I’m not a Who-head or a Whovian or whatever Doctor Who fans call themselves. But I am familiar with the controversies surrounding Doctor Who in the past several years especially. David Tennent gave way to Matt Smith, Matt Smith gave way to Peter Capaldi, and die-hard Whovians are really, really mad at Steven Moffat, the showrunner and writer of Doctor Who for the past six years. Has Moffat screwed up the series? From what I hear, yes, he has. Which is probably why this is his last season/year as showrunner. He announced his exit from the show back in January, and the new season (season 10) of Doctor Who will be his last. But Moffat had one final send-off before he left the series for good: he had to introduce a new “companion” for Capaldi’s Doctor Who following Jenna Coleman’s exit last December. And the new companion is… a woman of color! The companion will be played by Pearl Mackie.
Doctor Who fans, meet your new TV best friend! Pearl Mackie has been announced by the BBC as the Doctor’s (Peter Capaldi) new companion, replacing Jenna Coleman, who left the series in December. The theatre actress, who most recently appeared in the West End production of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime, will play a character named Bill, who she describes as “cool, strong, sharp, a little bit vulnerable with a bit of geekiness thrown in.”
Capaldi praised his new costar, saying, “It is a genuine delight to welcome Pearl Mackie to Doctor Who. A fine, fine actress with a wonderful zest and charm, she’s a refreshing addition to the Tardis and will bring a universe of exciting new possibilities to The Doctor’s adventures.”
Mackie, who is also a trained singer and dancer, joins a long list of actors who have played companion to the legendary time-traveling alien, including Coleman, Karen Gillan, Arthur Darvill, Freema Agyeman, Katherine Tate, and Billie Piper.Ever since the long-running show was rebooted in 2005, companions typically stick around for no more than three seasons before moving on from the show. When we last saw Coleman’s character, Clara Oswald, she was sailing off in her own time-traveling Tardis with guest star Maisie Williams to travel the universe before returning to the eventual time of her death.
While the show seems to be in a constant state of shake-up, that will be especially true over the next couple seasons as showrunner Steven Moffat exits after season 10 and Capaldi may also be exiting, since his contract is up after one more year.
The complaints about hiring Peter Capaldi had nothing to do with his talent – and he is a very well-known and well-liked actor in Britain – but because he was just another white dude playing Doctor Who. I mean, it’s science fiction, the Doctor can be played by literally anyone, the sky’s the limit. But Moffat-haters complained about how Whoville was being kept dude-based and white. There were also complaints that Jenna Coleman’s companion was just a bargain basement Manic Pixie Dream Girl, and that Moffat never knows what to do with female characters. I can attest to that – Moffat’s work on Sherlock shows that he doesn’t really know what to do with women, as evidenced by having Sherlock literally MANSPLAINING women’s suffrage. So, Moffat’s Doctor Who swan song is to hire the first woman of color to play the Doctor’s companion. I mean… it’s better than the alternative, I suppose. Moffat would have been getting a ton of shade he hired just another pretty young white actress. Update: because I don’t watch the show, I was just looking at other listings of companions and I didn’t realize they had hired women of color before now. My bad! Pearl isn’t the first woman of color, she’s the second.
Photos courtesy of WENN, @BBCDoctorWho Twitter.
Thank you!
That’s not entirely correct, Freema Agyeman was a companion in the third season.
Edit: I see it’s been corrected, thanks!
I really did enjoy Martha Jones’s stint 🙂
Martha was my second favorite companion!! Love the actress!!
It’s great that they hired a woman of colour, but it’s a young, attractive woman. Again. Why not someone older? Why not an alien? Why not a man? Apart from Donna ( who was my favourite) did they ever have an older companion? I watch Doctor Who here and there, so I might have missed someone.
Thank you! I thougth exactly the same! Although the guest characters have been very diverse, his ”main companion” has always been a young, not very posh, attractive woman from 21th century London. I had also hoped for an older companion or an alien or a person from the more distant past/future. Or even better bring back our pan-sexual hero Jack Harkness!
But I still LOVE doctor Who and I think Stefan Moffat is a great writer (Blink, the girl in the fireplace, silence in the library are my favorite episodes). And he created some great female characters (I know not everyone agrees with me but I really liked River Song) for doctor Who, so I have to disagree with you there Kaiser :). But I must admit that his writing wasn’t as good as it used to be; the show had become way too Clara-centered.
BB….did you forget Alex Kingston (Mel) she played against three incarnations of the doctor, eventually becoming his wife and she was not ‘young’.
@Meadow I didn’t forget about River Song 😉 (Mels is played by Nina Toussaint-White, her incarnation as River Song is played by Alex). But even though she is a very often occuring character, I don’t really consider her a main companion like Rose, Amy, Martha & Donna (and like I said the occuring characters have always been very diverse). But I loved it that Donna wasn’t a 20-something. 🙂
Oh yes, and Mickey too…although I always considered him more of a tag-along than a companion. 🙂
And Clara’s dead boyfriend, purposely forgot his name. (Danny?)
That relationship being the focus of a whole season was so boring (nothing to do with race, age, religion or whatever. The show is and should be about the Doctor and his adventures, not the companion’s wretched love life. )
Fans always argue that Moffat ruined the show, but the truth is that we only hear from a small, vocal, Internet group who is never happy, no matter who runs the show. Some of the best episodes in past seasons were written by Moffat. And the show is currently more popular and widely distributed than at any point in the past. Is that entirely to Moffat’s credit? No, it is a team effort. Just like everything that is wrong with the show is not entirely his fault either.
For the record, as a true blue Whovian, I have never had a problem with the casting (except that I think Capaldi and the way they write his Doctor is over the top dramatic with a shade of boring). Like most BBC shows I find it relatively diversely cast, and they make a point of showcasing diversity in every way, including a lesbian relationship (also inter species), a pan sexual hero, (God I miss Jack), a variety of class /socio-economic backgrounds and so on. If people want to complain, lack of diversity is really not an issue with the show.
I agree. While The Doctor has always been white (at least this time he’s Scottish – so he can complain about things!), the rest of the cast, including the aliens, have always been rather diverse. I have to say that from that clip of Bill above, I don’t like her. But then I rarely like the new companions right away. Donna Noble being the exception to that rule.
Agreed. Diversity is not an issue with Doctor Who. Take that complaint elsewhere.
Yeah, diversity is not an issue in the Whoniverse.
Another blue Whovian here to agree with you.
And I thought that some companions (Martha, Donna are my personal favourites) had a been given a really meaty role.
Martha aka Freema Agyeman is black. She was his companion after Rose, before Donna.
The 3rd season in which David Tennant was the doctor. She’s made cameo appearances in subsequent series.
They have also had black women in random episodes, if you are counting eg Zawe Ashton pops up from time to time.
Sorry, I corrected and updated the post. I’m so not a Whovian, my bad!
😉 You are forgiven.
We love you anyways. 🙂
Saw the correction – you are, as always, forgiven 🙂
I used to be a die-hard Whovian… Like to the point that I’d go to premiere parties at a Doctor Who themed bar in Brooklyn. Over the last few seasons that went from this to “oh I’ll just DVR it” to now, where I actually didn’t watch the majority of last season. I dunno if that’s all Moffat’s fault (I’ve also gotten older and my tastes in media have changed) but yeah… In my opinion the show has changed a lot and not for the better.
Plus there was Noel Clarke (of Kidulthood fame), who was also a secondary companion.
I like this casting. The girl’s previously been consigned to daytime soaps and she is MUCH better than that.
BTW: the guy they’ve hired to write the YA spin off, Class, is an ex-pat American, the YA author Patrick Ness. How’s that for diversity?! They let a Yank in to the Whoniverse! I love Ness to the end of the u(who)niverse and beyond, so I’m looking forward to it. Diverse leads in it, too: http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-04-04/who-are-the-stars-of-new-doctor-who-spin-off-class.
Neil Gaiman said that the main Doctor Who role was once offered to a black actor. He would have followed David Tennant. Top of everyone’s casting wish list, but actor turned them down, and so they went with Matt Smith.
I remember! Who do you reckon it was? I was liking Daniel Ezra for the new companion but just as happy to see Pearl.
Apparently Chiwetel Ejiofor was offered the role and he turned it down. At least that’s the rumour that won’t go away. I don’t know if anyone ever confirmed it. Can you imagine! He would have been so amazing.
I seriously don’t get the ‘handsome’ status of Matt Smith. Not helped that i went to a play he was in, shortly before he was cast as the Doctor. Rubber mask features, giant head!!
He is playing Philip, DoE in ‘the Crown’. I saw bits of it and all i could think was ‘giant head! giant head! giant head!’
@LAK, I don’t get the handsome status of Matt Smith myself. I think he’s a good actor and he seems like a nice guy in real life and I think that’s what compensates for the looks.
Capaldi is probably my favorite doctor. Unfortunately most of the writing he has had has not been great. Coleman should have left with Smith, they had no clue what to do with her other than make her a manic pixie dream girl. Unfortunately the writing let her down too and she’s not as a good of an actor as Capaldi to compensate.
I am liking the Pearl Mackie casting. I hope this is not a one season deal for her until the new showrunner comes on and I hope she gets some great writing.
@ LAK, Matt Smith isn’t traditionally handsome or good-looking, but he’s one of those people who I personally find attractive anyway, because of his charm and humor and personality (as much as it’s possible to know someone’s personality without every meeting them!).
The more I watched him in Doctor Who and interviews, the better-looking he became!
I read on a Doctor Who fan site (don’t judge!) that Paterson Joseph, who had a featured role on the Season 1 episode ‘Bad Wolf’, was offered the part:
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0430667/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t8
He would have been great in my opinion, but apparently he didn’t want the role.
Definitely @Pennylane.
Looking at his CV, i can see why he turned down the role. Seems to be either too serious meaning heavyweight roles or American money. As much as Doctor Who is a beloved show, it’s not well regarded by certain types of actors.
Heard it was Patterson Joseph too, he would have been great. Would have been a bit of tradition too, being in it before being cast as a main part, see Freema, Colin, Peter…
On a different note, Noel Clarke is determined to go bigger than this show. They were writing him into the show, but he turned them down to go make his films.
He is currently prepping the 3rd in the KIDULTHOOD trilogy.
And his comics! What’s that one everyone (well, Sixlet Major) likes? … *googles* … The Troop. I really like him. Treads his own path.
I like that Noel Clarke is a self starter. He’ll go far. Like Matthew Vaughn.
During the Davies era Moffat wrote some of the best episodes-The Doctor Dances/The Girl in the Fireplace/Blink, etc-but as showrunner the quality has slipped. For Matt Smith’s final season I found about half the episodes nearly unwatchable. But I love Doctor Who and hope it gets back on track.
Under Russell T Davies the previous showrunners the world just had more diversity. And it wasn’t just that there were more black companions there were also more people of different diversities and different sexualities. The show wasn’t perfect but it did have a vibrancy due to that.
I wish Davies would come back.
Damn straight. There was awareness and determination to show diversity.
You were partly right. This is the first person of colour that Moffat has hired as a companion. Martha and Mickey were part of the Russell T Davies era. It was a completely different show before Moffat took over.
I’m really sad because I feel P. Cap got a raw deal. His Doctor should have been amazing, but Moffatt’s storylines were a mess.
It’s been so hard for me to get into Dr. Who. My mother and I used to watch it together when I was a kid. I loved it then but as an adult I can’t get into it for some reason. I just don’t have any sustained interest.
She seems fresh and fun in the promo, but the way the lines are written they might has well have been for Mary on Sherlock.
I am really hoping that the speculation that Bill is from a decade other than this one, perhaps the 1980’s, is true. One thing that has been forgotten is that the Doctor used to gather companions from all of space and time.
Geez, she’s annoying already, I couldn’t even watch the whole clip.
I loved Amy, I thought she was a great complicated female character?
I’m American, but I watch a lot of British television, and I find that they’re better at casting people of color in their shows than we are in the US.
As far as Doctor Who goes, Moffat can suck it. A bunch of episodes of the last several seasons don’t even make any sense. I know it’s sci-fi, but I shouldn’t have to make a graph in order to understand what’s going on.
I’m here to honk for Cap’in Jack, John Barrowman is the bee’s knees, and I loved the arc with he and Burn Gorman in Torchwood. I wish they would make more of them, all the characters were kick ass, and Gwen was the business. The crossovers with the Whovian world were so well written, and the storylines were gripping and exciting. All round good television. In the spirit of full disclosure I started watching Doctor who in 1963 on the black and white telly. In my defence, I was just a kidlet at the time. A forever fan!
I love Torchwood. I wish they would revive it.
There’s been talk. And then silence. I want the talk again.
I loved Torchwood but that last season wasn’t really the best.
Yeah, another honk for Captain Jack Harkness! And another one for Bill too. I began watching Doctor Who when I was a child too. All the William Hartnell episodes too. Favorite memory is of recording the episodes on VHS to look at them later. I’m probably dating myself.
😊
Honk, honk for Captain Jack!
Martha was black, River was black. River wasn’t a companion but she was pretty important for awhile. And Mickey was technically a companion. So? This doesn’t seem to be a big deal to me. It seems like they’re promoting more gender fluidity with this companion.
Is white v. black casting a problem in the UK? I watched that David Tenant Casanova a few years back and it struck me that it was very ethnically diverse-that wouldn’t happen here in the US, they like to make period movies very white. That’s part of why Hamilton was so dynamic, because we really only cast period movies a certain way.
River had a regeneration where she was black, but she was Melanie, Amy’s friend, then. When she regenerated into River Song, played by Alex Kingston, she wasn’t black, as Alex Kingston isn’t black.
I gave up watching Dr Who during the Matt Smith era. I didnt mind him as the Doctor but found the stories far too complicatedvand weird. I tried again with Peter Capaldi but couldnt get into it. Ive also found most of the recent companions very annoying especially Clara. My favourite was Donna. Her chemistry with David Tennant’s doctor was excellent. The new girl will only be good if she is given decent storylines
Casanova was an RTD production again he’s very aware of diversity issues.
First comment on Celebitchy. Excited to see my favorite show talked about on my favorite celeb blog!
I’m a massive Doctor Who fan. I’m somewhat of a Moffat apologist, although I recognize his flaws. If I had to choose, I prefer the Davies era, but neither are without their problems. On the gender side, Davies wrote a very problematic ending for Donna which took all her agency away (acknowledging this but I still love that episode) and essentially wasted Martha, who was such an intelligent and capable character but pined hopelessly after the clueless Doctor most of the season.
Davies really excels at writing characters. You see that Rose, Martha, and Donna’s backgrounds and families were all featured strongly in ways that Amy and Clara’s weren’t (Amy & Rory’s family was explored to a small extent). Moffat excels at writing complex plots, even if they get a little messy at times.
Moffat definitely has some issues in writing women, although I don’t feel like he’s the raging misogynist some people make him out to be. He’s certainly capable of writing strong female characters. But I feel like many of his female characters show their “strength” by using their sexuality almost as a weapon against their male counterparts. You definitely see that with River, Amy, and season 7 Clara, as well as Missy. Outside of Doctor Who, you see the same thing with the women characters on Coupling and Mary in Sherlock to an extent. But he’s also capable of writing good female characters when he puts his mind to it. Sally Sparrow in Blink, Reinette in Girl in the Fireplace, Nancy in Empty Child/Doctor Dances, and Season 9 Clara. Outside of Doctor Who, you have Lynda Day in Press Gang and Mary in Sherlock in her better moments.
I feel like Moffat tried to tackle some of the issues people had with his depiction of women in Season 9. Even though I didn’t like Clara, thought her characterization was a mess, and wished she had left in Season 8, her Season 9 arc was really good. She had an actual personality and flaws that didn’t feel like “female problems.” And when she left, she did so on her own terms. I think Moffat was purposely trying to show that Clara had a different fate than Donna, because the ending started out so similar but Clara got to control her destiny.
As for Pearl, I’m really excited for her. I loved the short clip. She felt a little bit like Ace from the classic series. I’m wondering if she’s going to be from the 80s given her clothing. There had been some rumors that they were going to cast an actress of Indian descent as the companion. A woman who was on EastEnders. That would’ve been really cool, since characters of Indian and Asian descent have been the least represented on Doctor Who (I wish Rita from the God Complex could’ve been on again).
Hear, hear, couldn’t agree more about Moffat and Davies! (Seriously, I was fervently nodding whilst reading your comment) And I second you with the hope of a character of Asian descent 🙂
I stopped watching for awhile because I couldn’t stand Clara. As long as it:s somebody other than Clara, hooray.
My order of favorites was Donna, Martha/Rose(tie), Mickey/Rory, Amy and waaaaay behind Clara.
haha, same! Couldn’t stand Clara, loved Donna the best!! I thought Martha was too whiny though.
Thank you for the Dr. Who post! LostHusband started with Tom Baker in his youth. He had lost his “Dr Who love” until LostDaughter reignited it starting with Christopher Eccleston on forward…..they both adored Martha Jones….Clara not so much especially toward the last two seassns……they like Peter well enough but feel his talent as an actor hasn’t been given his full potential due to the writing…
I’m a pretty rabid Whovian, and I actually think the show has been pretty diverse since NewWho (2005 onwards). Different races, different sexual preferences, different aliens (haha)…Peter Capaldi’s episodes have been some of the best Doctor Who fare ever, and many, many fans agree, according to the stuff I read on different Doctor Who sites. I think he’s tied for my favourite Doctor with David Tennant. I liked Russell T. Davies’ showrunning and Steven Moffat’s. Hopefully whoever runs the show next will also do a good job. Looking forward to Pearl Mackie as the companion! I never did care for Jenna Coleman’s Clara, so change is good! 🙂
My very first comment on CB! Long-time reader though..
So happy to see a post on my favourite show! Agree with every point which Alison and Donna made. Peter Capaldi is fast replacing David Tennant as my favourite Doctor.
Moffat does create strong female characters but then doesn’t know what to do with them, if their story arc plays out for more than one episode. Then their characterisation devolves into something from a bad fan fiction. As an Indian, I’m always happy to see actors of Indian origin playing key roles in the episodes without being reduced to stereotypes.
Super excited to see Bill as a geek!