Julia Louis-Dreyfus explains why Seinfeld and Elaine never hooked up


Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Empress of Comedy, has a new profile in The Times to promote the UK theatrical release of her indie film Tuesday (it’s currently available to stream in North America, but not for free). Tuesday sees Julia star as a mother caring for her terminally-ill teenage daughter, and Death shows up in the form of a giant, talking macaw. If you’re waiting for the punchline, there is none. This is a dramatic turn for Julia that sounds more like a punch to the gut, albeit one with its own macabre sense of fantasy. The timing of the film’s UK release has turned out to be quite fortuitous, as Veep viewership has skyrocketed since VP Kamala Harris became the Democratic nominee. While the article starts out heavy on Veep and present-day politics, it also covers the span of Julia’s career, including some old tea on why Jerry Seinfeld and Elaine Benes never hooked up. A few highlights:

On what advice Selina Meyer would give Kamala Harris: “Let me just say this,” Louis-Dreyfus begins, sounding so much like a politician that initially I’m unsure if she’s answering as herself or Meyer, whom she played for seven years in the deliciously savage political satire Veep. “If Selina had any advice for Kamala, she had best not take it. I think Kamala is so intelligent she wouldn’t take the call.”

Veep could no longer outdo reality: “I think in the last few years the culture of politics has become much more venal. So when we started we were pushing against reality, but now less so, certainly in terms of the nastiness of the communication,” she says. One example of that is JD Vance, Trump’s chosen vice-president, referring to Harris in 2021 as a “childless cat-lady”. What did Louis-Dreyfus make of that? “I thought, You poor f***ing idiot. These guys can’t help it. They can’t help it!” she says with a cackle.

Women candidates are more scrutinized: Louis-Dreyfus insists that any similarities people notice between Meyer and Harris have less to do with Harris and more to do with how women in the public eye are perceived. “Female candidates are more scrutinised,” she says. “That is the reality and we played into it and used it to our comedic advantage. There is an episode in which a character suggests Selina open a speech with ‘As a woman’ and she said, ‘I can’t identify as a woman! People can’t know that! Men hate that and women who hate women hate that, which I believe is most women.’ So we used that for a lot of fodder.”

She likes the unlikeable roles: Louis-Dreyfus has never feared playing unlikeable characters. “God, no. I base my career on it. Fallibility is always good for drama or comedy. And with Tuesday, to have that kind of conflict is phenomenal for storytelling,” she says.

NBC wanted Jerry & Elaine to hook up: To have created one TV character who becomes a cultural reference point — Selina Meyer — would be impressive. But Louis-Dreyfus created two; her first was the peerless Elaine Benes. One of the smartest things about Seinfeld is that Jerry and Elaine never become a couple — they are just friends. “Oh, the network wanted it! They wanted a will-they, won’t-they, all that crap. But Larry [David, the show’s co-writer] was just immovable on that point. The show was built on doing things that were outside the norm, so doing something stereotypical would have been atypical of the show.”

She may be related to the Dreyfus affair?! Louis-Dreyfus grew up in Washington DC. Her mother was a writer and her father was a Jewish French-American businessman who escaped the Holocaust as a child, and whose father fought in the French resistance. It was thought the family were descended from Alfred Dreyfus, the French officer who was wrongly convicted of a crime in one of the most notorious antisemitic scandals in the 19th century, but Louis-Dreyfus isn’t sure that’s true. Given her family history, what does she think of the rise of antisemitism in the US? “I’m very worried about it, and I’m very worried about fascism, and I think it looms,” she says.

[From The Times]

I don’t care if maybe it isn’t true, I find it fascinating that lore suggests Julia mayhaps be descended from Alfred Dreyfus! (Wikipedia says she’s his fifth cousin four times removed, fwiw.) Can you imagine what Monsieur Dreyfus would think, looking at Julia today? She comes from wealth and (possibly) quasi highbrow lineage… and all the gal wants to do is play viscerally unlikeable characters who say things so vulgar that we’re left howling with laughter. “But you’re besmirching the family name! J’Accuse!”

The Times interviewer was a bit too intent on making VP Harris out to be the non-fiction carbon copy of Selina Meyer, for my taste — a trend I see cropping up from political pundits. I don’t understand how you can look at Kamala Harris’s character, achievements, and work ethic and find a throughline to Selina Meyer, in fact I find it quite offensive. But Julia answered that question with more class than I would have, chalking it up to how women in the public are judged at large. You know what I would’ve clapped back with? Say it with me now: J’Accuse! (History nerd here; désolé, pas désolé.)

Embed from Getty Images

Photos credit: IMAGO/Dave Starbuck/Avalon, IMAGO/mpi099/Avalon, Joy Scheller/Avalon, Getty and via Instagram

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

24 Responses to “Julia Louis-Dreyfus explains why Seinfeld and Elaine never hooked up”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Melody Calder says:

    I thought they did hook up one episode. She said Jerry was lacking and he wanted a chance to prove her wrong.

    • Proud Mary says:

      Yeh, they did hook in the “Fake, Fake, Fake” episode. But I think what they are talking about here is a Sam and Diane type hook up. If you are old enough to remember Cheers.

      • mightymolly says:

        I think their hookup was early on because by the time I started watching (mid-90s) it was well known they were exes (or whatever two people who hooked up a couple of time and become friends are). But I agree it’s refreshing to have a dynamic other than sexual tension.

    • Mtl.ex.pat says:

      @melody – their characters did hook up, possibly a couple of times. I’ve watched the entire series from beginning to end several times and actually own it. there’s one episode where they had hooked up and things didn’t go quite so well and Jerry’s begging for another chance and at one point, Elaine’s character tells him he got five minutes or something like that.

      In the article Julia says they never became a couple which is accurate. The headline says they never hooked up, which is not accurate.
      I loved that show and my friends and I still quote from it from time to time and burst out laughing.

      • Melody Calder says:

        THANK YOU! I thought I was losing it!

      • Sigmund says:

        Yeah, I’ve rewatched this show SO many times and was confused by this, lol. They do hook up several times, but it’s casual, doesn’t stick, and they move on from it with no lingering feelings or anything. They never become a couple. I think the word choice in the headline is confusing/inaccurate.

      • pottymouth pup says:

        for some reason, I thought the characters had dated years prior to when the show was set and knew it was not meant to be

      • Nikki says:

        I use “sponge worthy” to this day!! Ha Ha!! And hubby and I still laugh at her making devil horns when her boyfriend (Sully??) told her she was going to hell someday!

    • Chrissy says:

      Yes, I remember the episode and the line about separating their friendship and the sex – separating “the THIS and the THAT.”

    • Isabella says:

      They hooked up when they were exes and it was super cringey. Was not an early episode.

      Jerry discovered that she’d faked orgasm every single time when they were dating. So she had to let him try, to “ preserve the friendship” They tried friends with benefits. No staying overnight was one rule. Elaine becomes kind of needy and they stop. As if, Jerry!

      I hated every humiliating second of that episode. Ugh ugh.

      Hard to believe Julia can’t remember. And Larry is patting himself on back for not crossing that line. He did and it was revolting.

  2. Proud Mary says:

    I really, really love Julia. Apparently she was born and raised in a very wealthy Baltimore family. But you will never tell from her attitude. She just has so much more class and talent than people like Gwyneth who were born with silver spoons but can’t stop talking shite. “Sienfeld”, especially the early episodes, is still some of the best tv ever. I still remember the water cooler days of the Soup Nazi and Yada Yada.

  3. Amy T says:

    And her podcast is 👩‍🍳👩‍🍳💋

  4. Lightpurple says:

    I thought the whole basis of Jerry and Elaine was that they had dated in the past and remained friends. That’s how she knew Jerry’s “move” and taught it to Puddy.

    • lucy2 says:

      That’s what I was thinking too, but it sounds like the network wanted them to have a romantic storyline and Larry said no. Good.
      Julia is the best. Not many people could top Seinfeld/Elaine, but Veep was perfection.

  5. Lightpurple says:

    The writer lost me with “cackle,” a word misogynists have been using to demean strong women for a very long time. Here it’s used to describe Julia. It was used as an insult against Janet Reno, Hillary Clinton, Elaine Kagan, AOC, and now social media is full of horrible memes of Kamala Harris cackling. It needs to stop

  6. Tessa says:

    The characters on that show that interacted with the main characters were funny like the close talker. Jerry s date who wore the same outfit all the time. Jerry nemesis Newman. George’s parents.

    • Chrissy says:

      You’re right….Crazy Uncle Leo!! Kramer! The Soup Nazi! Mr. Pitt and Mr. Peterman! Crazy Joe Devola! I could go on all day.

  7. CC says:

    Dreyfus himself didn’t write the article “J’accuse.” Emile Zola did.

  8. Sass says:

    What’s so funny about this is we are on a re watch with our teenagers now and so the show is very clear in my mind. Several times Elaine and Jerry reference why it didn’t work out between them. In other words, the characters had been a couple at one point, but it was before the story began.

  9. Chaine says:

    I’m not sure why she doesn’t know if he is her ancestor or not? It’s not like it was 1000 years ago. It was just in the 19th century. Pretty sure she could go on ancestry and figure it out and 15 or 20 minutes.

    • Mayp says:

      💯. I knew my grandparents who were born in the latter part of the 19th century. It wasn’t that long ago, lineage-wise. I had a great-grandfather who was born in 1854!

  10. Thinking says:

    I thought they realized they loved each other at the end. Not quite the same thing as being a couple or facing sexual tension or anything like that, but for some reason I thought they realized each other in that way.

  11. LadyUltimate says:

    Idk, did they not have a FWB situation going on for at least 1 episode? Or am I experiencing the Mandela effect here? LOL