Did Emma Stone dump Andrew Garfield after he cheated on her in Taiwan?

FFN_Garfield_Stone_FILE_040815_51704814

By now we know that Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone are over. The tabloids have been saying they’re over for weeks, although the first whiff of a breakup was back in February, when Emma was nominated for an Oscar and Andrew Garfield was nowhere to be seen. Us Weekly claimed this week that Emma did the dumping, and she was over Andrew’s whole dark, tortured artist routine. She wanted to be with someone who could be a “better partner.” It’s worth noting that Star Magazine got the ball rolling on the whole breakup story, so maybe Star has some inside information somewhere. You never know. In this week’s Star, sources claim that yes, Emma dumped Andrew and for good reason – because he cheated on her.

“Andrew cheated on Emma with a girl in Taiwan, where he is shooting Martin Scorsese’s new movie,” reveals a source close to the couple. “He confessed to Emma and she was horrified. She broke up with him right away.”

The couple had been going through a rough patch for a while. With Andrew thousands of miles away, it had been harder for them to communicate. And within the past month, the source says, “Emma noticed that Andrew was acting different – more distant.” When she asked him what was wrong, he tried to come up with excuses. “At first, he blamed all his stress on filming the movie, but then he broke down.”

Andrew told Emma that he’d had a one-night stand with a girl he’d met at a bar. “Emma was shocked…she can’t trust him anymore. She is starting to think that there may have been other girls too. She never thought that Andrew would do this to her and now she feels like she never really knew him.”

Meanwhile, Andrew is even angrier at himself than Emma is.

“He made such a big mistake,” says the source, who reveals Andrew has been ‘drunk dialing’ Emma and begging for another chance. “Andrew’s inconsolable… Emma loves him, but she’s standing film. She thinks that the fact he cheated just shows how much they needed a break.”

[From Star Magazine, print edition]

Well, that’s one explanation for why there were sudden breakup confirmations all over the place. Emma and her people did the confirming, because she’s DONE with his cheating ass. Who cheats on Emma? For goodness sake.

So, who will her next boyfriend be? She’s got Aloha coming out in May, and I could totally see some “rumors” being spread about Emma and her costar Bradley Cooper, much like those old rumors about Booty Shorts and Jennifer Lawrence, which were strategically deployed for the publicity tours together. I could also see Emma being connected – briefly – with her costar Joaquin Phoenix. They worked together on Woody Allen’s Irrational Man, which will be at Cannes this year. I remember those set photos too – either Joaquin is an amazing actor (he is, for all his faults) or he was genuinely into Emma during filming. Some people have also suggested Emma with Tom Hiddleston. That would be PERFECTION. Seriously, I would love that. Hiddles needs a high-profile girlfriend for a little while, just for fun and to help him get his name out there ahead of what might be a big awards-season push.

FFN_Stone_Phoenix_RM_exc_081214_51500805

Photos courtesy of Fame/Flynet.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

136 Responses to “Did Emma Stone dump Andrew Garfield after he cheated on her in Taiwan?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Kiddo says:

    That’s as good of a reason as any.

  2. serena says:

    Please not Bradley Cooper!

    • GlimmerBunny says:

      Agreed. I’m even skeeved out by the Aloha trailer because they look so mismatched age-wise, he looks much better with Rachel McAdams.

      I liked Emma and Andrew together but if they truly are over her and Hiddles would definitely be cute.

      • Doris says:

        I thought I was the only one who thought the Aloha trailer looked skeevy. Everyone was raving about the Bradley & Emma pairing but it made me uncomfortable

      • VirgiliaCoriolanus says:

        You actually made it through the whole trailer? I thought it was horrible. I think I made it a minute in…..Cooper is ruining the goodwill I had for him from “American Sniper”…..

  3. MelissaManifesto says:

    Is never really about the schedule, is it?

    Hope she finds someone who is worthy of her.

  4. unmade_bed says:

    I wish I looked like her in a pair of shorts.

  5. Hannah says:

    Not hiddles, he’s too cheesy and earnest for someone as dry and sarcastic as Emma.

  6. Hannah says:

    Can someone tell me what brand her blazer in the top picture is?

  7. Kittenplant says:

    See? I knew he sucked all along.

    Eat it, Mark!

    • FLORC says:

      3 Questions Kitten…
      Who’s Mark?
      Did one of your adorable kittens eat a plant?
      And how did you change your name? I’ve tried renaming here as Fat With Cats since someone made the comment, but it never even posts.

      • eggplanthoKiddo says:

        FLORC, Mark is the guy who shows up and tells us how much we suck and then promptly leaves. He’s kind of fun and a hunk. I think he has a lil’ somethin’ going for the O’kitt.

      • FLORC says:

        Oh THAT mark. Haha yea.

      • Kitten says:

        FLORC-You should be able to type right over your name. That’s what I do, and leave my email address obviously.

        Mark is usually busy protecting men folk from crazy broads like mimif.
        But I’m excited that he’s gracing us with his presence today. It must be a holiday…somewhere..

    • mark says:

      I’ve never said anything about how great he is just that if a guy was talking about how they want to punch emma stone this site would be going crazy.

      Other than that I don’t really care I really like Emma Stone and hope she wins loads of oscars but this story is fake, if he’s so into the acting why would he be getting plastered at a bars, wouldn’t he be in the ‘zone’.

      • nikkisixx says:

        A lot of the stuff you say I don’t agree with, but I will say this. I agree with you to an extent about how there is a certain herd mentality about hated (and loved) celebs on here.

      • Kitten says:

        You were all upset over the fact that everyone was siding with Emma and blaming Garfield for the break-up. Looks like it may have been his fault after all.
        So there, I told you so, etc.

      • Mandy says:

        I can see him in the zone for sure, that’s why I don’t believe this story at all

      • Jonathan says:

        Mark, you need only have come back with something like “Bruisable Eye” Emma, not by, you know, appealing to common sense or equality or other such unbelievable, unheard of science fiction concepts.

  8. Abbott says:

    I know I was on the Hiddles train yesterday but what about Hozier?

    And I’d sign off on these three if they ever get out of their long term relationships: Hunnam, Chadwick Boseman, Gary Clarke Jr.

  9. Mika says:

    I know this is not the right site to discuss this but her alleged circumstance is too similar to mine. We’re in a long distance relationship,bf had a one night stand while he was drunk and he tearfully confessed about it the next morning. I dumped him at first. But after much discussion, i was back with him. I hate him for what he had done but I love him and I don’t want to be alone. But every night after that I was haunted by this image of him being with another woman. And I often questioned myself a lot. Why am I so weak? Why am I not strong enough to leave him?

    I am inexperienced about relationships,I’m only 20 and I dont have anyone to talk to about this..sorry for the ramblings. Just wanted to get it off my chest.

    • Dani says:

      You’re not weak. You’re young and in love and things happen. If you could live with it and move on than do what you want. But don’t stay with him just because you can’t bare the thought of being alone. It’s okay to be on your own. You’re still so young, you have your whole life ahead of you girl!

      • Mika says:

        Thanks for the kind words, Dani. My state of hopelessness sometimes made me forget that I still have a long journey ahead of me 🙂

    • Esmom says:

      So sorry you’re going through that. I was in a similar relationship back when I was your age and my teenage son and I were talking about it just yesterday. He said he couldn’t understand why I wouldn’t just dump the guy when he cheated on me and I said it was more complicated than that. He said something like “no, it’s not complicated, he treated you badly and didn’t deserve you.”

      And he was right. No one deserves to be treated badly. I totally understand not wanting to be alone but I promise you won’t be alone forever. It’s scary as hell to leave a familiar, comfortable situation. But sticking around only to have doubt and anger eat away at you is so incredibly unhealthy. I think you recognize that and if you take some time away from this relationship — even if it’s temporary to figure out what you really want — you will probably find you are much stronger than you think. Best of luck!

      • Mika says:

        Yes I probably do need a break from this relationship. It’s eating me from inside out, no doubt.. I’ll just have to think about it. Thank you for your encouragement, your son is so lucky to have a great mom like you 🙂

    • Abbott says:

      Sorry you’re going through this. I had something similar happen in college and even though I took him back, I never got over it. It was like a one year relationship and a three year break up.

      You’ll do what’s best for you. But, there are a lot of mediocre things in life, love shouldn’t be one of them.

    • Nev says:

      Your 20?!!!!!
      If you continue to be haunted by this break it off. You have your entire life ahead….

      • Mika says:

        It would have been easier if he was a straight-up abusive partner or a serial cheater or something but that one night stand was his only downfall and even he was deeply affected (by his guilt) which made me contemplate on leaving him. Ugh I sound like I’m making excuses to not leave him but that’s what I see. Thanks for the support Nev

    • Francesca says:

      It might help to consider the whole relationship. Is it generally healthy? Are there communication issues? What really led him to break your trust like that? I might be in the minority, but i do not believe cheating is always a deal breaker. Sometimes it is a symptom, an ugly awful one, of a bigger problem, that if identified, could be addressed and you could end up a lot stronger as a couple because of it. Good luck and be kind to yourself!

      • Mika says:

        We were just fine before that happened. We were best friends. We shared everything even though we often spend months apart from each other. That one night stand was his only downfall and I wish I can just forgive him and move on and erase it from my mind but from then on, as long as we were apart, the memory of it is ALWAYS there, clinging to my brain like a parasite. I wanted and tried to blame it on the alcohol but he insisted that it was his fault, that yes he was a drunk mess at the time but he ‘knew’ what he was doing, and only after halfway that he realized what he had done and he immediately backed out.
        I did felt like we were a stronger couple after that but the fact that there are days where I slip into depression after reading these sorts of stories, and that I spend many nights crying my lungs out just at the thought of it just shows how weak I am.

      • KB says:

        You crying doesn’t show how weak you are, it’s like your subconscious is trying to make you accept the truth! It sounds like you’ve been miserable. I think you know what you need to do and are just mourning the end of something that was once great. Maybe you should just take some time away to get some perspective.

      • PennyLane says:

        Part of growing up is learning about yourself and what sort of person you are. Some people can deal with being cheated on, and other people simply cannot deal with it.

        I had to learn about this myself and I learned about it the hard way. The painful part was this: two years after I took him back, he cheated on me again. I felt (and still feel) like I wasted two years of my life because I was exactly the same as you – extremely broken up about the betrayal and feeling like things were never the same again, but trying to salvage things and move forward nonetheless.

        I don’t know you personally, but from your statements it sounds like you are the sort of person who cannot deal with being cheated on. You need to be true to yourself! Life is for learning, and it sounds like you have learned that you are not someone who can handle sexual betrayal in a relationship.

        It is OKAY that that is who you are – please please please don’t try to be someone you’re not and pretend that you can leave it in the past and move on when you can’t, as that will only cause pain.

        Also? If your relationship was good and he cheated anyways, there is an excellent chance that even though your relationship in the future is good, he will cheat on you again. It sounds like the motivations for his cheating come from inside him rather than arising from the dynamic between the two of you, and those kinds of people are far more likely to cheat again. In a real sense you have nothing to do with his cheating, so all you can do is decide whether this is something you can put up with.

    • Ana says:

      You answered yourself on why you are not able to leave: “I don’t want to be alone” Which is also the worst reason for getting into or staying in a relationship.

      It’s harsh and your young. But if this is causing you serious emotional distress then even no matter how much you love him it would be better to break up. If you feel you won’t be able to put the cheating behind completely.

      Good luck! Lots of strength to you!

      • Mika says:

        Thank you for the support, Ana. It’s nice to have all these advice from all you great ladies on CB. I’m glad I posted my original comment. I feel much better now.

    • Wren33 says:

      That is so hard. I definitely think that a one-time one night stand is forgivable, but unfortunately it can still poison and doom a relationship. I have had guys cheat on me, and it always ends up exploding. I think you can forgive a person and realize they are human, but also recognize that continuing in the relationship is harmful to your self-esteem and you need a break. Those images really are like parasites on the brain.

    • Denise says:

      Mika, don’t beat yourself up. No matter how old, experienced and sure of ourselves we may be, love is a beast that makes us do crazy things. You’ll find the strength to leave when you’re ready. Keep reminding yourself that you deserve the best.

      Love your avi – that movie still makes me snort with laughter. ALVA!!

    • Cheryl says:

      It sounds like a sad troubling time. But, I think jump into being alone. Learn how to be alone. You will never regret having that card up your sleeve and that experience worked through. The universe is giving you a great opportunity.

    • Egla says:

      Been there. Usually it’s more than just one night stand and makes you question IF it was more then that. Before the action is the thought. Going out, drinking, flirting taking someone back to your place to have sex takes some thought and time to act. During all that he didn’t think of you BUT after that he felt guilty???
      I had my sweetheart boyfriend cheating on me because (his words) we had a hard time and he wanted to take his revenge on me for the fights BUT after that he felt sooo sorry. He even cried telling me that. The only difference was that i smelled something wasn’t right so he had to confess. Anyway i took him back for old times sake. It lasted a month during which i made his life and mine hell. I asked him to remain friends, it was hard but we survived. Oh and we were at the same class for 5 years. We use to see each other every day. So no it wasn’t easy. We were used to each other, we knew everything, we understood our moods so it was hard to not have each other like before but i felt so free and it felt so right. It was bad for 3 days after the breakup, the forth it was all good and i wasn’t crying anymore. So i knew it was right.
      Do what you feel is the right thing for you but don’t be unhappy because you might feel alone in the future. I was 20 when it happened to me. Now i am 34. Never felt alone for more then a day or two. I had friends and family and i was in peace with myself.
      Good luck and be strong. Either way make the cheater PAY

  10. Lama Bean says:

    Isn’t Joaquin dating a 19 year old or 12 year old or something?

    And I wish Bradley would just give it up. I swear I’m starting to believe the rumors that he is closeted.

    Emma Stone seems like a really cool person.

  11. merski says:

    Once a cheater always a cheater, eh? Depressing.

  12. FLORC says:

    Star will forever be as credible as a Blind Item. They didn’t break the news of the break up. They were just the 1st to print it while others said it was likely over, but wanted the facts. Star is forever a shot in the dark that may at some point hit something.
    If he cheated he’s a fool.
    If he valued getting into character over being there for her as a partner does. he’s a fool.
    It’s about priorities in relationships. I wonder if he thought she’d always be there no matter how he acted?
    Whatever the reason they’re done. She was dating below her level and will be just fine.

    • Carey says:

      Until People or E! confirm the breakup (which they haven’t) I’m not believing anything. Star Mag is so hit and miss

      • Nathan34 says:

        I did notice People hasn’t changed their initial story, even after the US weekly insider claims, so there’s still hope

      • Mia says:

        People & Eonline and yep, even TMZ > Us Weekly so yep, I think i’ll wait for a more credible source. The only thing US weekly is good for is C-list scoops from The Bachelor, Real Housewives, Dancing with the Stars, etc… b/c those C-listers run to them for publicity but they rarely score any of the real good stuff

    • Kara says:

      i also dont buy this story. i guess they broke up but i doubt if anyone would have inside info Star would know. they would have sold it to the big mags.

      • Mandy says:

        Exactly, a huge scoop like this you wouldn’t shop it to the lowest of the low tab out there, OK Magazine. People here seem to confirm that it wasn’t Star who ran this article, it was actually OK Mag.

  13. Farah says:

    didn’t Emma and Andrew’s relationship start sketchy too? They were both in relationships, double dating, while shooting the first spiderman. By the end of shooting, Andrew and Emma had broken up with their respective partners, and were all over each other.

    • JB says:

      And didn’t she once tweet a bunch of weird stuff about Andrew and Shailene Woodley sittin in a tree and then delete it and then say her account was hacked and none of it ever actually came from her?

    • Claudia says:

      Exactly! He had been with Shannon Woodward for years and I’m pretty sure there was some overlap. What goes around, comes around, Emma.

  14. notlistening says:

    If he cheats with you, he´s gonna cheat on you….

  15. INeedANap says:

    Why does she keep doing romantic movies with men who are way too old for her? Colin Firth, Joaquin Phoenix, Bradley Cooper…

    • Heather says:

      It’s gross

    • Renee says:

      I love Emma but that’s the one thing I can’t get over. I can forgive her for working with Woody Allen once, but twice? C’mon…. Magic in the Moonlight wasn’t even that good, actually it was awful. I have no idea why she agreed to work with him again so soon

      • Trina says:

        Magic in the Moonlight was awful. I fell asleep three times, and I still haven’t finished it!

      • Nathan34 says:

        Magic in the Moonlight was a pile of crap. Why Emma is working with him again after that disaster of a movie is beyond me, thought she had better taste. The plot line to Irrational Man w Joaquin sounds just as awful.

      • Mandy says:

        Thanks for the heads up, I guess I won’t be watching this movie!

      • Mia says:

        I love Emma but can’t defend her on this one. She should know better. One movie, ok, I can forgive…but TWICE?!!!

    • Mandy says:

      It’s not like she doesn’t have options, I’m sure she has her pick of good scripts too

      • Doris says:

        It is disapppointing. Hopefully this will be the last time she works with Woody Allen. There are so many great directors out there, I don’t know why she keep going back to him.

    • Feebee says:

      Ha ha ha ha ha ha OMG that’s hilarious. I’m not laughing at you, just that isn’t this problem one of the biggest regularly bitched about…. Middle aged men cast with 20 something love interests? Yeah but Emma should find a romcom with the male lead who’s a similar age.

  16. Renee says:

    It is from OK! Magazine, not Star. Everyone knows OK! magazine just makes up everything. Feel bad for Andrew because people actually believe this garbage

    • Nathan34 says:

      But, but, but it’s on the INTERNET, so it MUST be true. People are stupid sometimes

    • Kara says:

      its crazy that people can make money with libel.

    • Mandy says:

      It’s crazy that sites like Ok Magazine have a “submit scoop” page on their site and they don’t even ask for your email or contact info, all you have to do is write a BS story and they’ll print. Pretty sad.

    • Doris says:

      I hope they can work out it out. They seem like good people and seem well matched. They were one of my favorite young hollywood couples. I wish them well.

    • Mia says:

      Ok magazine suuuuuucks. Pure fiction. I think Gawker did a study on all the tabs over a two year period, checking stories they printed and seeing if they were true years later and OK Magazine came in dead last with like 2% accuracy

  17. Heather says:

    Sorry, this story is pure BS. And yes, it’s from OK Magazine (not Star) which is widely known to post fan fiction. Garfield is filming a movie about priests, he ain’t filming the Wolf of Wall Street. In the past 4 years since I’ve been following his career, I don’t think there’s ever been a sighting at a bar. I don’t even think he drinks. And now suddenly he’s getting plastered in bars in Taiwan picking up chicks? There were recent photos of him on a Taiwanese news site, he HAS lost a lot of weight for the role, he looked gaunt & unwell, totally unrecognizable and he was papped going to a hospital. He takes his acting very seriously and I can believe that his method acting took a toll on his relationship but this story is BS. Hard to believe this story unless he got a personality transplant.

    • Carey says:

      Yeah, I don’t believe this. So out of character. I am worried about him though, hope filming finishes soon. I think they have two more weeks? It’s been filming FOREVER

    • Renee says:

      Garfield is hardly a party animal so I have a hard time seeing him getting sloshed at bars hooking up with random chicks. He’s never had that rep.

    • jocelyn says:

      he may not be a party animal, but nobody spends months without having sex, it’s got to be something, I don’t believe that actors in particular, that are needy emotional messes, could go on for months and month without, ahem…releasing the tension, if you know what a mean. Plus, it’s a mostly male cast…in TAIWAN…so I totally believe that in addition to the method-y crap (excuses) he also had his share of other women.

      • Melanie says:

        Nobody goes months without having sex? I’m pretty sure there are people, even actors, who are not into hooking up with random people. Anyway, I agree with those who think this story sounds fake. I mean, consider the source.

      • Misha says:

        Exactly. If we go with that “no one can go months w/o having sex logic”, that means Emma must’ve cheated on him as well.

      • Josa says:

        “Nobody goes months without having sex? ”
        Huh? logic got bended to fit the narrative.

      • Ange says:

        Sweet. Next deployment my husband has I’ll be sure to let him know we both get a hall pass because it’s biologically impossible to go without – or god forbid sort yourself out.

  18. Samtha says:

    Maybe she read the hacked Sony emails about what happened with Andrew and Batkid. 🙁

    • Jedi says:

      oh no, did the emails confirm he actually was a jerk to poor batkid? That whole story was making me side eye him ages ago…who bails on a kid with cancer?

      • Samtha says:

        It confirmed that he tried to rewrite the script and then when they wouldn’t use his version (which, according to the guy emailing Pascal, didn’t make sense), he bailed.

        There are quite a few emails detailing the back-and-forth talks between Sony, the Academy and the Make-a-Wish foundation as they tried to clear up the PR backlash.

      • Misha says:

        This is old news. There’s an article on The Wrap (very credible site) from last year which gives a good eye witness account of what happened. AG thought the segment was exploitative and tried to fix it, producers disagreed. Garfield was reluctant to continue, Sony intervened at the last minute and Garfield agreed to do it but by that time, the producers had already cut the segment. The Oscars CEO was not upset, she said in her emails that AG sounded like a great guy and Pascal didn’t sound mad either, she said AG’s heart was in the right place. Garfield did go to Disneyland with him the next day, and he did it on his own, judging from Pascal’s emails she didn’t know about the Disney trip until after it happened. So he didn’t exactly bail on the kid. The whole Batkid thing at the Oscars did sound like a ratings ploy, there was no reason for him to be there so I can’t blame Garfield if he tried to help fix the segment. the emails indicated that the Oscars said AG could have creative input on the segment so it wasn’t like he was overstepping his boundaries. AG had some stipulations which the Oscars agreed on, in the emails, his rep said he wanted to be introduced as just AG, not Spider-man, and not as the star from the upcoming movie The Amazing Spider-man 2 and that he wanted the segment to be about the kid. That doesn’t sound like someone who was being douchey or preplanning to bail on the kid. I actually gained more respect for AG after this incident. It showed that he actually cared about the kid and wasn’t there just to sell his movie

  19. Carey says:

    I’m getting so sick of this story. New stories every week and new reasons. That’s the bad thing about not having your reps respond, people will just keep making up stuff because they know they can get away with it. I know they value their privacy but I think it’s time to issue a statement so that all this nonsense and speculation can stop. Emma has a movie to promote next month and I don’t think she wants her relationship drama to overshadow the movie

    • Renee says:

      I agree, they have to put something out, it’s getting out of control and it will keep going on and on and on until they say something. She has 2 new movies out this summer, plus she has Cannes in a few weeks so it would be a good time to end all these rumors

    • Trina says:

      I don’t think it matters is they put out a statement to be honest. Tabloids will always speculate and put out new rumors even if there is an official statement. They just want to make money

      • Dana L says:

        Very True. Sad because they are good people and don’t deserve this. They’re not like the Kardashians.

      • Mia says:

        I do hope they shock everyone and show up at Cannes together and give the paps the finger, woudn’t that be amazing? But they’re not famewhores so that’ll never happen

  20. Deanne23 says:

    I don’t believe this story at all. I hope Andrew & Emma can work it out. They seem like such a great pair. I know Andrew is a method actor and can reallly get immersed in his roles so I hope this is temporary. Emma knew going into the relationship that he was very method and has stated that in interviews before, so it’s not like this would be a shock to her. This is the first time he’s travelled so far for a movie, so distance I’m sure is an issue but filming will be over soon, so hopefully they’ll reconcile in the summer. Fingers crossed. They’re just too cute together. They were my relationship goals.

    • Renee says:

      I thought I heard filming ended May 10th, so he should be back soon. Hope he gets a haircut and shaves that damn beard off. He has such a pretty face

      • Trina says:

        I thought I heard end of April but I could be wrong and I know there were delays because a worker got killed on the set so you could be right. I also hope he shaves that nasty beard, he’s too cute for that

    • Dana L says:

      I hope it’s soon. I also saw the pics of him at the hospital in Taiwan and was genuinely concerned. He’s so skinny now, it can’t be healthy to lose that much weight in a short time, especially when you don’t weigh that much to begin with! I know it’s a Scorsese movie but I hope he’s not risking his health (and possibly his relationship) for a film. He’s been filming this movie forever, I think since January, and the movie is so damn dark and depressing and we know how method Andrew can get with his films…I read the book and I was a mess at the end, so I can’t imagine living with this material for 5 months and staying sane.

      • Nathan34 says:

        That’s sad, I hope he’s alright. I know he’s a really dedicated actor but I hope he isn’t going too far. I’m aware of the book, my girlfriend has read it and i know it’s a really difficult story so I hope it doesn’t mess with his mind too much.

      • Mandy says:

        Oh no, that doesn’t sound good. Where are the pics? Andrew is so serious about his roles sometimes, I hope he doesn’t mess up his life over this movie.

      • Doris says:

        I read the book in my book club last year. It is a depressing book and it would definitely put me in a dark place too. And he’s been filming this since January? Ugh Hope he’s alright.

      • Rees says:

        Oh geez, I hope he’s ok. I hate how actors go too far sometimes, hope that’s not the case here. He’s such a young & talented actor and I want to see him in a lot more films in the future.

      • Mia says:

        i hope this movie ends up being worth it! he better win an Oscar for all the mess it’s created

    • Anne says:

      If the distance and his method is a problem they won’t work out because they are actors who will always work. Andrew has the new Mel Gibson movie to do later this year so he goes back to US they get back together then in a few months he goes deep into another crazy role and starts being a bad boyfriend and go shoot his movie far away for months so waht they do, they break up again? they don’t have their franhcise to work together in a light role anymore. If they can’t handle that is just better to break up for good and move on. Sometimes its not meant to be. I love them together but if this was really the reason then they are doomed. They are young with a lot of their career ahead. This is the first time since they started dating one of them is working far away and apparently broke them so no much hope left.

  21. Renee says:

    Oh god, not Joaquin Phoenix, that would be creepy. And definitely not Bradley Cooper. That’s just gross. And Tom hiddleston is way too cheesy for Emma. If this breakup is true, which I’m still iffy about (People hasn’t budged on their initial story) I don’t think Emma is the type to jump right into a new relationship anyway. She should just concentrate on her career

    • Trina says:

      No, not Joaquin. Those pics on the film set looked creepy, not romantic at all! And I can see the Bradley Cooper rumors b/c it’s just too easy but no, I don’t think Emma would want to be his beard. I don’t think she’s the type to waste her time playing those games and she doesn’t need him!

    • Mia says:

      oh they’ll definitely be Bradley Cooper rumors

  22. Trina says:

    BTW, I can’t believe we’re making news stories out of things from OK Magazine. Seriously? Out of all the rags out there, they’re the absolute worst. I trust In Touch more than OK! Magazine and that’s saying a lot!

    • Dana L says:

      OK Magazine is a pile of you know what. I’ll never understand how they get away with the crap they print.

      • Doris says:

        I don’t know how celebs handle this. I know it’s easy to say, just ignore it, but man, it must hurt. I’d go absolutely crazy

  23. Dana L says:

    I swear this came from the OK Magazine print edition. Star doesn’t have a story on them this week. And if it’s from OK Magazine, I think we can say with 99.999% certainty that it’s a load of BS. I feel bad for Andrew, his name is getting dragged through the mud by sites like these who just repost lies to get clicks.

  24. Nathan34 says:

    This story screams fake. Way too many intimate details for “a source” to know unless they were in on the private conversation and how the heck would he/she know that Andrew is “inconsolable”? Are they actually in Taiwan with him, watching in “drunk dial”?

    • Mandy says:

      Exactly. I was rolling my eyes when I read this. Crazy how people believe everything on the Internet

      • Doris says:

        Story seems fake as hell. Way too many details. And if you had a scoop like that you wouldn’t run to OK Magazine.

    • Mia says:

      yeah, it sounds pretty fake but that doesn’t stop all the sites with running with it unfortunately. it’s a perfect click baity headline

    • Misha says:

      Ughhh, fake. This doesn’t pass the smell test at all

  25. captain says:

    I don’t believe she left him for being a method actor: Emma herself is a highly ambitious, extremely committed professional. She lives and breathes work, and would only appreciate a partner with the same mentality.

    I don’t believe she left him for cheating on her, even though I can totally see him having a one-night stand. It is probably impossible for a drunk young guy to have all these hoards of willing women chasing him and trying to get him one way or the other. Especially if he is not happy in his relationship. And I don’t think he was happy. I don’t think Emma was totally in love with him, she didn’t act like he was her dream come true, the best man on earth for her – that sort of feeling.

    I think she was cool and detached and sometimes outright annoyed with him, and didn’t give herself fully, simply because the deep strong love wasn’t there. He was a good choice at the time, and then he wasn’t anymore.
    I don’t know who it must be to make her really fall in love. But I hope it will be beautiful, because she is worth it.

  26. Patty says:

    Nobody really knows what goes on inside a relationship, except the people involved. We don’t know what their relationship was really like; so if they have broken up maybe it’s what’s best for them.

  27. Corrie says:

    I know you ladies love Hiddles. But NO. Sorry. He can’t get that. He’s definitely a downgrade in the looks dept and the game dept. Also, Andrew cheated when he started dating Emma. Emma was the other woman. But the cheating rumors sound like ad-lib versus fact here. Lets see what happens once Andrew comes home. All is settled.

    • **sighs** says:

      You think Hiddles is a step down from Andrew Garfield? AG looks like he’s 12 and comes across incredibly…..weird, I think is the word I want.

      Oh, and in that top picture he looks like he has more makeup on than Emma.

      • tigerlily says:

        I think Hiddles would be a step up from Goofy Garfield and she wouldn’t be intelligent enough to keep up with Hiddles anyway.

  28. sara says:

    OMG. Emma and Joaquim would be amazing. Just weird enough to be interesting and I find both of them hot.

  29. Naddie says:

    Even if it’s true, why does she need to be paired up with anyone? With so many lame options, it seems like anyone could be better than her being single, which’s not true at all.

  30. Original T.C. says:

    Somewhere out there Shannon Woodward is having a great laugh. Cheater’s karma properly served back. I knew the breakup would happen after Spider-Man. Andrew believes in out of site, out of mind. As for Emma, I hope she learns that a man who cheats on his girlfriend with you is going to cheat on YOU when you become the girlfriend. LOL

  31. HipsterIrony says:

    First time commenting. U guys are hilarious. Emma stone and jake g but i can see him with ANYONE.or leo d, douglas booth.make it happen.

  32. LetItBe! says:

    She is so pretty.