A few weeks ago, Katherine Heigl embarked upon a celebrity blog for iVillage with a rather frank essay on her struggles to identify both as a mother and an actress as well as why she prefers being a working mother. It was a pretty coherent and rather lucid essay, in which Heigl resisted the temptation of appearing preachy towards mothers who either elect to stay at hom with their children or have no choice whether or not to work. Yeah, Heigl’s got a nanny to help her out with the technicalities and early morning risings that motherhood demands; yet she was quick to point out that while her decision to continue acting (in crappy romcoms) might make her feel like a better mother, she understood that it’s not the best thing for every mother. She won many of you over with her thoughts, and I started to like her more too.
This week, Katherine tackles what I feel is an even touchier subject by giving her thoughts on marriage. Of course, she’s only been married to Josh Kelley for four years, but her thoughts are still relevant to the subject. It’s a rather lengthy essay, so I cut out some of the anthropological details about a South American civilization (which allows for four annual days of hedonism and adultery) that Katherine uses as an illustration how other cultures seek to prevent divorce. Basically, she takes a very monogamous stance on that example and then goes on to describe the difficulties she’s already experienced in her marriage:
Josh and I were recently asked at the American Music Awards how we make our marriage work in Hollywood. We answered the best we could but when the interview went live, we suddenly found ourselves to be the poster couple for successful marriages. My first thought was, “That’s a hell of a lot of pressure. We better make this work!” My second thought was, “What is my real answer to that question once given an opportunity to think about it?” The topic of relationships with a partner or spouse is a pretty relatable one, and it’s something people have been trying to figure out since the beginning of time.
I have no desire to physically hook up with any man other than my husband and have been a serial monogamist from the moment of my first serious relationship at 20. I have never been able to connect with a man sexually without it becoming emotional, without giving a piece of my heart and soul to that connection. I always loved the idea of Samantha on Sex and the City, but it just isn’t how I’m built. I understand that every human being on earth wonders if the grass might be greener in other pastures, but I could never imagine myself really going there or really wanting to. I guess the relationship I’m in is so consuming that the idea of a dalliance with another man sounds exhausting. It’s hard enough to make one connection work — I can’t imagine, even for four days, splitting myself between two!
What I took away from the story of the village was the idea of not taking your partner for granted. We all do and will throughout the course of our lives with each other — after all, that’s just human nature. But I wonder if being aware of it can help me to do it less. I very easily slip into negative patterns of nagging, bossing, frustration and miscommunication. Josh easily slips into negative patterns of not paying attention, work consumption, forgetfulness and miscommunication. When we start orbiting around each other in this way, it’s pretty easy to forget what the gravitational pull was that brought our planets into alignment was in the first place.
I’ve certainly had moments, as I’m sure Josh has, where I’ve asked myself if it’s really worth it. Is a great marriage really even possible? Do you just resign yourself to the idea of growing old with someone you don’t talk to anymore, share anything with but your children, and avoid like the plague? Yes, the giddy romance of first love fades but does love itself just wither away as if it’s a season coming to an end?
It would be preachy and naïve of me to tell you I have the answers to those questions. Josh and I have only been married four years and though that may seem record-breaking in Hollywood, we’re still considered newlyweds to the rest of the world. What I can tell you is that I was infatuated with this man the moment I met him. I was crazy about him three weeks later, and madly in love with him two more after that. More often than not he brings the best out of me and when he doesn’t, I tell him the truth about how he’s let me down and listen when he tells me the same. He makes me laugh like no one else, he makes me feel safer than I’ve ever felt, adored with abandon and when he doesn’t, I tell him how I feel ignored and listen when he tells me I’ve driven him away.
I have been drawn to this man like a bee to honey and I can’t quite explain it but I do know he’s worth it. We stand by each other, we respect each other’s thoughts, ideas, passions and fears. We compromise constantly for each other and change for each other when compromising isn’t the answer. We’ve had some pretty explosive fights over the years trying to make our marriage work, but it’s been worth it.
[From iVillage]
Okay, it’s really easy to read Katherine’s thoughts on marital squabbles as well as losing the initial butterflies of early relationship bliss and conclude that she must certainly be on her way to a split. Yet I don’t think that’s the case, for it sounds like she and Josh have figured out how to balance their differences and learn to communicate, which is generally be a neverending struggle for any couple whether they’re willing to accept the challenge or not.
I also truly appreciate that Katherine admits that her marriage isn’t without flaws. Once again, she’s not Gooping it up by claiming to be perfect and she’s not actively avoiding the issue like Sarah Jessica Parker (and her “splitting the atom of our marriage” talk) does. Instead, Katherine sounds like a real woman here, and Josh (from the outside anyway) seems like a pretty good husband to Katherine. They enjoy regular outings together, there are no whisperings of him cheating on her, and he seems to be really good at carrying her luggage and pushing a grocery cart. On that last point, I’m completely not knocking the guy either. My husband never did that.
Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet
she’s smart and mature.
like her more now.
seems grounded.
sexy.
sounds like to me she understand what marriage is about. seems pretty normal and grounded to me. I agree with just about everything she said about marriage.
word.
me too.
Those are the only five pictures of Heigl that I’ve ever seen that don’t include her mother.
Holy hell, she’s human.
Am rooting for them
A good marriage is possible but not if you’re a spoiled, narcissistic, “Me first” type person. Also, you can’t always get your way in marriage…that’s why it is traditionally reserved for responsible adults who understand that they are making a serious committment to another person, for life, in good and bad times. I have a good, and happy marriage. I am the female half of that couple that is always hanging off of each other, making people want to puke with their PDAs and true love nonsense. So trust me it is possible. It’s not perfect and never will be but if you put someone else before you, and they put you before themselves, you can have a good marriage. (There is more to it than this, but I don’t think anyone would be receptive to it…however this is a good place to start)
Nobody ever wants to hear about your happy relationship. Believe me because I’ve been in one for a long time and I know how little anyone wants to hear me talk about it.
*sigh* Ain’t it the truth.
SO MUCH WORD to all three of you. I have gotten to the point where I can’t even give advice to certain girlfriends anymore-they are more invested in the drama and BS that they create while attempting to “find an awesome relationship like yours!!” but never, EVER, want to hear about how to establish and/or maintain a healthy relationship “like mine.”
It’s rather infuriating, and it’s nice to know it’s not just me!
I must comment on this – it is true! I used to try and try to explain that this (love) doesnt come naturally, that this takes work, but nowadays I just keep my mouth shut. People just need validation and nothing more.
agreed. *like*
Hope they make it for many more years.
I feel like she’s on a mission for me to like her more. It’s working. Meh.
never did that? or currently doesn’t?
They seem really committed to making their marriage work, wish them the best.
She seems really self aware and likeable here.
She hit it on the nail. When I met my second husband, I never wanted to forget how unhappy I was in the first or how alone I could feel in other relationships. I really prayed that I would never lose the gratefulness (not in a needy way) of finding him, not just because I love him but because I really enjoy and he enjoys being together. My vows to myself were I wanted to always feel gratitude for this relationship, and hoped I didn’t let that slip away, and be that couple that still holds hands five, ten, fifteen years down the road. Many couples seem disconnected physically and emotionally and only about the kids as their connection anymore. So on the few days I hate him or I’m irritated, I just think, well, he’s mine to hate and smile to myself. The key is to pick your battles and still think like a girlfriend sometimes, not a wife. But as a woman I can only do that because he respects me and I feel needed and loved. I never felt that in my first marriage and it showed in the way I treated him back.
Where’s her mom? I’m concerned. I have never seen any picture of Heigl without her. What’s going on??!! And as I say everytime: poor Josh.
I think this is another misleading headline–she’s not suggesting that a great marriage is not possible, as the headline implies. She’s saying that as she has experienced the ups and downs of hers, she’s asked herself a number of questions, including that one.
Maybe Heigl should only give written answers to interviews. This is quite thoughtful and respectful–of herself, her husband, their relationship, and other people. That’s not the impression I had of her up until a few weeks ago.
I don’t trust couples that don’t squabble. I don’t even see how that’s possible. Marriage is not always sunshine and roses. A lot of times it is hating the other person’s face. It’s how you deal with those feelings and move beyond them and start seeing the person you fell in love with again. It’s called real intimacy, real love, real commitment, real compromise, even when you do hate their face – because deep down you know you don’t, you are just being asked to grow as a person. It takes constant work. She seems like she knows that and is willing to put in the work.
Sorry, but I’m on to year 12 of a great marriage, and while you may not trust us, we do not fight and I have never hated his face. On the contrary, I adore his face, always have, always will. Some couples agree on a lot of things, and agree to disagree on some others without feeling the need to fight about them or convince the other that we are right. It may not be as dramatic as those who feel the constant need for issues and to convince others that marriage is really hard work, but there it is. There are lots of us out there happily living our lives and not feeling the need to fall in and out of love with out partners. We fell in and we’re staying there whether you find it suspicious or not.
Nearly eight years in, and I have yet to experience what you’re describing. Am I sometimes frustrated or annoyed? Sure, but that’s not “hating someone’s face.”
Then again, our relationship is based on respect, appreciation, and communication. It’s surprising how little that feels like work, I guess.
I have always liked her…not just for being true to herself, but also for being honest and open with others.
I think the key to a good marriage is the platform – both people have to go into it with the mindset that they are totally and utterly committed to making it. It helps to have warm, fuzzy, loving, sexual feelings, etc…But at the end of the day, you need to be in agreement that you are there to work together. I don’t mean to sound totally unromantic, but there is a “work” aspect to any long term relationship.
When my husband decides on something, I usually agree and am up for whatever it is he wants to do. That’s a good way to get along, to co-operate, to compromise, think his idea is a good one, not criticize it. If you really don’t like it, just make other suggestions and alternatives without condemning his idea. Also, don’t sweat the small stuff. That is key, very important. Just let it go and you will be glad you did.
Great essay. She seems to have the pulse on what makes their marriage work. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again COMMUNICATION is the key.
Speaking as one married seven years with some very rocky periods in between.
This is the best publicity she has in years. I think she wrote a nice little piece. I liked the end where she sounds like she genuinely loves her husband. I read read a recent article she did for some parenting magazine I saw on another blog. She sounds real and humble. I love her – I even loved her when she was bitchy, though to a lesser degree.
I’ve always said that marriage isn’t easy, but it’s not supposed to be that hard.
If more people had more realistic expectations of marriage and were willing to compromise more often, the divorce rates wouldn’t be so high.
It sounds like she and Josh have a very mature and thoughtful approach to their relationship, which should stand them in good stead over the long haul.
wow, reading her essay actually made me like her a lot more, or hate her a lot less? whichever applies
I’ve always thought she was quite bright and that it simply didn’t come across well in soundbites and in our 1950s hangover of women-must-be-quiet-and-grateful-at-all-times.
Her essays are thoughtful and well-written, personal without being tawdry.
Now if only she would emancipate herself from her third-wheel momager.
So many people go into marriage with the thought that they’ll just divorce if it doesn’t work out. The essense of commitment is to actually be, well, committed to making a marriage work, not just bail out the first time they become bored or restless. It’s normal for feelings to change throughout the years, but what I’ve learned is that hanging in there through the rough times makes the good times all that much sweeter. It saddens me that so many people bail on their marriages after a couple of years when the shiny newness wears off. They will likely never experience the depth of a true, committed marriage.
And any couple that claims they never argue or fight, that simply means that one of you is habitually submitting to the other in order to keep the peace. I feel sorry for couples who claim to never fight because I know what that means, and it’s never good. In fact, the two couples I personally know that “never fight” are both miserable; one is a very long term marriage (more than 25 years) that just separated, and the other is a live in couple of about 20 years that never “argue or fight,” but both are admittedly miserable and feel trapped in their relationship.
What intrigues me the most about her post is the bit about instant infatuation/ very quickly being madly in love. I’m still dealing w a breakup of a seven year relationship (we never made it to marriage), it still feels absolutely excruciating to me, and ive been doing a lot of thinking. With him, and in fact w my relationships before him, there wasnt that instantaneous attraction for me… In every case the guy had to kind of work on me for a while, in the latter case 3 years (the part that we lived in difft countries countries may have contributed to that) and then i eventually realized/ became attracted/ fell really in love… Now im starting to wonder if it means something that ive actually never had that instant ‘ you just know’ thing. Man, is that the kind of knock-down connection it takes to find a true life partner?? I actually always thought that w my last guy, (god it hurts to write that, i still love him so much) it was a really good thing that we had time for things to develop slowly, sorta simmer- at least for me- but maybe the fact that i wasnt immediately blown out of my socks points to what now seems could be just some inherent incompatibilty…? Happily marrieds, i -do- want to know what you think. Did you all know pretty qui kly that he was ‘the one’? ?