As you probably know, when it comes to medical research, women are under-represented. The most famous example was the lack of female crash test dummies, but studies on issues like heart disease and cancer have also mainly focused on male participants. Enter Lululemon. The popular yet pricey athleisure line funded a study to research breathing patterns in “elite” female runners. The tests were conducted on treadmills, with the participants doing different treadmill workouts while wearing custom sports bras that were adjusted to different levels of tightness around their rib cages. Surprise! The study found that wearing a sports bra that’s too tight around your rib cage may “compromise” a woman’s ability to breathe properly while exercising, which can also affect their running performance. Lululemon really dropped all that money to tell us something every single woman who’s ever worn a sports bra while exercising could have told them for free.
Be cautious: It turns out that wearing a tight sports bra while exercising may not be good for your health, according to a new study. The study, which was published in the National Library of Medicine, was funded by Lululemon Athletica and conducted by the University of British Columbia. During their research, they examined the breathing patterns of nine elite runners.
While on a treadmill, runners wore custom sports bras that could be adjusted to different tightness levels. The bras were designed for individuals with rib cage sizes ranging from 30 to 34 and cup sizes of B or C. Throughout the study, the runners engaged in various treadmill workouts, during which they adjusted the tightness of their sports bras differently for each session.
The study — which focused on the tightness only around the rib cage — revealed that women who wore a sports bra that was too tight took fewer breaths and exhibited a higher breaths-per-minute rate, noting that “respiratory function may become compromised by the pressure exerted by the underband.”
However, those who wore a less constrictive sports bra “resulted in a decreased work of breathing,” and improved one’s running economy by decreasing submaximal oxygen uptake.
“People ask, ‘What sports bra should I wear?’ I say, ‘Wear one that is correctly fitted,’” Shalaya Kipp, the lead author of the study who is now a postdoctoral fellow at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota, told the Washington Post. “That’s probably the biggest thing that would help.”
Specifically, the study showed how wearing a looser bra had a 1.3% improvement rate for a person’s running economy. Kipp told the outlet that a 2% increase in running economy would help a three-hour marathon runner improve their time by three minutes.
“It was quite invasive,” Kipp, who also competed in the 2012 Olympics and participated in the study, said. “It’s the hardest experimental protocol I’ve ever had someone do.”
“A decline in lung function makes breathing harder, which is especially critical during exercise or daily physical activity,” she added, per the outlet.
I think most of these results are common sense. Of course wearing a too-tight sports bra is going to make it more difficult to breathe while running. Wearing anything too tight from your hips through your shoulders is going to make it difficult to breathe! I think the problem most women run into when buying a sports bra is wanting to feel that extra support to avoid bouncy boobs. Running when you’re flopping around is equally as painful and annoying. So, just like with everything else made for women, the struggle is real. Also, I wonder if Lululemon sponsored this “study” as a way to promote whatever wildly overpriced custom sports bras they want to sell to women with cup sizes C or less. Be the heroes, Lululemon! Give us a supportive yet comfortable sports bra for under $50!
On a more serious note, I do want to take a minute to do a quick PSA on the topic of too-tight sports bras. Obviously, this will not be the case for most women, but if your sports bra suddenly feels too tight without reason, please consider getting checked out by your doctor. My friend is a marathon runner. She had a routine mammogram last winter and it was clear. This past fall, while training, she noticed her sports bra felt too tight and that she was having trouble breathing. It kept happening, so her doctor sent her for another mammogram and she ended up being diagnosed with Stage IV triple negative breast cancer. I don’t want to be a downer or scare anyone! But, it’s been weighing on me, so I thought it was important to mention it just in case it could help any of you out there.
Photos credit: Andrea Piacquadio, Andres Ayrton, The Lazy Artist Gallery and Monstera Production on Pexels
Someone please explain why only 34C and smaller were included in this study.
Because women of average size aren’t sexy enough to warrant research, despite the national love of booo-beeees.
Yes! 36H here. And yes, that is the equivalent of 5Ds. They’re natural, they’re heavy, and there is no exercise bra that works. Study that for me instead!
Examining 9 athletes instead of just asking them is kind of amazing in a way. Especially given that their band and cup sizes are within such a small range. And yeah, I’d rather have sports bra that’s too tight on the ribs, if it means jumping around during zumba will be at least a little bit less painful.
Also, bras and sports bras in particular are so fucking expensive. Forever jealous that men don’t have to pay for those OR for menstrual products OR painkillers for cramps.
My boobs are on a time delay when I run (my foot goes down, they go up ; my foot comes up, they go down). So, yes, I wear a tight sports bra. It’s that or risk being knocked out by flying tits. If someone could make a *decent* sport bra, I’d appreciate it.
This. I literally feel your pain. I used to bind my chest with ACE bandages when I could still run (knees and hips have taken the option to run away now).
OH YES!!!!! I used to wear two running bras at a time to prevent that. These days, I’ve found that the Panache running bras (found on Title Nine) work really well for me – but as you might expect, they are stupidly expensive. I wear a size 32E, to give some perspective.
I would love to see a study like this expanded and done one more women with a broader range of sizes.
Today in no-duh news….
Appreciate this post!!!
I used to think “No sh*t” about “obvious” studies like these, but then I learned that they are actually useful. It gives a solid resource for people to cite when talking about the topic, as a fact check and an actual source rather than “Trust me, we all know this!” It can help a topic be taken more seriously, as I’m sure we’ve all talked to someone who won’t take “it’s common sense” as a reason and will refute something because it’s not “proven.”
This. Everyone is all about “evidence based” this and that, which means somebody actually doing the research to prove very basic facts. Acting like this is something that is stupid and shouldn’t be done is a choice and deeply anti-science. Be better. We are getting overrun with antivax and anti knowledge BS everywhere. Don’t feed into it.
Edited to add: mentioning that they only studied the ideal Lulumon customer is very pro science.
I think is great to have those studies and the possibility of more in the future. Lululemon bras are great, they last long, like years, and are affordable (less than $50). I think this brand is successful precisely because the clothing is well designed for exercising, the fabrics really don’t get bad smell over time and the fact that they are funding medical research for this purpose makes me feel confident about them. Will keep giving them my dollars and using their stuff
I can attest to this. I JUST got rid of a Lulu bra I have worn 4 times a week for 6 years. I don’t out them in the dryer, I let them air dry so the elastic lasts forever. It was $120.00 when I bought it, and I definitely got my money’s worth out of it.
OMG color me shocked.
I hate bras sports, regular, built in shelf, adjustable or whatever. I’m a 38 H and the one thing which has helped support and stop the bounce has ironically been the align racer back style tank top meant for smaller chested women which I use as a compression top. The black and tye dye looking prints have the best material thickness and support to them. I’m not a fan of lululemons ceo being a sizist ahole who is always making digs at women who aren’t petite and claiming their products aren’t meant for other types of bodies. Also the larger you go in lululemon clothes the fabric material is different than the smaller sizes imo and if I’m paying over a hundred for a pair of pants I want the same quality as the petite sizes get.
Thanks for posting this. Of course I come for the celebrity gossip but I really appreciate the women’s health posts.I am not at all a buyer of Lulu but I really would like some recommendations. I also have to wear 2 bras and it’s just so frustrating. Has anyone tried any she fit or glamorise
Interesting note about your friend & the bra feeling tighter due to what ultimately turned out to be breast cancer. Good to know.
One point I don’t understand, because I’m not a statistician although I was always pretty good at math: how does taking fewer breaths equate to more breaths per minute? I think there’s some sort of translation error between the study itself & the reporting of it.