Brad Pitt is being sued by justifiably angry Make It Right homeowners

Brad Pitt and Leonardo DiCaprio back in their car on the set of 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood'

A few weeks ago, we heard that a group of people were planning to sue Brad Pitt and Make It Right, the foundation he started after Hurricane Katrina ripped through Louisiana. Make It Right was started by Brad and it was his baby… until he got bored and moved on to other things. The purpose of MIR was to provide affordable and environmentally-friendly home to New Orleans residents. The problem was that many of the homes were shoddily made and became unliveable after a year or two. When the residents tried to contact Brad or anyone at MIR, they got the run-around. Several of the MIR homes have even been demolished by the city because they were environmental hazards. Well, here’s the update: the lawsuit is going forward.

Brad Pitt’s Make It Right Foundation, which built homes for New Orleans residents after Hurricane Katrina destroyed their neighborhoods in 2005, has been hit with a lawsuit by two people who claim the homes built for them “were deficiently constructed and built,” according to a complaint obtained by PEOPLE. A rep for Pitt and his foundation did not immediately respond to PEOPLE’s request for comment.

The lawsuit was brought by residents Lloyd Francis and Jennifer Decuir, who state in the document that the homeowners “were and are extremely grateful to Mr. Pitt for spearheading the rebuilding of the Lower Ninth Ward because their neighborhood housed more than their homes. It housed their community.” Their lawyer, Ron Austin, told NOLA.com, residents “were forced to file this lawsuit because the Make It Right Foundation built substandard homes that are deteriorating at a rapid pace while the homeowners are stuck with mortgages on properties that have diminished values.”

Some of the problems with the homes include mold from trapped water, poor air ventilation, structural problems, electrical problems, plumbing problems and rotten wood, according to the complaint. Francis and Decuir allege the foundation was aware of issues with the materials used to build homes by 2013 but “never provided homeowners with notice of these design and material defects” despite the residents paying for mortgages on the homes.

In 2016, 2017 and 2018, the Make It Right Foundation allegedly sent engineers to inspect the homes and to write reports on the state of the houses. The residents repeatedly asked for the reports but were told they weren’t ready or were ignored, according to the complaint. While members of the foundation promised residents they would provide the engineering reports, homeowners were allegedly told they needed to sign “a packet” in order to begin repairs. Francis and Decuir claim the packet contained a non-disclosure form and a binding arbitration document that needed resident signatures — which they allege Make It Right tried to gain while they were under duress, according to the complaint.

The two, who state they are representing all the residents who bought homes from the foundation, claim the foundation members “have caused and will continue to cause plaintiffs to suffer significant mental distress” by continuing to ignore the state of their homes.

A source familiar with the situation tells PEOPLE that “Brad has confidence in the Make It Right team; he made a promise to the people of the Lower Ninth and he intends to keep fulfilling it, and to keep contributing money as he has been all this time.” The source adds that “repairs began months ago.”

[From People]

This sounds like an absolute nightmare for all of those residents. Of course they have every right to sue, and I wonder what took them so long to do so – it was clear that MIR was giving them the run-around and no one at MIR was being held accountable. This was Brad’s baby, and he couldn’t take enough credit in MIR’s early days. But at some point, he just got bored or stopped caring, and that was right around the time when the houses all began to fall apart. Now the “source” makes it sound like Brad is just a neutral observer in all of this, some well-meaning donor who had no legal or moral responsibility for the MIR homes. He’ll probably get away with that too, because he’s Brad Pitt.

Brad Pitt leaves The Metrograph Theatre after attending a screening of his Netflix movie 'War Machine'

Photos courtesy of Backgrid.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

30 Responses to “Brad Pitt is being sued by justifiably angry Make It Right homeowners”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Astrid says:

    Brad has reached a new low

    • arianan says:

      Brad reached his lowest point on that infamous plane flight from hell.

      I don’t care how much his stans try and rewrite history, facts are facts, it was Brad not Angie who destroyed their family, and in the worst way possible.

      Now Brad’s stans are trying to say Brad really wasn’t that involved with MIR, I guess all those photo ops of Brad walking to each and every house taking bows for being the poor people’s “savior” were just fignments of everyone’s imaginations.

  2. Lady D says:

    I wonder if this will affect the golden-boy image? Or will they be lining up in the thousands to call him magnanimous and magnificent, and the people who are now homeless ungrateful?

    • Carmen says:

      That’s exactly what’s happening. Check out the comments on TMZ about lazy, ungrateful homeowners. Some of the comments are racist in the extreme.

      • .... says:

        And written by his pr or himself….under diff screen names. He’s been writing the narrative on those comment boards for years and years. So pathetic.

  3. Renee2 says:

    I know that this is a serious matter but I am picturing the scenes from the Simpsons where there are angry Springfield residents with torches.

  4. Veronica S. says:

    What took them so long? The expense is the most likely answer. This is going to be a long court case, and these people have already suffered a major financial blow by losing those homes.

  5. Lala11_7 says:

    The thing about this horror show for homeowners…Brad et al used a new fangled manufactured wood on the properties that was supposed to be environmentally friendly and hold up to the elements…well, it seems as though the wood material is DISINTEGRATING which has lead to the cornucopia of crud that these homeowners are dealing with…so other than tearing down the houses and building them with materials that have been tried and tested…I don’t see how this is not going to end in economic and REAL heartache for these poor folks…

    Imagine the hubris of Brad Pitt…to go into an already frightful situation and instead of focusing on providing the people he was claiming to help with viable home options that were humanely priced and made of materials that would last…he decided to be “cutting edge” and shoot for the moon…pulling hundreds of hard working folks into the depths of Hell instead…Just think if he had took his considerable resources and partnered with “Habitat For Humanity”…an organization with not only a proven track record of building viable homes for working people…but also an organization that has a world-class reputation for its administrative/logistic infrastructure regarding getting the job done…

    I can NOT stand him…

    • Skylark says:

      *applause* So well said.

    • Erinn says:

      Is the company who manufactured this product being sued as well? There should easily be a lawsuit there, if that’s the case. I get that the idea of the environmentally friendly solution was nice – but man. That’s a freaking shame – I can’t even imagine having to deal with the SECOND loss of my home.

      • Stumpycorgi says:

        @Erinn Make it Right sued TimberSIL for $500,000 back in 2015, but I can’t find the current status of the case. The glass-infused wood product was supposed to last for 40 years, and be recyclable. I don’t know if Make it Right used due diligence in choosing to use the product, but in any case, they were obviously in way over their heads. NOLA’s unique climate and sea level makes it a challenge for architecture. MIR had no business experimenting there and taking advantage of that horrible nightmare to stroke Pitt’s ego! Shame, shame, shame. https://www.fastcompany.com/90230876/brad-pitts-housing-nonprofit-make-it-right-faces-lawsuit

      • Erinn says:

        @Stumpycorgi

        Thanks! I can’t believe that’s all they sued for. Due diligence was a major major issue here though. What a freaking mess.

      • Stumpycorgi says:

        @Erinn My pleasure! Yes, $500k seems like a pathetically small amount. You’ve piqued my interest, and I may try to find out what happened with this case on Westlaw or Lexis later today. I will report back if you are interested! Btw- I’ve been a long time lurker and infrequent commenter, and I always really enjoy reading your thoughtful, clever, witty comments. Thanks for being you!

    • Stumpycorgi says:

      Well said indeed. I lived in NOLA and by chance, moved to the Midwest shortly before Katrina hit. In the aftermath I drove straight back down there and ended up working with a church that had turned itself into a nondenominational volunteer center. What happened to that city was a total nightmare, but the 9th ward in particular, I’m telling you, was the worst part of that mind-boggling nightmare. I saw a huge BARGE that had been swept over the levee and crashed on top of houses. Entire houses swept down the street with cars and everything else mangled up together. Some houses had holes in the roofs, where people had desperately climbed and punched through to escape the flood. It is one thing to see images on the news; it is quite another to be standing in the middle of it. Taking advantage of a situation like that is utterly despicable. On a positive note, the courage and hopefulness of those who remained, in the face of seemingly insurmountable tragedy, without assistance (I remember the real you, George Bush), will stay with me forever. Love you NOLA!

  6. maggi says:

    wow, this thumbnail next to Voigt’s and all I can think is Angelina really did marry her father. my stomach hurts for her, to see that pattern.

  7. Spike says:

    I wouldn’t be surprised if it becomes a class action suit.

    This project was supposed to provide homes for families who lost everything during Hurricane Katrina. But it became a disaster for those it was supposed to help.

    Pretty boy loved to portray how involved he was in the process. Since he headed this up it was his duty to stay involved. Help work through issues. Help to resolve serious problems that plagued owners.

    He’s a dilettante who was playing with people’s lives. Guess he was too busy getting stoned and drinking to really care.

  8. Anastasia says:

    Wow, for the houses to be falling apart that badly in two years. That’s some SERIOUSLY shoddy home building!!!

    This was the final nail in the coffin for me regarding Brad.

    • Sandra says:

      That’s what I think too!!! How can a house POSSIBLY be falling apart after 2 years??? Were they built out of sugar cubes? Because I would expect even a substandard material to last longer than that! It’s just incredible that the materials and workmanship are that bad. Those poor people.

  9. Ophelia says:

    Brad seems to be a type of man who thinks that throwing money at things are his only duty and stuff will magically repair itself.

    What do you mean I’m a bad father? I’ve paid millions.

    What do you mean I did nothing for NOLA? I’ve paid millions!

  10. SWP says:

    But guys, come on, you don’t get it. Cut a golden boy a break, this was during his architect/do-gooder/impress Angelina with his humanitarianism phase! He’s waaaay different now!!

  11. LadyT says:

    >>> The problem was that many of the homes were shoddily made and became unliveable after a year or two. When the residents tried to contact Brad or anyone at MIR, they got the run-around. Several of the MIR homes have even been demolished by the city because they were environmental hazards.

    Source?

  12. A says:

    It’s so funny how, when Angelina Jolie goes through controversy (as was the case for her film last year), people crawl out of the wood work in DROVES to talk about how her entire existence is a sham that only serves to make her look good, that she doesn’t actually do anything worth while, that her charitable impulses were all a lie, that she only adopted those kids as an accessory etc etc. That her work for the UN isn’t actually helping anyone, it’s just causing more problems because of her celebrity (lol).

    Meanwhile, Brad Pitt is getting sued by the people who lost their houses in Hurricane Katrina for f*cking their lives and their homes over, and he only gets a FRACTION of that response. Barely a fraction, actually. Even though it’s very likely that he will have to settle this at some point in the future. It’s no secret that if this happened to Angelina, Brad Pitt and his TMZ demons would be beside themselves with excitement and would go all out in talking about how this makes her a completely unfit mother and what a hero Brad is for being so honest and good.

    I hope the MIR homeowners take every penny that they rightfully deserve. This man promised them a home after a devastating natural disaster, only to let them down again. That’s disgraceful.

    • Carrie says:

      Misogyny and sexism at work.
      I feel terrible for these people in NOLA. Only vague memories of MIR but going to look up what happened again re : Mike Holmes in Canada and his involvement here

    • KLJ says:

      I noticed that too and it’s not just here but on other sites too. It’s completely disgusting.

  13. raincoaster says:

    I found this Canadian article about the origins of the project. Mike Holmes, a star contractor who had a tv show called “Mike Makes It Right” and may or may not have sold Pitt the rights to the “Make It Right” name, was brought in to create the prototype. That particular house is still going strong: no complaints. But he also warned at the time that Pitt didn’t seem to know how to get from a beautiful plan to a beautiful reality. Seems like he was right about that.
    https://www.thestar.com/opinion/columnists/2009/04/07/mike_holmes_helps_make_it_right_in_new_orleans.html