Are Simon Cowell and Ellen Degeneres not speaking?

ew-cover

We told you earlier this week about how “American Idol” judge Simon Cowell is acting like a diva in his final year on the show, much to the irritation of new judge Ellen Degeneres. Now, new reports say that it’s gotten so bad on set, Ellen and Simon aren’t speaking.

While the singers have provided enough entertainment this season, the real show is behind the scenes where Simon Cowell and Ellen DeGeneres are no longer speaking to each other, RadarOnline.com is reporting exclusively.

“Their relationship started poorly but now the situation has escalated,” a source familiar with the situation told RadarOnline.com

Widespread reports said that Simon arrived an hour and a half later for Idol’s first taping with Ellen, which has not aired yet. Those same reports claimed that Ellen was greatly annoyed and things were off to a very bad start with Simon.

But a source who was at the taping says the reports of Simon’s late arrival are greatly exaggerated. “He showed up exactly 14 minutes late,” said one person who was there.

The show started taping without Simon, a move that immediately polarized Ellen and Simon. “People were surprised the show started without Simon,” said one observer.

The tension between Simon and Ellen escalated instantly due to the situation and quickly it became apparent that when the cameras stopped recording they were not speaking to each other.

“There’s two camps on the show this season,” said an Idol insider. “It’s a lot more tense than previous seasons. It seems as if Ellen has decided to try to take control since Simon is on his way out and that’s created problems.”

[From Radar Online]

So far, the judges’ table this season has been the least interesting thing about the show, and I hope it stays that way. Why does this show even need judges? What do they offer? In these early stages of the show, it’s all manipulated by the show’s producers anyway. I think this is a sign that the show is on life support- but of course, we’ll have to see the ratings numbers before that conversation happens, right?

Meanwhile, Neil Patrick Harris seemed to fit right in as a guest judge in last night’s episode. Harris didn’t have any problem disagreeing with Simon on a few occasions, but he also didn’t hesitate to tell any of the contestants when they sucked.

At one point Patrick Harris said, with seeming sincerity, “I’m scared to disagree with him” – “him” being Simon, of course – before the camera cut to Simon rolling his eyes.

In fact, we’d just seen NPH disagree with Simon half a dozen times.

In response to one contestant, whose audition we don’t get to see, NPH says “I thought you were just great.”

Simon’s reaction? “I get absolutely nothing out of that audition, I’m afraid.”

NPH’s vote? “Yes!”

Simon’s vote? “No.”

In one instance this devolved into what Simon called “Mutiny on the panel!” but was in fact just the other three disagreeing with him about Kimberly Carver, a strong singer who performed a jazzy number she’d written herself.

Over Simon’s objections that this was not “Jazz TV,” which he said with a derogatory sneer (sorry, Miles Davis and John Coltrane!), the other three passed Carver through.

And she wasn’t the first contestant to gush over NPH when she ran out and told her family, “Thank god for Neil Patrick Harris! I’m going to have to go back and watch ‘Doogie Howser’ again.”

The guest also was assertive about getting his say. At one point we saw Simon ask Randy for his verdict on an auditioner, apparently before Patrick Harris had weighed in. “Don’t I get to say anything?” he cut in. “Jeez Louise, you invite a guest judge on . . . .”

And he had good reason to demand his say: His critiques were spot-on.

[From NY Daily News]

Personally, I wouldn’t mind seeing him as a permanent fixture on the show!

Hope For Haiti Now: A Global Benefit For Earthquake Relief held in Los Angeles

67th Annual Golden Globe Awards - Press Room

National Television Awards 2010 - Winners Boards

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

16 Responses to “Are Simon Cowell and Ellen Degeneres not speaking?”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Shay says:

    I’m not really sympathetic. Ellen knew what she was walking into. She’s been complaining about Simons jokes against Seacrest but Seacrest does the reverse to Simon also.

    I still don’t get Ellen on the show as a judge. I’d rather have a judge with a technical ear than one who can just comment with fluff.

  2. Kevin says:

    I saw NPH on the show and I have to agree, he was awesome. I was afraid Ellen was going to be TOO nice for the show when they announced her but I’m willing to wait and see. She may have not found her rhythm yet. She was always sooo cool to her guests on her own show. I remember some little boy (guess he was 8 or so) and he was just tearing it up on his little generic guitar. When he was done she gifted him with a NICE guitar, think it was a Les Paul if I remember right. Kid looked like he was gonna explode he was so excited.

  3. Juiceinla says:

    NPH was amazing. love love, loved him. Wish he would replace Simon next year.

  4. Sudini says:

    I loved seeing NPH on Idol last night. And my God, he’s just fun to look at 😉 And really smart and kind..

    I’m crushin on doogie..

  5. Sumodo says:

    Oh, good! Drama on AI. Way to boost ratings much?

  6. princess pea says:

    I can’t help but think all this ELLEN VS SIMON – THE FIGHT TO END ALL FIGHTS talk is a silly effort to get more ratings for AI. They’d be wise to be a little worried about people leaving the show now that there’s no Paula; I think that’s why Ellen was approached at all. I love Ellen, but I was irritated when she guest judged on SYTYCD (because she has no professional dance experience) and I feel the same way about AI. Other than the auditions and then finals week there isn’t much pre-season taping, so I’m not sure how much time they’ve even had to get all hatey on each other. Some pretty bad singers make it through auditions and get cut later; I’d be more concerned if there was no disagreement over people like them.

  7. lastwordlinda says:

    I agree with Princess Pea. The audience is being set up to keep the ratings up. Ellen is not a good actress so anything contrived that they try on the show will be obvious from day one. I won’t be watching. I don’t like being manipulated.

  8. Carol says:

    What a ridiculous story! Simon is getting paid a lot of money to be Simon; I don’t understand why Ellen would think her job is to come in and change him. And the deal with NPH? I read an interview with NPH earlier and he said he asked Simon if it was okay to disagree with him and Simon said of course. Told him to say whatever he wanted because they were all just winging it. Stupid article trying to make drama for drama’s sake.

  9. annie says:

    I don’t understand the stunt casting of Ellen as a judge. She has no musical background. She isn’t as popular as she thinks she is. NPH or Shania would make better judges, imho.

  10. Tru says:

    ALREADY???

    maybe its just tabloid talk..

    probably not

  11. Feebee says:

    I think this is hype for the show but having said that, it’s no big deal if they’re not talking to each other. Do they need to off camera? As for her starting the show without him, I wish that happened all the time.

  12. skeptical says:

    ellen not speaking to a coworker what nonsense is this?

    this is a PR ploy, some joker thinks this is the way to save that dying show. Have the very epitome of kindness get up in Big Bad Simon’s face.

    Riiiight.

    Poor Ellen…. she thought she was going to be the nice judge who soothed the broken hearts of contestants who were being sent home.
    Instead she’s cast in this inane tabloid drama!

  13. Bete says:

    Simon is a moron. An underqualified wannabe who should just basically work in a b grade marketing company. Only Americans were so stupid to make him something. Now deal with him. I hope his new show fails.

  14. kelly says:

    i will always be on ellens side watch out simon ….if america hates u (and we will if ur mean to ellen) u will not make money from us anymore. sorry but its true

  15. jenn says:

    Saw the headliner.. Big F&%$king deal

  16. Amanda says:

    Kathy Griffin has spoken about how controlling Ellen is on her own show.