Debra Messing describes emotional abuse from the director on her first film

In the wake of this terrible new administration, more of us are openly discussing how we’ve been personally affected by similar abuses to those committed by Baby Fists and his panel of a-holes. Debra Messing, 48, gave a speech at the Maker’s conference detailing how the director on her first film, A Walk in The Clouds with Keanu Reeves, went out of his way to shame her for her nose, insisted on seeing her naked basically despite assurances from her management that nudity would not be required for this film, and worked to break down her self esteem. She was only 25 and all of this sounds like sexual harassment and textbook emotional abuse however no one stepped in to protect her. The director, Alfonso Arau (Like Water for Chocolate), has denied these claims, including Messing’s opening line in her speech that Arau told her that her nose was ruining his movie and that she needed to get plastic surgery for it. The Wrap did a good job of recapping this and I’m including their segment below but if you have some time and want to watch the video it’s on their site. Messing explains it so well, especially the way that Arau was sweet to her in the lead-up to filming but then completely tore her down afterwards.

At the MAKERS conference in Palos Verdes this week, the actress recounted her time on the set of her first movie which also starred Keanue Reeves and was directed by Alfonso Arau. She began her story by saying that the “a– hat” director once told her that her “nose is ruining my movie.”

“How quickly can we get a plastic surgeon in here?” she says he shouted after ending a scene. “Her nose is ruining my movie! … I can’t do this! Look at this!”

Fox had no comment, and representatives for Arau and Zucker Brothers Productions have not responded to TheWrap’s request for comment. But Arau’s rep told TooFab that the claims are “false” and “inaccurate.”

Messing said she “felt ugly, I felt like garbage, and I felt deep shame.”

The actress said that on the second day of filming, Reeves was supposed to find Messing’s character in bed with another man. Messing says she wasn’t told she would shoot a nude scene and approached Arau about feeling uncomfortable.

“Are you kidding me?” she said he told her. “Your job is to get naked and say the lines, that’s it. You should be grateful to have this part. Get out!”

Messing said she was distraught and ran to the producers, and asked them about why she was told there would be no nudity in the movie.

She said they responded that they promised her no nudity in the domestic release, but not the international release.

Messing said her agents told her, “you can say no and they fire you or you can do it and you keep your job.”

After pondering the situation, Messing decided to do the scene. The director apparently wanted to “set the sheet” when Messing laid down on the bed.

“He lifts it, scans my naked body, then drops the sheet on top of me like a used Kleenex. He walks away without a word,” she explained. In other scenes, she said, he walked around her and told her to cover both her nipple and her “a–.”

“It turns out, after all this trauma, the only part of my body that is seen naked in the film is my back,” she said. “The whole thing was a power play, a game. And the goal, to demean me, to strip me of my power and make me feel on a cellular level his dominance over me.”

She added, “I told my agents I would never work with that a–hole again.”

[From The Wrap]

In her speech, Messing explained how she experienced prejudice growing up Jewish but that Barbra Streisand inspired her as a child. Later she saw Dirty Dancing with Jennifer Grey and thought “there might be a place for me in Hollywood.” It’s clear that her experience with Arau was demeaning and abusive and that it changed her career. She switched from film to theater and TV after that because she thought she “didn’t have the look” for the movies. When she first started on Will and Grace she was made to wear chicken cutlet-type breast enhancers in her bra. After three weeks she complained and learned that order to wear the fake boobs came from the president of the network. However she persisted, said she would talk to the president although she never did, and she was allowed to take the enhancers out. (NBC had no comment to this.)

At the end of her speech, Messing said “I have a strong nose, I have small breasts. There’s something wrong with Hollywood and our culture’s painfully narrow definition of what a beautiful woman looks like. I’m a f-king original. My nose and I have come this far, and like Barbra Streisand I’m defiantly keeping it.” Good for her and good for her for telling her truth. Note to abusers: we remember and we will tell. Maybe not now, maybe not next week but it’s coming.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

30 Responses to “Debra Messing describes emotional abuse from the director on her first film”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Alleycat says:

    I just love that men in Hollywood (and in real life honestly) are held to a different standard than women are. I wonder if anyone screamed at Adrian Brody about his nose.

    • hmmm says:

      Her profile resembles that of the late great Myrna Loy in the days when unique character mattered. Lucky Myrna. I believe Debra- men can be such pigs. Arau is an abusive woman hating a@shole.

  2. Mia4S says:

    I’m sorry she went through this but I am glad the tide is turning and these stories are being told. Hey men of Hollywood; want to maintain your reputation and legacy? Be decent to the women you employ, or work with, or casually encounter. It’s not hard.

    No more silence, you will be exposed.

  3. SusanneToo says:

    Debra was excellent in AWITC. That’s sick that she was treated that way. I’ve been following her twitter for awhile. She was one of Hillary’s biggest supporters and she is on top of all the deplorable trumpiness. Like so many other celebs, she gets a lot of grief for it, including tweets along the lines of “Get in the oven” and “Bring back the camps.”

    • Annika says:

      OMG, how can people make such disgusting comments?

      • SusanneToo says:

        They do it to Sarah Silverman and other Jewish celebs who dare to question their god. Some of the most vile comments I’ve ever read.

    • Lahdidahbaby says:

      Good God, it never ends, even all these decades after the Holocaust. I admire Messing for refusing to be bullied into changing her face just to please that jackass.

    • Alix says:

      Tweets like that make me want to vomit. Human beings are disgusting.

  4. L84Tea says:

    Wow, I never realized how much I prefer her with red hair.

  5. mimi says:

    Last sentence of this article is GOLD.

  6. Annika says:

    Unbelievable.
    People need to give actresses more credit for dealing with some much scrutiny.
    I couldn’t handle that crap. While I’m no where near as beautiful as she is I’ve not had to hear such cutting remarks about my appearance as my career field has nothing to do with my looks.

  7. Madailein says:

    I read a little more of this article, and in it she insists she never had a nose job. I don’t believe her; the nose she currently has looks small and thin and paper-cutter “Hollywood” to me. It’s not that I doubt the rest of her story–at all–it’s just that I think she was affected enough by the physical criticism to have cosmetic surgery on her nose, after all.

  8. Hola says:

    Working in the industry, Ive seen straight male , gay male and female film directors either sexually harrassing workers (both straight and gay male) or completely manipulative and rude abussive assholes (all of them)… i dont know other industries but cinema is full of abussive “artists”… a lot of them make “important” movies about “important” issues and are very respected by the public opinion… but they are despicable human beings at work and private life… its a very difficult industry …actors and technicians can have really difficult lifes sometimes…

  9. nicegirl says:

    You go, Deb.

    Love her.

  10. HoustonGrl says:

    I commend her on speaking out. I had an abusive boss for years, it nearly destroyed me.

  11. Hola says:

    On the other hand its strange that Arau…a mexican (?) who was new to Hollywood at that time and who no longer helds the status of promising film director at all… was surprised about her nose after casting her, rehersals, wardrobe and light testing…
    I will never stop amazing me how this people can one day give you the best speech about human rights and the next day tell you how amazing was to work with Allen or Polanski
    I applaud the writers at Celebitchy to giving perspective to facts and statements of glitery artists and hustlers

  12. lucy2 says:

    If he had a problem with her nose, he shouldn’t have cast her. It’s her nose. It’s on her face all the time, it wasn’t like it was a surprise to him. Also, there’s nothing wrong with her nose. I’ve always thought Debra was so pretty (but I agree her red hair suits her best, though everyone likes to change it up now and then).

    It sounds to me like a common story – person with issues gets some power, finds someone powerless to take it out on. Sadly this is all too common. But the more we talk about it, the better.

  13. L says:

    The ironic thing is i have seen people in this comment section demeaning people based on looks too … its no different just because you dont say it to their faces…

  14. Wurstbonbon says:

    I never spent a second even thinking about her nose. It always looked perfectly fine to me.

  15. LaDiabla says:

    Good for her for speaking out. I love that movie, and always thought she was very talented. Sucks to know that Arau was such an ahole. I loved Like Water for Chocolate too. Wonder if Keanu was witness to any of this…he doesn’t seem like the type to stand by while a young actress gets humiliated like that. And he had plenty of hits before AWITC, so he had at least some clout within the industry.

  16. thaliasghost says:

    I’m reading this coming out of a meeting about the book cover of a an erotic novel for women. Three women and one male boss. Two covers to choose from. One is a Georgia O’Keefe flower style cover. They other one is a sexualized objectified photoshopped tits and ass picture. The male boss interrupted and then talked over three women giving them a sermon that the first cover was a waste, the only one selling copies was the second one because that is was sells stuff, that is what we want to see. Remember, the target audience for this book isn’t even men. But he cannot see beyond male gaze.

    But at least this article reassures what we have to teach out children again and again. Tv and movies are a represention of patriarchal capitalism. It doesn’t reflect who actually makes up society whatsoever.

    • mayamae says:

      I read strictly e-books now, so covers no longer matter to me. But as a straight woman, I have no interest in T&A covers. And I often read erotic novels.

  17. Anare says:

    I don’t care what line of work a person is in no one has the right to belittle and abuse another person period. I read Debra Messings speech on another site and I felt sick just reading about what she went through with that director Arau. Good for her for speaking out. The only way to fight that kind of ugliness is to shine a very bright light on it.

  18. vespernite says:

    I lover her….she’s beautiful! And I also learned to love my nose because of Barbra, she is still my idol! I jokingly tell my mom that Barbra is my real mother, because of my nose and the fact that I can sing and my mom can’t. LOL