can’t open jars and cans or chop etc)
there is a ton of stuff she could have done but didn’t bother to even try. she could have at the very least asked her readers to call and write their local reps and demand changes in current programs (or even that children out of school be feed during breaks) or how to get involved in meals on wheels or pantries, or where to donate money to.
Toody, i appreciate you taking the time to share options that work for budget conscious eating. there could be a reader in the celebitchy community this information will really help. i think you mentioned this the other day as well and you are awesome and goop is a lazy self-indulgent jerk that can’t be bothered to have her people do the work for her.
to me she really blew a great opportunity to help others and one that would have actually helped her image.
When I was broke I pretty much lived on chilli and pasta.
I if you know how and are willing to cook you can eat halfway decent even on a budget.
As long as I have beans rice and onion and garlic I know Im gonna eat well.
That’s beans and rice. That’s soup. That’s pasta fagioli. Bean burgers. That’s 4 dishes with those basic 4 ingredients as the base of the meal. The rest is seasonings.
I lived on chilli when I was broke and didn’t have a car. I’d take the bus to Aldi and would have a duffel bag on me in the days I planned to get heavy canned goods or a log of meat. Otherwise I’d have a backpack on me and load up.
I once lived in a rooming situation where I had a mini fridge, a microwave but no kitchen access.
I bought a crock pot and would cook at night. I only bought frozen food items when I planned to cook and consume them. I used the fridge to store beverages and sandwich meat. I’ve mastered making rice in a microwave.
“I once lived in a rooming situation where I had a mini fridge, a microwave but no kitchen access.
I bought a crock pot and would cook at night. I only bought frozen food items when I planned to cook and consume them. I used the fridge to store beverages and sandwich meat. I’ve mastered making rice in a microwave. ”
Same here. I lived in an efficiency that didn’t have a kitchen and came with a small refrigerator and the freezer shelf did little in the way of keeping frozen food frozen, so you can’t keep that stuff in the fridge for too long before it spoils. For the most part, I avoided buying too much frozen food.
I would purchase fruits and veggies, sometimes, but those would start to spoil if I didn’t eat them within a few days.
I had a rice cooker. I ended up eating lots of rice, sometimes noodles, and even beans. Oh, and peanut butter and jelly were in abundance.
My dead broke go to is always a block of frozen spinach, a can of tomatoes, ground beef, an onion, some garlic salt and pepper, and whatever starch is cheap. You can put it in rice, pasta, or even beans, just adjust the seasoning. It’s food. It’s not always what I want, but it’s healthy and gets me through. I bring it for lunch and save money that my coworkers are spending on Subway and Panera.
I used to make something similar I called Taco Soup. Leftovers would last for days, and it was fairly tasty and filling.
Black licorice? She’s despicable.
Could we get the mid eye-roll picture back? It’s the only way I can tolerate goop posts.
Have any of you heard of the Dr. Suess book “Marvin k Mooney will you please go now?” I want to substitute her name and send her this book.
Why isn’t she supporting he food bank on the regular? Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad she gave them money once, but I’m no millionaire and I give my local food bank regular donations of food and money. Surely if I can do it, she can.
She bought an unrealistic 1,000 calories per day diet. If you look at other people’s SNAP challenge purchases, you’ll see that they bought more food and calories, because they throughly and seriously thought out what a real person in a real life situation would need in order to last the week. Some of them included the chicken that Goop says she broke her challenge over but which she didn’t think to include in her own poverty tourism diet.
She wrote “As I suspected, we only made it through about four days…” Uh. Ok. So she knew she bought the wrong things in the first place but didn’t want to go through the effort of re-thinking what she should buy. Well, thanks for admitting that it was a half-assed try.
And then her article deals mostly with wage inequality to which she admits she’s going off on a tangent. Yes, wage inequality can be one reason why women would need food stamps, but… it would have been more to the point of the challenge itself if she had pushed her readers into trying to get Congress to increase the food stamp budget.
Typical her.
While I’m no fan of Gwynnie, I think her attitude is not unlike that of many people who really just don’t get it, and some of them are my friends and family. The next person who says they’re “starving” because they haven’t eaten in half-an-hour is gonna get punched.
For instance, I just read this today: http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/spendingandborrowing/12-ways-to-spend-less-on-food My immediate thought? No, duh!
It shocks me how much food people buy and waste, letting stuff rot in the ‘fridge, forgetting about takeout and leftovers. Even before I got benefits, this bothered me because I only ever buy what I know I’m going to eat, and I eat everything I buy. Always.
“It shocks me how much food people buy and waste, letting stuff rot in the ‘fridge, forgetting about takeout and leftovers. Even before I got benefits, this bothered me because I only ever buy what I know I’m going to eat, and I eat everything I buy. Always.”
We’re reading each other’s mind. I didn’t have a kitchen in my efficiency and the mini-fridge had a freezer shelf, which barely kept things frozen.
Like you, I couldn’t store too many things in the fridge because they wouldn’t last more than a couple of days.
I’d only purchase what I was going to eat.
Is everyone missing the point or am I?
OF COURSE Gwyneth didn’t make it on $29 of groceries to feed 3 people for a week. Did everyone actually think that was possible? In North America?!
Even going to a bulk store or Asian grocery and getting family size packs of whatever, I don’t know how this would be possible to do. Especially if you considered the need for fresh(-ish) fruits and vegetables a requirement. Yes, frozen is fine, but not canned.
Seriously. Who are you people? The last time I lived on ~$29/week in groceries, and all I ate for lunch was stoned wheat thins and water. Dinner was ramen. Sometimes with frozen spinach. Sometimes I had fruit. Sometimes I had soup. I was seriously undernourished and vitamin deficient.
That was also 25+ years ago. So yeah. Today? Feeding just myself with $29? 4 days sounds about right. (I think she was lying that it lasted that long. I say two days tops. 3 meals for 3 people every day for 4 days? Rly?!)
I’m not Gwyneth’s fan and I don’t read her Goop thing. But you folks are barking up the wrong tree.
Honestly. Where do all of you people live, where do you get your groceries, and how do you manage not to be malnourished for $29/week for an entire family?? Are you farmers? Because that’s the only thing that would remotely make sense.
It’s $29 per person. Not for an entire family.
“The last time I lived on ~$29/week in groceries, and all I ate for lunch was stoned wheat thins and water. Dinner was ramen. Sometimes with frozen spinach. Sometimes I had fruit. Sometimes I had soup. I was seriously undernourished and vitamin deficient.”
Were you me? Seriously. This was not that long ago for me. For a while, I was undernourished too. I was doing the ramen diet, but then I veered off into rice and beans territory. Oh, and PB&J sandwiches.
As a single woman (with no kids), can easily spend between $30-40 a week on groceries. Sometimes closer to $25. It depends on what I need to replenish and what’s on sale.
For a while, I used SNAP benefits, in addition to what leftover discretionary funds I had.
Why would ANYBODY buy all those limes for a weeks worth of food? They are really expensive now. What a joke Goop is.
Thank you. It’s illogical. I get all the other choices…but seven limes? It’s not even that versatile. You could season salsa and use it as a salad garnish/dressing with what…two? Three?
I don’t understand all of it…but the crazy limes sends me over in a barrel.
I can’t shade her too much for this part of it. Yes, her food choices were ridiculous and pretentious, failing after four days did bring up a valid point about how the people who really do live like that don’t have the luxury of throwing in the towel and going to buy some licorice. Her write up does make some good points.
V
Very few are TRUE HUMANITARIAN’S and not just publicly seekers. And yes her children are vey blessed to her high end food. I hope she along with many privileged families teaching their children values.
Life has many twists and turns many ups and downs, we don’t know what tomorrow may bring.