Soon after Scarlett Johansson and Ryan Reynolds split up, and a few months before Justin Timberlake and Jessica Biel split, there was a rumor going around the tabloids that Scarlett and Justin were hooking up on the downlow. This was back in January, although Scar and JT were rumored to be in some kind of casual hookup situation back in 2007, before she got with Ryan and before JT got with Biel. While I think Scarlett could do better, she doesn’t listen to me, and JT might still be good for the occasional night out. According to Page Six, that’s exactly what went down:

Scarlett Johansson didn’t seem to be mourning her split with Sean Penn during a late night out with Justin Timberlake. The pair headed to Kenmare and partied until 3:30 a.m. yesterday along with Bungalow 8 nightlife queen Amy Sacco and a few other friends.

While Johansson and Timberlake — who split with Jessica Biel in March — have been linked in the past, a spy said, “It didn’t look particularly flirty. Scarlett was dressed down and remained low-key with Justin and the group. At one point she went over to the deejay to request a song. Later, two girls joined them. They all left together around 3:30.”

[From Page Six]

“Later, two girls joined them. They all left together around 3:30.” That made me think they were going to have an orgy/foursome. Wait, are foursomes considered orgies? I forget. Anyway, I’ll buy this. I think that when Scarlett is single, she just hangs out with dudes who she’s already boned, or who maybe want to bone her. She doesn’t seem to have a lot of girlfriends, and maybe she’s just one of those chicks who seem more comfortable with men. So, are Scarlett and JT actually hittin’ it? Meh. It seems rather drama-free now, given that they’re both single.

I love this video so much for the terrible, awful acting from both of them. It’s so bad, it’s hilarious. Plus, it’s a good song.

Screencaps from JT’s “What Goes Around” video featuring Scarlett, plus additional photos by Fame.