Lucy Liu isn’t just an actress, producer, director, independent woman and Asian-American icon. She’s also a multidisciplinary visual artist, and she’s currently promoting her new virtual exhibition at the Napa Valley Museum. To promote the exhibition, Lucy spoke to the LA Times’ Asian Enough podcast about her Asian-American identity, growing up in Queens, New York, and working with Bill Murray on Charlie’s Angels. When Charlie’s Angels was filming more than two decades ago, there were many rumors about Bill Murray falling out with cast members and just being generally unpleasant. I remember specific rumors about Murray verbally abusing Lucy especially. She addresses that directly for the first time in this interview. Some highlights:
Her independence: “I think I was born with it. I’ve always felt this wonderful urge to explore and be free, and I really love the idea of having that freedom creatively and as a woman, as a mom. There is something very freeing about that curiosity. And I love having people around me all the time and exploring that.
On getting her foot in the door in the industry: “A lot of people said to me: “There’s nobody that’s out there. There’s not a lot of Asian presence in media, television, film. You’re going to be very limited and you’re never going to make it.” I just thought: I don’t know what that means. I don’t know what “never” means. So let’s just try. It’s just one foot in front of the other. To me, the glass is always half full. I don’t even see it being empty at all. I guess I’m an optimist.
Growing up in Queens with immigrant parents: “We didn’t have very much money, so we grew up with whatever we grew up [with]. It’s that idea of, you get what you get and you don’t get upset. And if you do get upset, you get a mouthful of why you shouldn’t be upset. We were left to our own imagination and curiosity to do whatever we wanted. I’m not saying it was a simpler time, but there was not the complication of technology. There was no possibility of not attending high school and college. We didn’t discuss art and theater, and we didn’t do any of that because we had very limited funds. It was all about survival. And I think survival creates a very different environment than, let’s say, my child now has.”
The Bill Murray situation: “I feel like some of those stories are private. … But I will say, when we started to rehearse this scene, which was all of us in the agency, we had taken the weekend to rework that particular scene and Bill Murray was not able to come because he had to attend some family gathering. So it was everyone else, and we just made the scene more fluid. I wish I had more to do with it but I didn’t, because I was the last one cast and I probably had the least amount of privilege in terms of creatively participating at that time. …As we’re doing the scene, Bill starts to sort of hurl insults, and I won’t get into the specifics, but it kept going on and on. I was, like, “Wow, he seems like he’s looking straight at me.” I couldn’t believe that [the comments] could be towards me, because what do I have to do with anything majorly important at that time? I literally do the look around my shoulder thing, like, who is he talking to behind me? I say, “I’m so sorry. Are you talking to me?” And clearly he was, because then it started to become a one-on-one communication.
Standing up for herself to Bill Murray: “Some of the language was inexcusable and unacceptable, and I was not going to just sit there and take it. So, yes, I stood up for myself, and I don’t regret it. Because no matter how low on the totem pole you may be or wherever you came from, there’s no need to condescend or to put other people down. And I would not stand down, and nor should I have. I remember years later, maybe even decades later, some crew members that I didn’t even know at the time came up to me on other sets and told me that they were there at the time and they were really grateful that I did that. I have nothing against Bill Murray at all. I’ve seen him since then at a “SNL” reunion, and he came up to me and was perfectly nice. But I’m not going to sit there and be attacked.
What the press said about her at the time: “I don’t want to be that person that is not going to speak up for myself and stand by the only thing that I have, which is my dignity and self-respect. Because in the end, we all end up in the same place as time goes on. Nobody is immortal. But in that time, no matter what happens between now and whatever career choices I make or whatever life decisions I make, I will walk away with my dignity. I remember after that time, what came out in the press was that I was this and I was that. It was incredible to me how it was turned around and they automatically thought that the woman was the difficult one. … But I didn’t understand how it got flipped when I had nothing to do with instigating it or creating that platform of confrontation or anxiety. So even though it’s been decades, it’s something that obviously I remember very intimately and have not forgotten.
This is one of the reasons why there tends to be a kind of unsettling energy around Bill Murray. Sure, there are tons of stories about how he’s a great guy and all of the fun and crazy things he does on-set and in real life. But stories like Lucy’s have been around for years too, where Murray acts like a complete f–king jackhole, especially to women. I also think it’s interesting that it’s taken this long for Liu to feel comfortable enough to tell her side of the story. I remember Drew Barrymore – who executive produced those Charlie’s Angels films – always said nice things about Bill Murray, but she still replaced him as Bosley for the second film (she hired the late, great Bernie Mac). Did Drew and Cameron know the extent of it? Did they have Lucy’s back from Day 1?
Photos courtesy of Getty, Avalon Red.
Wasn’t that man accused of hitting his former wife? I’m not a fan and wouldn’t mind never seeing his face.
Lucy is a gift and I wish she was in more projects.
Yeah he has a history of abusing women and his “fun quirky antics” are actually unprofessional and self-serving feats of being an asshole.
Lucy Lui is spectacular and should absolutely be in more films. Her acting isn’t more wooden than Keanu Reeves and he’s a leading man so……
I read about this yesterday and I’m so glad you’re covering it. Bill Murray does have a mean-spirited, bullying energy to him. I think Lucy was probably left to fend for herself because Bill was the bigger star and I think he knew he could get away with targeting Lucy because she’s Asian and not a white woman.
Here’s what Bill said about it in 2009, “Look, I will dismiss you completely if you are unprofessional and working with me. … When our relationship is professional, and you’re not getting that done, forget it.”
Yeah, BS. Bill Murray is a creep. If you watch his episode of the Graham Norton show, even there he’s so full of himself and disrespectful to the female guest.
Speaking of creeps… when will creepy Jeff Goldblum get exposed. I know people who have been harassed by him and whoa is he ick.
And Bill Murray is a famous sexist. He comes of the “women aren’t funny” school, and thinks he’s an ICON. Nice to finally see the stories come out.
Agreed, I get sketchy vibes from him too. I had to turn off the podcast episode Jeff Goldblum did with Conan.
My cousin interviewed him at TIFF a number of years ago and he was a complete ass to her. Like unprofessional, dismissive, rude etc. She does a lot of celebrity interviews and usually doesn’t spill the beans on who she likes and dislikes, but she really was disappointed in him. She’d heard he could be problematic, but is good at her job and can get almost everyone to warm up to her. Not him.
I think it’s going to be like Ellen. Once someone (Maybe another celebrity) outs him and then the flood gates will open cause there are A LOT of stories! That’s a shame about your sister, she must have to deal with that kind of thing a lot! I have been around the business most of life now and have so many stories, lol. But I also had to sign tons of NDA’s so can’t spill as much as I’d like. I try but just…..obliquely. lol. (But Lordy, when I’ve had a martini or two, I’ve been known to spill….)
tbh I feel like this is a particular kind of mean energy I have experienced from (white) men in Chicago after living here many years. It’s an energy they carry and especially those in the public/entertainment eye who bring what is really a kind of depressed/negative and depreciating “humor” which would be funny except the the depreciating is not of themselves but directed at you. And if you don’t like it, you’re the problem. I notice it all the time in comparison to other places.
Reminds me of Bill Cosby.
So I’d add in Jeremy Piven (known jackass) and John Cusack (more recent curmudgeon).
She is one of the most beautiful women of all time.
And yes, there are so many stories of him being a jerk. I’m glad she spoke up.
Agreed!
I am a huge fan of these movies and Bernie Mac was a WAY better casting choice as well as DuBois. They played off eachother so well.
And I have never cared for Bill Murray. Kudos to Lucy for standing up for herself.
He came out of SNL back when it was really bad for women. And I don’t think it’s great now honestly. Those guys were all sexist asshats. I’ve never been a Bill Murray fan.
He and John Belushi were brutal to the women writers and actors on SNL. Both stated that women in comedy just weren’t funny, either writing or performing. And Chevy Chase was always an arrogant POS and bailed out of SNL because he thought he was so much better than the rest of the cast. They’re all a bunch of misogynistic bullies.
Belushi even gave Lily Tomlin hell when they were only six episodes into their first season. Lily Tomlin!
Was Dan Aykroyd a di*k too? God I hope not because I like him. And these dudes were lucky to have been on SNL with the great Gilda Radnor & Lorraine Newman!
Lucy , he came up to you and was “perfectly nice” at the SNL reunion because he tried it with you and found out that you weren’t the one. Sounds like he’s a bully.
Bully, yes, that was my immediate thought. He berated the person he thought was the weakest and wouldn’t fight back. Little did he know that Queens don’t play. Love Lucy Lui and I’m glad she’s telling her story.
I love how much physical space she is taking up in that photo of the cast when they’re seated – she’s got her arm over the back of his chair and isn’t leaning away from him. I don’t know how much of her body language is deliberate, but it’s clearly stating “I deserve to be here. This is my space. I will not be diminished.” He’s the one who looks uncomfortable and I’m really liking it.
@ncboudicca, I noticed that too, she is OWNING that b!tch lol 🙂
There are alot of stories out there about how Bill Murray is a jackass to everyone on set from actors to crew. His ex wife has told some stories that would make your toes curl. Paul Feig mentioned on ghostbusters how stressful it was working with him.
He’s a bully and always has been-but it’s cute because he shows up drunk to college parties *shrugs*. Not a fan and this seals it. Good for Liu for standing up for herself
Yep. Chevy Chase was more talked about as being an asshole, but Bill is horrible, too. No wonder they hate each other–they’re so much alike.
Chase is terrible. Belushi was, by almost all accounts, a piece of work too, but Chase takes the cake.
What do you know about Chase? He has such a punchable face but I have never heard much about him (I may not have tried to hear anything? I hated those vacation movies).
@It’sJustBlanche – read this article and you’ll be disgusted at Chase’s behaviour with a whole lot of people who to this day will have nothing to do with him. https://www.gawker.com/5899097/hes-not-chevy-hes-an-asshole-a-history-of-chevy-chases-horrific-behavior
Wow Jaded, what an ahole he is.
So he said something either really sexist or really racist
She was an easy target being the only minority star in the cast. He knew that no one would take her word over his. He was a celebrated comedian from the hey days of SNL when there were no minorities in the cast and bad behavior was probably tolerated and/or encouraged (“He is acting out because he is a genius”). Her star power started to dim after Charlie’s Angels because Hollywood believed him when he called her a bad actor. His opinion is the only opinion that matters because he is a “good” actor.
Melissa McCarthy was vague as hell about them working together on St. Vincent.
The fact that the director had to call a 800 number and leave a message hoping someone will get back to him, yeah, I would move on. Egotistical jackhole.
I’ve always like Bill Murray as an actor, and some of his quirkiness stories are amusing, but I have no tolerance for the “I’m a genius so I can be an a-hole” attitude.
So a scene changed without his participation, and he got angry not at the director, or the writers, or the producers, but the 3rd billed actress? WT?
I love Lucy Liu, and I’m so glad she stood up for herself. I’m guessing maybe now the timing is finally right for her to feel free enough to speak about what happened.
He actually wrote changes to the Charlie’s Angels script and then delivered copies of the changes to everyone’s trailers and expected that those changes would just be accepted.
even people who like bill murray have gotta admit that he’s unpredictable and his bit isn’t being *nice* – there’s always passive-aggressive tension in his restraint, a random blowup, then a shrug – the behaviour liu describes is on brand and i never questioned that he was the worst to her
also always wondered how much his attack on her talent was rooted in his own insecurity/ambivalence about taking the backseat in a goofy female-driven blockbuster at a time when he was ageing out of young hot comedian roles and pivoting to *serious/artsy* supporting work
‘also always wondered how much his attack on her talent was rooted in his own insecurity/ambivalence about taking the backseat in a goofy female-driven blockbuster at a time when he was ageing out of young hot comedian roles and pivoting to *serious/artsy* supporting work’
I think you hit the nail on the head there
yup!
It also seems when he trots out his a-jokers, he’d more likely to punch down than punch up. Which makes him a cruel coward,
Ok, I have a good friend who worked with this POS and he physically injured her on set by “joking around” she is still dealing with the physical pain to this day.
He is a total POS who treats the “less thans” like crap. I hope he burns in hell.
And man it feels good to finally speak this truth. We all learn to never ever talk about what happens on set. Well, times have changed. Go f yourself Bill!
Holy $$$$ that is so so evil! What a completely worthless jerk.
Wow, so sorry to hear that! Jerk!
She’s gorgeous and she seems like an amazing woman.
I once in a while catch myself remembering that Bernie Mac passed away and it saddens me every time. He left us too soon.
Me too! I loved Bernie Mac’s sense of humor. His death was so sudden and unexpected. I feel the same way about Brittany Murphy.
A few years ago when promoting her memoir, Anjelica Huston talked about how awful he was to her on the set of movie The Life Aquatic. She said he deliberately excluded her from dinners he arranged for the cast and crew, and then would gaslight her by saying “We missed you last night”. She was very hurt. And then the same thing Lucy is saying about him later acting nice to her and as if nothing happened.
I love her. I think most women are, unfortunately, still raised to be deferential or to turn the other cheek and be peacemakers, and we often let WAY too much slide. Standing up for yourself is difficult enough as it is, much less when your bully is a beloved veteran actor and you’re a more lowkey (and non-white) actress without much clout in the industry. So I’m glad she had the courage to do that.
Also, whenever someone says “low man on the totem pole”, my anthropology degree obliges me to correct them: In every totem-making tribe I’ve worked with, the figure at the bottom of the pole is actually considered MORE important, because he’s holding up and supporting the higher figures. This has been my pedantic know-it-all moment of the day.
Love that!!! Pedantic on Miranda!
Isn’t he the same a$$hat who poured his drink over Mahashala Ali, a practicing Muslim who abstains from alcohol? And had the nerve to think he was being cute?
YES! I had forgotten about that story. Dumped vodka on him at the globes
https://people.com/movies/mahershala-ali-bill-murray-vodka-2019-golden-globes/
Whaaat? I forgot about that. What a piece of shit!
What!?! What a fucking asshole. Pure evil. Pouring a drink over someone also is just the lowest. I feel sick to my stomach. The things BIPOC and especially Black people bear in this f-ing country from white folks. It’s just…it never ends, does it…
Im so sad she had to go through that. Bill is a piece of you know what. He is a nightmare to work with according to multiple costars. Richard Dreyfuss said he was abusive toward him on that ridiculous movie they made together years ago.
Damn. What About Bob? is one of my favorite movies of all time.
I just saw Lucy Liu in Women Who Kill. She was fantastic and her story line was heartbreaking. She’s perfection.
seeing as Lucy was paid FAR LESS than Cameron and Drew for CA, they probably knew it and did nothing about it.
Ugh I forgot about that but yeah you’re right. Really gross of both of them, especially Drew who was a *producer* on the film.
The pay scale may have been based on the star power of actors at that time rather than race. Cameron Diaz was a big star as was Drew.
Murray, like most of the men who worked on SNL, is a known asshole.
I can’t forget the rumors that both he and Sofia Copella ganged together and treated a very young Scarlett pretty poorly/made fun of her on the set of Lost in Translation, and basically Mean Girled her.
I don’t know if that story was true, but I found it believable.
Sorry to hear about Lucy’s experience, and we should also remember the angle that she was being treated this was as the non white actress. Note the physical distance between Cameron, Drew and Lucy in the photos. I know drew and Cameron are close, but there are ways to not be exclusionary , especially in public.
I think it was mutual. Scarlett Johannsen was insufferable back then. She gave the worst interviews centered around her youth and geared towards older men. But the power differential is still way off with Sofia being the director and Bill being the bigger star. But yes, I remember stories about Scarlett pretty much being frozen out.
“ notice the physical distance between Cameron, Drew and Lucy”.
What are you talking about? They are sitting in chairs so the distance is pretty much set. In one photo Cameron is literally leaning into Lucy and has her hands on her knee. In the second photo she’s turned towards Drew.
Lucy Liu is everything. Stunningly beautiful. I really can’t take my eyes off her when I see a photo. She just glows like she’s made of golden light. Yes, fangirl here. lol She is glorious and I wish her every abundance. Did anyone see her in Why Women Kill the first season. Absolutely fantastic.
A colleague of mine told me that a mutual acquaintance (not someone I really know) is Bill Murray’s son and the “product” of a one night stand. Apparently the guy is really bitter and doesn’t really talk about it, because his father has never even acknowledged his existence. I 100% believe it. Now that I know, he is very clearly related. Anyway, that’s really soured my opinion of Murray, along with this other stuff.
I loved Lucy in the series Elementary on CBS (?), and was sorry to see that series cancelled without a chance to properly finish its narrative arcs. I think the network damaged the show by changing its time slot a couple of times, but I thought her work was riveting. The writing was hit and miss, although I thought the first season was brilliant. I also loved the quirky concept of a female non-white Watson as well. I wonder if she will eventually be able to develop her own projects.
She’s a treasure 💚
Lucy Liu is a knock-out and a g*ddamn national treasure. F Bill Murray. If you haven’t seen Why Women Kill on Paramount+, you should watch it because Liu is in it and she is fantastic. I also loved her in both Charlies Angels movies (which are just as fun and charming today as they were twenty years ago) so I hate hearing what a prick Murray was. But he didn’t come back for the sequel so maybe this is why.
My friend worked with Bill Murray several times and when I asked her about him, she said: “I’ve had nothing but decent experiences with him, but my experiences are not someone else’s and I believe them. He has a weird energy around him, like you feel that at any moment he could lose his shit for no reason other than he can. He was probably nice to me because my dad’s in the industry.”
He has that kind of face. I’ve never been a fan of his or met him, but that asshole-on-edge energy is palpable.
I’ve always been a Lucy Liu fan but her starring as Watson on Elementary made me a super fan. F–K YOU, BILL MURRAY!!!!!!!! Also, I must say that I give credit to Barrymore and the other producers for firing Murray from the CA sequel. I’m sure they could all have done more in the moment to protect Liu but at least they got rid of the a–hole for the second film. Plus Barrymore and Diaz both showed up for Liu’s Walk of Fame ceremony and they took some cute Angels-like pics together. So I give the white women co-stars the benefit of the doubt. They seem to have supported, and still support, their WOC colleague, even if they’re best friends and not as tight with her. Not everyone has to be super duper special best friends to support each other at work or in the professional world.
+1 Everything you’ve said.