Sanjaya’s staying power and the little crying girl’s identity


My mom called me all excited about wondered if I knew why Sanjaya is still on Idol and didn’t even get into the bottom three this week. She also told the story of the mysterious crying girl in the audience, saying that the judges didn’t rip Sanjaya to threads like he deserved and that Simon referred to the girl and said she summed up his thoughts on his terrible performance.

My mom is pissed and says that it’s a shame that Howard Stern is telling people to vote for Sanjaya and that good singers like Stephanie are getting gipped of their chance in the spotlight. I told her about “Vote for the Worst” and about the buzz that Sanjaya and his many hairstyles are getting online.

Unfortunately I can’t watch the show as I live overseas now, but it sounds like a big old scandal and maybe Idol will rethink their scoring model after this season. It seems like they should use some sort of balanced score like on “Dancing with the Stars” where the judges votes still count for something.

Contributors at Oh No They Didn’t found an article that exposes the identity of the crying girl. Ashley Ferl is a 13 year-old who won tickets to a taping of “Smarter than a fifth grader” that also included a chance to sit in on Idol rehearsals. I guess she was spotted and given tickets to the show.

Let me know what you guys think of this because I’m stuck here reading secondhand accounts and watching clips on YouTube.

Here’s Sanjaya singing “Girl You Really Got Me.” He’s so bad, but there is something about the kid that makes you want to root for him.

And here’s a woman that’s going on a hunger strike until Sanjaya is voted off. She might end up losing a lot of weight.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

7 Responses to “Sanjaya’s staying power and the little crying girl’s identity”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Fabiola Thing says:

    the decline of western civilization…

  2. Kolby says:

    I managed to get through about 30 seconds of that clip….then my ears started to bleed.

  3. MaiGirl says:

    We should not be surprised by these shenanigans. AI is about two things: whatever brings the show ratings (the Sanjaya controversy, for example), and whoever the show can market to sell records. If that person happens to be the best singer, that’s a coincedence.

  4. Gayle says:

    I know that song came in a key. What the hell did he do with the key?

  5. Carol says:

    It’s funny because he was pretty good in the audition, I really liked him. Then the show starts and he can’t sing anymore.
    The preteen girls, who are a huge percentage of the voting force, love him. Between that and the freakin douchebags at votefortheworst and king douchebad Stern (what is with men named Stern that makes them dicks?) he’s staying on but he won’t win. One of those chunky black girls is gonna win.

  6. Britney ain't all that says:

    I like this Sanjaya he has that “it” factor and he truly enjoys performing. That’s very important if you have to pay money to see him you want to see someone who is going to put on a show.

    He’s only 17 and every week he has come out bravely and worked his behind off. I give him mad props on his bravery.

    The boy can sing but his voice has gone away over the insanely negative comments.

  7. john says:

    He actually has a chance to win, the AI call centers is in India. The Indians in India are voting for him.