One day in November 2010, Prince William brought out Kate Middleton to pose for photos just after they announced their engagement. It was an iconic moment, for Kate especially: she had a fresh blowout, she slipped her left hand through William’s arm, giving the photographers a perfect view of his mother’s famous sapphire engagement ring. And of course, there was the dress. Kate chose a sapphire-colored silk jersey dress by Issa for her big coming out party. Kate had been wearing Issa throughout her 20s – she was a big fan of short, silk jersey dress in bold colors and prints. When she became a duchess, her style changed a bit – she still loves too-short dresses and jewel tones, but now her go-to look is “doily.” Basically, Kate stopped wearing Issa within a year into her marriage. It was too closely associated with her single, Waity days.
So what happened to the label and to the designer, Daniella Helayel? I remember there was a lot of gossip that Kate wore so many Issa frocks during The Waity Years because Daniella would give Kate freebies in exchange for exposure. It was “The Kate Effect” in the early years, although I’ve always thought The Kate Effect – wherein whatever Kate wears sells out – was overblown, especially in recent years. As it turns out though, The Kate Effect ended up destroying the Issa label and Helayel is only climbing out of the ashes right now. Helayel gave an interview about all of the sh-t that’s gone down ever since Kate walked out in that blue dress in November 2010.
In a new interview with You magazine, Daniella Helayel says that the “Kate Effect’s” boost to her brand left her underwater and, eventually, contributed to its demise in 2015. Helayel says that despite success on the celebrity front — with stars like Madonna, Kylie Minogue and Elizabeth Hurley wearing her designs — the brand was in financial trouble in 2008 and 2009.
“Only the previous year the label was on the verge of financial crisis; it wasn’t all rose-tinted glasses,” Helayel told You. “Issa was a niche brand, we had a loyal following but in 2008 and 2009 we were in serious financial trouble. When Kate wore that dress everything changed.”
But it wasn’t all change for the better. Issa faced incredible demand after Kate debuted the now-iconic look on the day of her engagement. The style sold out in five minutes — and was reordered thousands of times after that. Helayel and her team had no idea that Kate would be wearing the dress that day, and thus had no time to prepare their inventory for the onslaught of interest. It was nothing compared to what they had seen before, even though Kate had been wearing her designs for years prior.
“That morning I’d gone to yoga as usual, and then I got a call from a friend telling me about the royal engagement,” she said. “It was all very exciting. We didn’t have a TV at the studio and this was pre-Instagram, but we soon knew Kate was wearing Issa because at four o’clock the phones began ringing and didn’t stop. It was bonkers.”
And the interest hadn’t subside weeks after the engagement was announced. After the royal engagement, Issa’s sales doubled, but the business (and capital) she had in place wasn’t ready for that sort of rapid growth.
“I didn’t have the money to finance production on that scale,” she said. “The bank refused to give me credit and the factory was screaming for me to pay its bills. I needed an investor.”
She found one: Camilla Al-Fayed, half-sister to the late Dodi Al-Fayed, who died in a car crash with Princess Diana in 1997. Al-Fayed bought a 51 percent stake in the company in July 2011. But Al-Fayed’s family — in particular, her father, Mohamed Al-Fayed — had been extremely critical of the royal family since the tragic crash. And although Kate continued to wear Issa designs at the start of her marriage, after the merger, she appeared in them less and less. Ultimately, the business move led to the collapse of the brand: A new CEO came on — whom Helayel clashed with — and she ended up leaving the brand in 2013 before it shuttered completely two years later.
“I left because I couldn’t take any more,” she said. “I felt so stressed that my hair went white and started falling out. I was broken by the end of it. I had a great business, which I’d built up on my own over a decade. To watch it evaporate was heartbreaking.”
Helayel took a break from design, traveling and spending time with family. But now she’s back with a new brand, Dhela. The first collection, which she says retains “hints of Issa” with jersey fabrics and similar styles, is available this month. (And includes plenty of Princess Kate-ready styles!) “Designing is what I do, it’s what I love, and I’m just so happy to be back,” Helayel added.
It’s clear that Helayel doesn’t blame Kate personally, although she probably thinks that Kate maybe should have given her a heads-up about the blue dress. But basically, this is a story about when The Kate Effect goes DARK and how fashion is such a tricky business. I also think that this Issa Situation is probably one of the reasons why Kate does so many repeats, why she wears stuff that has been discontinued and why she’s going for “bespoke” stuff more and more. She doesn’t want to wear something new and off-the-rack and have that choice destroy a small business. Or maybe I’m giving Kate too much credit?
Photos courtesy of WENN.
What’s going on with her in the 2nd pic?
The begin of her smugness lol
Haha! She looks pretty good in that first one though.
Ha, ha, I bagged a prince! I will never have to work again!
Correction: I have never worked and now I never will. Suckers!
I love that dress.
And it looked so good on her. Pippa wore the same dress at a wedding in a hit pink. Very nice.
It’s my one of my dream dresses, I just think it’s so flattering and I can think of a million ways and times I’d wear it.
I love it too and I dearly wish she’d go back to some of her Waity style choices. This cut works SO well on her figure and manages to look mature without being dowdy, youthful without being twee. She just can’t seem to find that balance much anymore and it’s a shame.
He has aged like a president.
Oh my goodness, I didn’t notice how young he looked there. Wow. Imagine when he STARTS a actually working.
That was what I thought too! What the hell aged him so much? I am the same age as the Dolittles and my kids are nearly the same ages as George and Charlotte and although we look tired, my husband and I haven’t aged that much!
Look at all the hair on him!
Yup and it hasn’t even been 10 years. Such a shame.
Does the Kate effect really exist?
She often dresses like a grandma etc. so I don’t know whether I should believe that or not.
Kate dresses boring but so do most people. Some of her dresses can be nice for family dinners or business meetings etc.
I could have sworn I read something last year that the Kate Effect no longer existed, but maybe it was just petty royal gossip?
It definitely still exists — it just isn’t as easy for most people to buy her clothing now since for the past few years, she’s been wearing *much* pricier items and designers such as McQueen more frequently.
But any time she wears anything even remotely affordable, it sells out insanely quickly and there are some eBay sellers who make a killing selling only “Kate” clothing.
You’re giving Kate too much credit, if you think she is concerned about the welfare of small businesses. If anything, I think she wears discontinued styles to avoid Z list British celebs (and socialites) turning up in the same clothes as her a week later.
Also, putting my economist hat on for a mo – there is no reason why a small business has to suffer negatively from Kate wearing their designs. Issa’s downfall was that they tried to scale up quicker than they were equipped to – in order to ‘seize the moment’.
Obviously this is a tempting thing to do, because that moment can be a once in a life time opportunity – but it is a decision a brand makes whether they was to scale up that quickly or not, and Issa made the wrong choice for them. I mean, why on earth would you partner with a Fayed while trying to capitalise on royal association – that’s just bad business. the Kate effect didnt kill Issa – a flubbed attempt to scale up, did.
There is no reason why a small business HAS to ramp up production/increase supply – they could, for example, capitalise on the publicity at a steadier pace. The key is knowing your business and what works for it.
This whole story is so dumb, imo. She was in financial trouble before Kate ever wore the clothes. She mismanaged the business at every step of the way, before and after Kate wore that engagement dress.
I found it ridiculous to blame Kate on this one. Issa wasn’t forced to grow at that scale or exceed its own capacity like that. The owner made a very poor decision to expand at way too fast a rate, and build on essentially the success of just 1 design. Not to mention, the moment she partnered with Al Fayed she severed the very relationship that her rapid expansion was built upon. These were poor decisions that Kate bears no responsibility for.
@Bridget, exactly!
I am no Kate apologist but Issa’s situation was in no way her fault; Kate had absolutely no idea that millions of women were going to want that same dress immediately. It was only that day that most Kate fans even learned who she was and the first instance of “the Kate Effect.” No one could have predicted that.
And partnering with Fayed was Helayel’s downfall. I don’t know HOW she possibly could have thought that was a good idea. No way would Kate be able to wear her clothes once the company was owned by the very people that accused the BRF of murder!
It’s a shame because all of her Issa dresses were gorgeous and very flattering on her. I have always adored the long pink one she wore to the Boodles Boxing Ball in 2008. She looked stunning. But no way can she be associated with the Fayeds in any way.
I don’t follow royals stuff at all, and I knew who Kate was for years before they even broke up the first time. That was back when Will was considered sexy and people paid a lot of attention to his girlfriends. Heh.
The talk about her style started before the engagement, but no doubt it ramped up as soon as they announced their engagement. But either way, this isn’t Kate’s fault.
i second this assessment. she took good publicity and made a bad business decision.
I fail to see how Kate tanked the business. I do, however, see the CEO making a lot of excuses and blaming others.
I agree with what you’re saying but it would have been nice if she could have had some forewarning that one of her dresses would be a part of a historic moment. I’m sure though that the thought never crossed Kate’s mind as she was simply focused on her prize.
I remember when Sharon Stone decided to wear a Gap turtleneck or something to the Oscars. She had the courtesy (or ego) to let them know in advance that they should probably stock up on them.
The issue wasn’t that the dress sold out, though – it was that the label widened production well past the point that they could handle. Forewarning wasn’t going to help pay those factories.
Also, Sharon Stone famously pulled that turtleneck and skirt out of her closet on the day of the Oscars. There was no advance planning that she was going to wear it, so Gap never got advance notice to stock more mock turtlenecks. In fact, she was supposed to wear a Vera Wang to the event and just wasn’t feeling it that day.
But Mimi, up until that day, most people didn’t even know who she was and the “Kate Effect” didn’t exist yet. I don’t think it’s fair to say she should have warned them. She never could have predicted the response that dress got.
Especially when the dress was matched with Diana’s sapphire engagement ring!
.
I agree. This was a business decision that label made.
That pic.. Kate looked healthy, now she’s horibbly thin. William lost his hair fast.
Uh, Kaiser, all due respect but you’re giving her WAY too much credit. She wears repeats to look thrifty and out-of-season-looks to either make sure not every peasant will run out and get it or look even thriftier by wearing things she ostensibly already had in her closet.
Also, and this is where I need help, how is this her fault? I don’t know exactly how the fashion industry works but it sounds to me like this lady was simply not prepared to grow her business this rapidly. And she shouldn’t have. On what basis? One dress? You tell your customers it’s sold out, period. Instead you decide to capitalize on the moment and get in bed with … the half-sister of Dodi??? Of all people? Is this a telenovela?
It’s not her fault at all. The woman is basically saying “Kate made my brand so famous that I made terrible decisions and ruined my company.”
She was already in trouble before the engagement dress. If anything, Kate prolonged a dying business by several years.
There have been stories to that effect. She gets things, puts them away, and then wears them when they are not available to others. Doesn’t want anybody wearing what she wears, but no, let’s not call her vain.
There was also talk that with designer gear, she orders things on approval and doesn’t pay for them until after she’s worn them publicly. Stringing folks along, following her mother’s lead with the wedding outfit.
Yes and am sure she gets things for free as well, remember that family are not too proud to ask for freebies or massive discounts. That Audi car lease when she was just his on/off booty call.
@NOTA: I absolutely believe you, but am genuinely wondering how Kate benefits by not paying for something until she’s worn it already? 🤔
It sort of sounded like the founder of Issa just made some really poor business decisions, so I think calling it the “Kate Effect” is pretty unfair. I mean, really, going with an al-Fayed family member as an investor when your biggest client is a royal family member? Surely there were other interested investors, since Kate wearing your brand was a big deal, especially in the Peak-Kate days of 2011.
We can blame Kate for a lot of things, but she gets a pass for this one from me.
Kate gets a pass from me too (just this once). It sounds like greed got the better of Helayel. Why did she allow orders to be placed if her suppliers couldn’t fulfil them? Has she never heard of the term “Sold Out”?
Agreed. Kate gets a pass from me today. That felt strangely odd for me to say. 😜
Just don’t say it again! LOL!!!
The Middleton family took freebies from this woman for years. I think it would have been thoughtful to give her a head’s up in gratitude for that. Then again, they didn’t bother to tell Her Majesty until after they’d organized the press conference announcing the engagement, weeks after her family was told.
Thoughtlessness-R-Us appears to be W&K’s motto.
Plus he didn’t bother to even ask The Queens permission to marry until after they announced it, as he is legally required to do. I have always wondered what the real story behind their engagement is? I have never believed the whole safari story, she had problems sticking to it during that engagement interview. And wasn’t it discovered it was taken word for word from the society pages of one of his friends engagements?
Sure, but none of that has a thing to do with the designer making poor business decisions. She ramped up production even though she couldn’t afford to – that’s what killed her business.
If she had been warned ahead of time, she could have planned to ramp up more logically. Been more prepared instead of having her site crash and her running around like a chicken with her head cut off.
Others have noted above, her business wasn’t doing great as it was – while it would indeed have been polite and helpful for Kate to give more notice, I don’t think that would have made a difference in Issa getting more capitol to pay their factories. She couldn’t get a cash infusion from anyone other than Al Fayed even after such a huge, high profile boost to her business – which points to some pretty serious issues with Issa.
The same thing has happened to many small companies who sign on to Groupon. But those small businesses hadn’t clothed the Middletons for free for years.
If she had had advance warning, she could have been better prepared. Even if her preparation was to say no, or to make it clear at the time of ordering that it would be up to a year before the item shipped. Only fair in return for the mountain of freebies the Middletons had taken through the years.
Do you realize you are literally criticizing Kate for giving Issa too much press now? I mean, one could consider wearing an Issa dress for the biggest photo op of the year adequate payback for all of those freebies. The woman makes a lot of bad choices, but Issa’s difficulties aren’t on her.
It really wasn’t up to the Middletons to tell HM anything. THAT is on William. It was his place/responsibility to inform his family before hand. The fact that he didn’t was just his way of flipping them the bird (esp. his father, IMO).
Wait, what’s the story of the engagement? I’ve heard many different things here and there but if someone could piece it all together that would be great?
@Llamas, thank you for asking this because I’ve often wondered the same thing!
Like you, I’ve heard bits and pieces (rumors, likely) but nothing to back any of it up.
One story that frequently gets mentioned is that Harry’s response to the news was that he was “looking forward to getting to know her,” but I’ve never seen that substantiated anywhere. The only comment I remember Harry making was something along the lines of, “l’ll finally have a sister now.”
Hopefully someone can enlighten us!
Llamas / Lorelai: Engagement shenanigans…..
1. at the time of the engagement, the fact that William only gave HM and POW 2hrs heads up on his engagement was widely reported. Not just in gossip media. It’s still listed in any newsmedia that puts together lists of facts about the wedding eg this birthday celebratory list about William turning 30. Item 9.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/prince-william/9346139/Prince-Williams-30th-birthday-30-facts-about-the-Duke.html
2. There is an informal way that the family behaves when BP makes such announcements. In this case, they all went about their engagements as if it were a regular day, and were subsequently doorstepped by the media who informed them of the engagement. Usually the informal way means that they have prepared remarks and obviously do not act surprised when the media asks them about the engagement.
3. Regarding Harry’s remarks, he gave an interview to an American morning news show about a month before the wedding when he made those remarks. Frankly i’ve never heard him describe Kate as a sister. That appears to be a media made lie that became fact. I’m happy for anyone to show me where he made that comment. ‘Looking forward to getting know her’ is a quote out of this interview which i’m linking below.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XE5kgxZVc3g
4. As for the engagement story, a month before the engagement was announced, one of their friends gave a very detailed story of their own engagement to the DM. When William sat down to describe how he proposed to Kate in their engagement interview, it was a copy of the friend’s engagement story. Word for word, except for the country he proposed in. The friend proposed in Botswana whilst William claimed to have proposed in Kenya.
It’s unsurprising that William deliberately lies to the public. He’s been caught out a few times because he is bad at his public lies.
Yeah, this sounds like bad business decisions all around. It’s not the first time a company has gotten a huge boost and fallen apart after not being able to meet demand.
When I look at those photos all I can say is that Wills and Kate don’t age gracefully.
Well grace isn’t exactly something they are aiming for either. Surprised if they know of the word’s existence.
Looking at photos of them today, my guess would be this was taken 15-20 years ago, instead of roughly 10.
I would never buy something just because Duchess Dolittle wears it.
I feel bad for the woman, but I don’t know about blaming the Kate effect.
Your dress is worn by one of the most famous women in the country, during an iconic moment that is worldwide news and will become part of British history, your work is on the front cover of papers worldwide, you’ve got hundreds of pre-orders, and yet still no one will give you a loan? Not to be cynical, but I can’t help but wonder what kind of financial situation they were in and if there had been any financial mismanagement in the past. It’s extremely unlikely no bank would give them a loan under those circumstances, unless they had a history of bad credit or defaulting on loans.
Kate can’t be good for business of cutting edge fashion. she is one of the most visible/high profile wearer of almost any brand by virtue of her position and her bespoke taste veer on horrible.
Alexander McQueen look downright backwards and dowdy on her, ditto the other dresses. Wicksteads continue to be awful, her Erdem bespokes speaks of middle of the road.
not to mention the alterations she made (presumeably her own seamstress?) where she lifts waistlines or adds buttons.
on the fashion choices that are braver (eg Bhutan/India tour) she ruins them all with bad posture.
So true. I’d hate to have Kate wear my clothes as a designer, she always looks so pedestrian, either the makeup and hair is off, she’s added some ghastly cheap necklace, had her “stylist” perform some less than professional alterations, and lastly she’s slouching and making bizarre maniac facial gestures.
Bad economic business model, can’t blame Kate for that.
As for Kate not wearing the label anymore, a Fayed investment might have been a bigger motivator in that direction.
Weren’t there reports at the time of the Fayed investment that Kate might have been told to cut ties with Issa?
I always thought the Fayed investment reflected poorly on Helayel. It seemed like both a bad business decision and a bad personal decision. I’ve worked with enough creative and visionary types who lack all common sense that I’m short on compassion for her. Most designers would kill for that type of exposure, and she wasted it with incredibly poor choices.
I don’t know if Kate was pressured (or encouraged) to cut ties after the Fayed investment, but the designer is a grade A idjit if she didn’t realise the implications and consequences of accepting that particular investment given the bad blood between the Fayeds and the royal family around that time. The royal family very publicly cut ties with the family including withdrawing their royal warrants from all Fayed businesses.
However, you have to wonder at how bad her business financials were if banks refused to lend despite back orders at the numbers she reveals and the no 1 royal to be causing an avalanche of new orders.
I’m a casual royal observer from the US, and I would instantly understand the likely repercussions of associating with Dodi’s family. Amazing that she apparently did not factor that into her business partner decision.
@Christin, same. I remember when I read that, my jaw dropped or I gasped or something. Even I knew immediately that Kate could never again be seen wearing that label, and at the time, Issa was the label most associated with her. The Fayed name is toxic to the BRF.
Helayel literally could not have picked a worse investor if she’d tried.
I’m guessing Kate chose that colour of dress to match the engagement ring. The hair seven years later is still a juvenile mess. Though it’s strange she seems more mature in attitude, in these photos.
I am not sure if mature is the word. I think she looks happy and content. Though given who she is married to and mommy dearest their aging doesn’t surprise me.
bad business decisions destroyed her business, not Kate.
Good lord how these 2 have aged in the past 5 years. Marriage and the pressure of their public duty workload has clearly taken a toll.
Issa was in trouble long before Kate wore that dress. I have a couple of the dresses they did for their Banana Republic co lab. The clothes were well made and designed and I get a lot of compliments on them. From this interview I get the impression that the designer was happy being a niche brand but she’s not really a good business woman, a good designer yes.
Sounds more like a story about how a fashion designer didn’t really know a lot about business and she over-extended herself to meet non-existent demand.
1. Too much credit. 2. Why the designer couldn’t have just sold the amount they were capable of producing and then put the ‘sold out, come look at our other items’ sign on the dress?
Girl, bye…she got rich enough to buy a townhouse in Chelsea. Her problem was scaling too fast. She could’ve kept her brand small and exclusive, but she wanted to cash in.
This is so stupid. They can’t blame Kate for having poor business and financial management. When you’re running a business you need to be prepared for sudden surges in sales, especially if you’re already rubbing elbows with celebrities, whom you know willl be rocking your stuff at any given time. At the end of the day, they didn’t have enough capital + inventory to accommodate high demand. That’s on them, not on her.
Agree. Issa should have had a setup where she would be able to contact someone to handle rush orders and Issa should have been educated in business and should have had the willingness to run her business herself.
in my view, a lack of business acumen is what ruins these talented designers.
This is the last time I remember William looking handsome.
Harry better get on with it. He is getting balder every day. By the time he walks down the aisle, his hair situation will be a real tragedy.
Bald or men going bald can be sexy, it’s down to how the ambrace it. The turn offs r the ones who try to hide it.
I met this guy who always wore a hat to hide his baldness. Even when he slept
Maybe Harry would look good just shaving his head, once the battle is lost (which is probably going to be 2 to 3 years from now). I think he could pull off that look. William’s head shape is not as conducive to it, though.
@Mimi:
“By the time he walks down the aisle, his hair situation will be a real tragedy”
is one of the funniest comments I’ve read in a long time! 😂👏🏻
I think the article is giving Kate too much credit regarding the wearing of bespoke and out of season clothes. She and Whiny come across as too self-centred to care about other people.
However I don;t think she can be blamed for Issa’s problems. The company was obviously in difficulty beforehand.
Continuing on the theme of Kate’s clothes, the DM is running a story today that the Queen is taking fashion tips from Kate. Seriously????
I can’t believe the change in the Dolittles from the engagement photos. Doing nothing all day is obviously very stressful and aging.
Agreed about too much credit. From the few reports that have come out about her shopping habits, I’ve gotten the feeling she likes buying stuff on sale because she likes a good deal (as many of us do). And maybe it makes her feel like she’s economizing?
$200,000 last year on clothing is ‘economizing’?
Or it could be that Charles refuses to break out the Black AMEX to buy couture when she isn’t at all working.
People are weird about how they save money. Maybe in Kate’s mind, she saved 50K because of items she got on sale …
@Cerys, I haven’t seen that DM article yet but that is one of the most preposterous stories I’ve ever heard. The Queen taking fashion tips from Kate? For crying out loud!
Semi-related: you see this little gem in People magazine today?
http://people.com/royals/how-princess-kate-is-changing-the-way-people-talk-about-mental-health/
My eyes rolled right out of my head at this headline!
“How Princess Kate Is Changing the Way People Talk About Mental Health”
Sure Jan. Delusional.
I’m blown away by HOW MUCH BETTER they both look in those photos. Granted, some of it you can’t help (baldness, wrinkles, passage of time), but my goodness her hair looks healthier, her eye makeup is less intense, no sausage curls or crazy faces, they’re smiling sincerely, wow. Just wow.
It’s actually amazing that was only six years ago. They look fifteen years older now.
” She doesn’t want to wear something new and off-the-rack and have that choice destroy a small business.”
Yes, you are giving Kate too much credit in considering she would take others in consideration.
Agreed… if she can’t give her charity patronages more than a couple of hours of her time per year, I doubt she’s strategically clothing herself to protect entrepreneurs.
Wait, what?! Too many people bought her dresses, so she went bankrupt? Then a wealthy investor came onboard to pour money into the brand and it still folded. Sounds like poor management skills. She is lucky about Kate, before the engagement most people hadn’t even heard of this brand.
To be fair, this label was well known before the engagement. Not at Ralph Lauren levels of saturation, but as a decent, well made clothing label beloved by girls about town, and not just sloanes.
As an example, It was well known enough to feature in the first SATC movie in 2008. Worn by Charlotte.
And considering how often Kate and Pippa were papped wearing the label between 2007 – 2010, it’s no surprise that she wore it for the engagement announcement. It was well known that Kate (and by extension Pippa) received freebie dresses from the label. They picked a design in several colours each time.
I don’t think that she wears off-the-rack and repeats for the sake of small businesses. I don’t think anyone would have that sort of forethought, least of all Kate. I do agree that she likely wears out-of-date things for the sake of preventing others from turning up wearing the same thing but….I’m surprisingly blase about that as well. On the rare occasions that she goes to her engagements, she is expected to stand out and command attention. I imagine a part of that is also wearing the right clothes, such that they set you apart from everyone else. She sucks at that so bad though, so it doesn’t matter if she’s the only one turning up in the millionth coat-dress she has in her closet, she just blends into the wallpaper.
I feel bad for Issa’s designer. I think it’s lousy that they wound up that way, and I wish they’d had more insight into how to do this sort of thing then. I think that Kate legit liked the brand though. I did like her style before she married William.