Kelly Clarkson covers Redbook: ‘It’s when I’m fat that I’m happy’

Redbook-December-2017-Cover
Kelly Clarkson covers the December issue of Redbook Magazine. The put her in some holiday dresses and it’s very seasonal without being red and green, which I appreciate. She’s a judge on The Voice this season and is promoting her new album, Meaning of Life, which came out at the end of last month. Her single Love So Soft is number one on the dance charts and #19 on iTunes and her album is #13 on iTunes so it’s doing very well. In Redbook, Kelly talks about body image and her relationship with her husband, two topics she’s touched on recently in other interviews. She said that she does get body shamed but that when she’s larger she’s happy and that she’s fine with that. It’s a good message and she’s just trying to reassure people and sharing her experience. I kind of wish she would phrase it differently though as she got some backlash for it the last time she said it.

On being a positive body image hero to so many women—and how fans might react if she lost weight: “That’s already happened to me. They shame you for it. Same thing happened with Miranda Lambert—I had dinner with her and we were talking about that. She was like, “Should I gain? Should I lose?” But no one actually cares about your health. They just care about aesthetics. It’s when I’m fat that I’m happy. People think, Oh, there’s something wrong with her. She’s putting on weight. I’m like, “Oh, no! I’m sorry, but that represents happiness in my emotional world.” For me, when I’m skinny is usually when I’m not doing well. If you gauge your life on what other people think, you’re going to be in a constant state of panic trying to please everyone. People should just concentrate on their own lives and their own health and their own happiness, and whatever that looks like for you, be happy with it.”

On how being a mom changed her: “Literally, having children has brought fear to my life. That sounds horrible, I know, but before kids I was fearless. Now I go to bed and I have nightmares of someone just grabbing my little girl and running. It’s always about me not being able to protect my kids somehow. I’m a mama bear. Just recently our nanny told me that an older kid was mean to my daughter at the park and that she just crumbled. I’m glad I wasn’t there, because I wouldn’t have handled that well. I totally went off on that 6-year-old in my head!”

On keeping things spontaneous with her husband, Brandon: “Any time we’re in a discussion about sex with a bunch of couples, Brandon and I stay pretty quiet. To keep it family appropriate, let’s say we’re just a lot more active than other couples. I’m a person who loves change. He loves spontaneity. Having a set time or place [to have sex] would be boring to us. When I met Brandon, I wasn’t looking for a friend. I have a lot of great friends! I was looking for a lover. I had never found someone I was truly passionate about, who I wanted to stay in bed with all day. The fact that I did, well…I was going to latch on and take advantage of that.”

On her upcoming gig as a judge on The Voice with Blake Shelton, Adam Levine, and Alicia Keys: “I’ve already warned both Adam and Blake that winning is not my biggest concern. I want to find someone who has incredible talent and really work with that person. It would be amazing to look back in a decade and see this artist have a huge, successful career that I was a part of.”

[From Redbook]

I can’t really relate to my weight reflecting my emotional state because I’m just about as mildly depressed and anxious as I always am no matter my size. Don’t get me wrong I’m not miserable or anything it’s just my problems are usually the same. (Exercise does help my mood though.) Kelly is saying that she associates being happy with being heavier because she was only thin at stressful times in her life. She clarified that well enough, she’s said it before and made it clear that it only applies to her. It does seem like a strange message but it reflects her reality. As long as she’s not getting down on herself for her body shape now or in the past I guess that makes sense.

Also, I understand how having kids made her worry more. I’ve heard that expression that when you have kids your heart is outside of your body and it’s true.

RB-Kelly-Clarkson-1

RB-Kelly-Clarkson-2

Photos credit: James White for Redbook, received via email

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

70 Responses to “Kelly Clarkson covers Redbook: ‘It’s when I’m fat that I’m happy’”

Comments are Closed

We close comments on older posts to fight comment spam.

  1. Mrs. WelenMelon says:

    She’s an endomorph. It feels better, more natural to her to be soft and round.

    Cue the concern trolls.

    • Alison says:

      I don’t even think the concern trolls could muster up shame AKA pretending to care about her health. She looks extremely vibrant and healthy and seems genuinely happy. She radiates health, I think.

  2. Hmm.... says:

    I appreciate when celebrities talk about weight issues that go against the grain. I don’t relate because i have the opposite problem. I used to weigh 130-140 at 5’6″.

    Then something just snapped. I’ve gained so much weight in the past two years after a crippling bout of depression. I think it’s been 40 pounds or so, and the past two months I’ve gained another 7-8. It’s an overeating compulsion and it makes me spiral out of control, because I eat and then I feel intensely guilty about it, and then I just don’t function.

    The thing is, I am undergoing psychiatric treatment and nothing helps. Not therapy, not medication, no working out. Because I just cannot stop eating. And I desperately want to, which only makes it worse. And the more weight I gain, the more ashamed I feel about how I went from being a pretty girl to basically invisible. My SO always wants to go out and I avoid it as much as possible. No pictures, either. When people take candid shots, I’m always surprised at just how big I’ve gotten. I don’t believe it when my SO tells me I’m beautiful, I can’t stand to look in the mirror, and just writing this down has shown me how much self hatred I’m carrying. Hell, after this last bout of weight gain, I don’t even have the courage to put on the huge pants I bought in June because if they don’t fit, I don’t know what I’m going to do.

    Probably stress eat.

    I wish I had Kelly’s confidence. And I wish my self-esteem hadn’t taken such a hit. It feels completely out of my control, so I can’t stand it when people say it’s all about dieting and your will to lose weight. That might well be, but at this point, I feel like I’ll have smoke coming out of my ears from the anxiety overload in my system if someone keeps me away from food. And then I’ll take to other self-harm behaviors, like picking at my hair, skin, grinding my teeth, or even cutting.

    Like I said: I wish I didn’t feel this way. I wish I were at peace with it, like Kelly seems to be.

    • Brunswickstoval says:

      I’m so sorry you’re experiencing this. It sounds so raw and painful. Yes not everyone is at peace with their weight. She sounds like a lovely person.

      I hope you find your happiness.

    • greenmonster says:

      @Hmm…. I don’t know if it helps to know, but you are not alone with this. If you want to talk, I’m sure people here will listen. i know I will. Until then, all the best to you.

    • supersoft says:

      Hmm, ive been there. I highly recommend couples counseling. My hubby was abusive in a very silent way, i only started to recognize a pattern when it broke, but one thing i can clearly tell.
      I wasnt happy in that relationship, and i tried to keep him and his family away from me unconsiouscly with “becoming invisible”. Good luck to you.

    • BlinkBanana says:

      @ Hmm…. Have you tried hypnotherapy? I found it to be really useful in adjusting my relationship to food. And the best tip I ever got (because I was a binge eater), was to never eat in my bedroom. It’s been really hard sometimes, and so tempting to do so, but I’ve gone 6 weeks without eating in my room and I had no idea such a little thing like that could make a bit of a difference. It’s not a miracle cure and I don’t want to be that annoying person who states the bleeding obvious! But if you haven’t tried hypnotherapy, I would give it a go. And also think about where you eat and if that affects the amount of food and eating behaviour. Best of luck to you. I hear your pain and I hope you can get to a place where you can be happy x

    • graymatters says:

      Something similar happened to me. I was so depressed, I was suicidal and although therapy helped with that, I ate and ate and ate as some sort of self-medicating comfort mechanism. I gained over 40 pounds before tapering off — it took a few years, but that constant need to feel something in my mouth did ease. Now I have high blood pressure so I have a non-aesthetic need to lose the weight and I’m afraid of triggering whatever impulse set me off the last time. I’m actually thinking about learning to knit because I can’t imagine stuffing my face while knitting, but I otherwise have no interest in anything crafty.

      Weirdly though, the extra weight makes me feel ugly when I’m out in public, but sexier in the bedroom with my husband — who has never mentioned that I’ve changed since he met me.

      So I’m rooting for you.

    • susiecue says:

      I can relate to a lot of what you’re saying. I’ve recently gained a bunch of weight due to depression as well. Self control feels impossible, and I deal with guilt and self-hatred daily as well. I don’t really have any advice, just want you to know you’re not alone. *hugs*

    • MandyMc says:

      Sorry you’re going through that Hmm. I struggle with about 40lbs due to PCOS. I can only lose weight on Metformin but my doctor won’t prescribe it unless I’m trying to get pregnant (which I’m not ). The weight gain makes me feel crappy about myself which leads to overeating which leads to more weight gain, and the cycle continues.

    • Wren says:

      I’m actually struggling with something similar. I gained weight in college, then made an effort to clean up my diet and got a very physically demanding job and lost a bunch of weight. I felt great, I looked great, life was awesome. Then I lost my job, moved to a town I hated from I town I loved and wanted to live in forever for my husband’s job, and a few other things happened that sent me into depression. Gained the weight back. Now I’m embarking on a path of health once again but it fucking sucks how huge I feel. It feels like I’m going to be this way forever and like nothing is going to help. My husband is super supportive but I just cannot bring myself to believe him when he says I’m beautiful or sexy or whatever. Facebook memories seem to taunt me with what I used to look like and how I want to feel again.

      So, anyway, I guess what I want to say is I feel your pain and you’re not alone.

    • Elyse says:

      The Brain Over Binge recovery book helped me get out of that cycle. Maybe it will help you. It’s not you it’s your primal brain. All the best *hugs*

      • sandra says:

        Yes. Highly recommend Brain over binge. I was a bulimic for many years, recovered now. It’s not ths book that helped me recover, but I read it recently and I wish I read it back then, would have made my recovery easier.

    • Renee says:

      Hmm, Hugs to you sweet lady. You are not alone. I’m currently dealing with anxiety weight issues & overeating myself. I hope you find some solace in knowing we are here to listen if you want to speak. I echo the sentiments of others here that hope you find a way to your own happiness. *Hugs*

    • Kristen says:

      Hey there. This sounds like me.

      I joined Weight Watchers in mid-August and I was crying in the first meeting because I thought that it was going to be like prison. But it is the best thing I did, I’ve lost 30 pounds and they make it really easy. The support helps too.

      My only regret is that I didn’t join sooner, because for some weird reason, it helps you to easily stay on track and you can still eat the foods you like (in moderation).

      If you sign up, make sure to choose the program where you can go to a meeting in your town. I promise it will help!

      Good luck –

    • Pandy says:

      The ways we torture ourselves over weight. I hope you find some peace! Trying to find it myself.

    • FHmom says:

      A big hug to you. I was bulimic for 15 years and the binging/weight gain completely controlled my life. (I always say I was a bad bulimic because I couldn’t completely purge.) I don’t think any suggestions coming from my experience would be of any help.

      I would seriously talk to your doctor, however, about finding the right medicine. Some antidepressants just pack the weight on. If you haven’t ever read about that, then google it because it’s a huge concern to people taking them. Some mess with your metabolism. Others make you ravenously hungry. It’s horrible when the meds you take for depression put weight on you which only adds to your depression.

      As a previous person mentioned, you are not alone in this. Try not to be too hard on yourself.

    • Ladidah says:

      @hmmm have you heard of health at every size (HAES)?

      It is basically the idea that you want to focus on mental health as part of your overall physical health – don’t just focus on weight loss as the solution for every problem.

      My doctor is marvelous and uses this philosophy and I cried when I met her – Instead of her telling me I needed to lose weight she really listened to me, found me a great counselor for my anxiety, hooked me up with a dietitian who encouraged me to have a joyful relationship with food rather than focus on calories or good foods /bad foods, and last but not least – she diagnosed my sleep apnea, which was making me feel crazy tired, anxious, depressed and gain weight way beyond what calories would predict.

      Apparently your body doesn’t like it when you stop breathing every minute at night.

      The sleep apnea diagnosis made me much more compassionate towards people of size – because my doctor said not sleeping has caused some of her patients to gain weight, just like thyroid issues, or pcos, or other issues that can affect our size and emotions. It is definitely not just calories in calories out.

      I really feel like you need support to get yourself out of this kind of situation you are in, but I know it is hard to take that first step so I wish you support and courage. Apologies if I overstepped.

      And yes! as you can see you are not alone, not at all, but that also doesn’t mean you might not need professional help.

  3. Jess says:

    I agree about the fear, I was always the first one to run off and do something crazy, until I had my daughter. Now I feel paralyzed by the fear that something will happen to me, and she’s of course fearless so I worry for her as well.

    I like Kelly a lot, and I hope she’s being honest about her happiness.

    • Sherry says:

      That was me too! I would take so many chances before I had kids. After I became a mom, I saw danger around every corner and still do.

      As for the weight thing, I think she’s spot on that people should listen to their own selves and be who they want to be at the weight they want to be, regardless of what other people want.

  4. SilverUnicorn says:

    Her message is spot-on and refreshing but… as a previously “fat-happy” lady who had to lose quite a bit of weight in the last 4 years because of my back pain, well… I am afraid she thinks like that because she is young…

  5. Lala says:

    I’ve been 335 pounds…and I’ve been 202 pounds from the ages of 21 – 35….I’m currently around 250 and I just turned 50…and I have never tripped about it…it’s who I am…and as long as I can outfit this body of mine in HAWT fashions…I’m good!

    • Shambles says:

      I love you!! You are awesome. Rock on.

    • Beth says:

      That’s a great attitude to have, and I wish there were more that felt as positive about themselves as you do

    • PhatGirl says:

      Me too! It’s my confidence that makes me sexy not my weight and I know it! I have been thinner and less attractive due to losing the weight through anxiety. Now I’m a little larger but hella more confident and it really shows. Stay HAWT girlfriend.

    • Ladidah says:

      I love this! I stopped weighing myself and for the last two years, my clothes fit all the same, I am happy, healthy, much more so than when I worried about losing that last whatever lbs. I wish all men and women could feel as much happiness and freedom in trusting their bodies.

    • Sophia's Side eye says:

      Lala, you just made my day with this post, you are awesome!

  6. Vovicia says:

    I love Kelly so much. I’d love to have that attitude about being fatter – unfortauntely that is not my reality. And the way that they’ve melded the two families – step-children AND the ex-wife is nothing short of incredible. I found it a little jarring at first when she used to so bluntly say, ‘I have four kids.’ But those are some lucky children to have so much love in their loves.

  7. M Marie says:

    I heard her on Anna Faris’ podcast and she touched on this. Love her attitude. Her relationship also seems to be super healthy and all about uplifting each other. (Exactly what I’m looking for in my next relationship)

  8. Sullivan says:

    Weight is a touchy subject. I wish it were a non-subject.

  9. grabbyhands says:

    I hate that she keeps having to explain/justify her weight, and I’m glad that she seem pretty fearless talking about it. But no woman should have to, no matter where she falls on the weight spectrum, unless she wants to. No woman should have to say anything about her body unless she wants to.

    • Amy says:

      I agree! I hate that women are constantly expected to justify their body when they often have little to no control over it to begin with. And many women are not as happy as she is with her body, but are still demanded to talk about it, justify it, explain it, etc. it is such a weird, gross part of our society.

  10. Barbcat says:

    I am opposite of her. I gain weight when I am stressed/depressed. When I am happy I exercise and don’t stress-eat junk or drink and I am at a great weight. Right now I am 5’7” and 135 in my 40’s because I take care of myself. I love being fit because I know that it increases my chances of living a longer and healthier life with my husband and kids. I want to watch my kids grow up and not die earlier from the many side-effects of diabetes…

    I sometimes think she talks about how she is happy when she is “fat” because she is trying to convince herself that is true. She “protests too much”.

    • Sandy says:

      Or maybe she is actually truly happy with herself? I don’t think she is protesting too much, I think she is talking about herself and only herself. She’s not telling anyone else how to feel in their skin or suggesting everyone should be fat and happy. I think that is a great message to send, ie be happy with yourself and don’t worry about anyone else.

    • Esmom says:

      It’s great that you found what works for you but I think everyone is different. When I’m unhappy/stressed/anxious/depressed I can’t eat, food has no appeal or even taste to me. So I tend to associate thinness with unhappiness.

      • Sullivan says:

        @esmom- Me, too. I’m of average weight and when I have gotten extremely stressed and depressed I have unintentionally lost a lot of weight because I felt too sick to eat. I call it the deep, dark depression diet. It’s only happened twice, but it’s awful and I work diligently on my mental health so I won’t get to that place again.

      • Esmom says:

        Sullivan, yes. It’s bad. And the awful part is when people are like “you look great, you lost weight.” Because size matters, apparently, more than the misery in my face or haunted look in my eyes. To be fair I try to hide the misery but still the focus on weight is annoying.

      • Amy says:

        I lost a lot of weight because of opiate addiction in my early 20s. I was getting high and smoking so many cigarettes so that when I ate, I would just end up vomiting. I was really really thin and everyone (even my dental hygienist!) was telling me that I looked awesome. They wanted to know what I did to lose the weight and they expected a response like it was very much their business. I would respond that I had stopped eating and they would laugh and smile. My mother in law even took me shopping for all new clothes because I “deserved” it for losing the weight. I was not very overweight to begin with, I didn’t have any health problems due to my weight, I didn’t complain about my original weight, but apparently everyone around me had a problem with my original weight because they all congratulated and celebrated hard when I lost it.

    • perplexed says:

      For some reason, I believe her. I don’t know if that’s because she always seems bubbly, though. Not forced bubbly, but real bubbly in a way that never seems fake. Her outward personality doesn’t seem to change whether she’s thin or fat.

    • Anna says:

      @Barbcat, I think you’re exactly right. Good to see some sanity in these comments!

  11. minx says:

    I like her but I wish she would top talking about her weight. It’s nobody’s business.

  12. Chaine says:

    What a great photoshoot! She looks just luminous and I like all of the clothing.

  13. Lucy says:

    She’s dangerously overweight though , why be happy with that ?

    • Sandy says:

      Really? Dangerously overweight? I’m not going to claim she is a healthy weight, but Kelly isn’t what I associate with “dangerously overweight”.

    • It took 13 comments. just 13.

    • detritus says:

      unless you are her doctor or Kelly herself, you have no idea what her health status is.

    • Plantpal says:

      Dear Lucy~ ever heard of the boy who cried wolf?? There is no way in God’s Green Earth she is “dangerously overweight”. She’s carrying maybe 20 pounds more than absolutely necessary. Hardly dangerous. And she’s saying in her life, this makes sense for her. So Lucy, Darling, Back off and sit down please.

    • Robin says:

      70% of Americans are overweight or obese today. That is your answer.

      • Ladidah says:

        Look I am not going to pretend to know everything, but did you know the BMI markers for obesity have changed? Used to be BMI 34 and above was cutoff for obese, and BMI 30-34 was overweight, then diet companies lobbied the American medical association and the AMA changed it BMI 30 and below as obese. they are considering making the new obese cutoff BMI 26 and below.

        Ergo, something like 80 million people went to bed “healthy” and woke up “overweight and obese” and supposedly diseased and sick Overnight. The diet companies want to lower the threshold for BMI 26 and above to be obese. Seems kinda ridiculous. There are sick far people and sick thin people in my life. Idk.

        People naturally gain weight as they age until age 80 – for women it protects our bones much better.

        Are there super big people? Yes, but something has gone seriously wrong with their bodies, just like medical issues can sometimes make people super thin.

        As Kaiser said – there are people like my dad who was thin his whole life, smoked cigarettes, ate crap, had good numbers at the doctors office, and got cancer. He is a miserable dude. But his BMI was good /sarcasm

      • Ladidah says:

        Linked to article I was talking about which mentions that the 90% of the AMerican medical association members who voted to change the bmi guidelines for overweight and obese had ties to the diet industry and it is very suspect in how that influenced their vote.

        In my opinion, stigmatizing overweight and obese disproportionately affects women as we tend to carry more fat for reproductive purposes, and then post menopausal, for bone protection.

        Google national women’s health network – prescription-for-change-forget-fat

    • Renee says:

      Ahhh Lucy, your faux concern over her health is unconvincingly obvious. Please take your insulting comments elsewhere.

  14. Leskat says:

    I’m glad she’s happy with where she is at, but she’s not fat. I think she naturally has a bigger, softer body type and if she is ok with it, I find no flaw in that. Watching any interview with her always makes me happy. She radiates happiness and confidence and peace with herself and she’s SO TALENTED. I want her to stop talking about her weight because it damn sure isn’t my business or anyone’s for that matter and she can do what she pleases with her body. It’s hers, after all and she doesn’t need to justify or explain herself to ANYONE.

    • Amy says:

      I have recently read some articles about the word fat and specifically the “but you’re not fat… you’re just….” The main idea was that we need to allow women to identify their body in any way they like. To some women, fat is not a bad word. They’re trying to “take fat back” from the body shamers and they find the word fat to be the perfect descriptor for themselves and refuse to allow the word fat to be shameful. The article made me think about how I think about the word fat and also about how I have many times said “you’re not fat, you’re just a different body type/big boned/etc”

  15. Giggs says:

    I love her. I know exactly what she means by happier when ‘fat’ – she may be fat to industry standards, but I think she’s beautiful and carries her weight well and with confidence and that’s gorgeous.

    I’m 5’6 and got down to 119 lbs – I was very lithe but didn’t look sick by any means- and the reaction from my friends and family was: this isn’t your look. And I was miserable at that weight as well even though I had what I thought I wanted – because who doesn’t want what they see all the time?? I’ve been at 145-150 for the past 8 years now and while I don’t consider it ‘fat’, I’m a size 8 and in that weird middle sized woman range that’s not really represented in the media. But this weight is easy for me to maintain for ME, and having that pressure off of myself and focusing on intuition and how my clothes fit has taken so much stress away from my life.

  16. aenflex says:

    I suppose there is some ease and happiness in eating whatever you like whenever you want , not needing to worry with working out, not needing to worry if your spouse or partner still finds you attractive, etc. I genuinely mean that without any sarcasm. Maybe for her, emotionally, it’s easier not to stress on those types of things. Maybe she’d rather not deal with those types of pressures, whether they be personally or externally applied. If she’s happier this way, good for her.
    Personally I like challenging myself, and working out and eating well don’t come naturally for me, so keeping fit is a challenge – but I enjoy it.
    Also don’t care how she or anyone else chooses to live with regard to weight and physical wellness. It’s when people start using body positivity in attempt to muddle and defy actual scientific facts that I get a little peeved.

    • Sandy says:

      Nice concern trolling. Where is anyone saying being overweight is healthier for you? I don’t think that is what Kelly was saying. She was saying she, herself, is happier when she isn’t fighting to stay Hollywood thin. Body positivity isn’t about celebrating bad health, it is about being okay with yourself. If being super fit is what makes you happy, great. If your fine being overweight, sure, be happy. Of it doesn’t affect you, why the judgment and concern? The only people we are truly responsible for is ourselves.

      • Ladidah says:

        I don’t think we in the US know what health is though. For me it is mental health, physical health (yoga), feeling like I am living in line with my values with my job. But for someone else they consider healthy to be emotions – leaving a bad relationship or a toxic famiy behind.

        For poc health I think health is to be able to be surrounded by non racist people since racism has been documented to have a huge affect on poc mental and physical health and leads to bad neonatal outcomes and other bad medical care or bad treatment by cops. Let’s not be so bougie to assume health only means fruits and veggies and exercise.

        for someone else it might be low fat eating, for someone else it is running marathons or ultra marathons, or lifting weights, or paleo.

        I just think there is a lot about health we don’t understand, and there are a lot of factors that go into it. And personally, if my friend is on antidepressants and gains weight from that, and looks plumper, I don’t think it is my place to judge that they are now unhealthy since their mental health is much better and they are able to live life again.

        I would like to see people be open minded that health can mean a lot of different things which social scientists have identified. I think the number one way to be healthy is to be rich and don’t stress about food or water or a roof. Then Have good parents, good genes, have a good support network. What if that can you really control?

      • Amy says:

        Ladidah: I am with you on this. Weight and body fat are a factor in determining health, they are not the sole determinant. So many people judge health by what they can see: skinny vs. fat. We don’t know if a thin person has 100 different medical conditions, mental health struggles, is being abused mentally or physically or sexually, is a smoker, heavy drinker, drug user. And we don’t know if a fat person is all of the opposite. Weight can be a contributing factor in health but it is not the only thing that matters.

    • Anna says:

      Good point.

    • Roman says:

      I agree completely, and seeing all these comments saying she is not overweight it’s not surprising we have a huge obesity epidemic in this country. People have become so accustomed to it we no longer recognize what a healthy weight looks like. It’s sad and terrifying.

  17. Angel says:

    I like that the pics are full body not just the face, usually what theyvdo when the celebrity is not skinny.

  18. GreenQueen says:

    As a trauma nurse I am so sick of the phrase “unless you’re her doctor you can’t label her as obese”. No, actually, that is not true. Every single day, I make that assessment, it’s actually very easy to eyeball. If I were to blatantly not chart ‘obese’ for someone who was obese then I would probably get fired for being a dumbass. In the medical field, we don’t waste time over dumb arguments. Technically, yes, we would chart her as obese. That doesn’t mean that she is super unhealthy, maybe her labs are somewhat normal. She will be at a higher risk for type II diabetes, cardiovascular disease, stroke, etc. as she knows I’m sure. If she’s happier at this weight, good for her, we want to meet people where they are at. She is probably very well aware of the risks. As she ages, things will likely change. This isn’t concern trolling or any trolling. People get touchy here, but 1/3 Americans are obese, 2/3 are overweight. Again, there aren’t any arguments about this. These are facts. It’s a balance, we want people to be mentally and physically healthy and happy – that equilibrium looks different for everyone.

    As a side note, if this trend in obesity does not improve that will cause catastrophic results. Currently, the number one thing causing nurses to leave the industry is back injuries. As Americans get fatter and the baby boomers (whom are currently the fattest population in our society) age we will lose nurses even quicker. We really need to come up with solutions quick. I have had two major back injuries this year alone from doing wound cares on obese people, where I needed 2-3 nurses aides to assist me just in lifting a leg, ass cheek or pannus. My unit itself, which is an extremely unique level 1 Burn/plastics/pediatric trauma unit has lost 2 nurses this year permanently to back injuries and 3 others for 9+ plus months from back injuries. It’s a crisis.

  19. Caty Page says:

    The beauty industry has a stake in making us think ‘men are visual creatures’ and we need to strive for an impossible and ever-changing standard of beauty.

    We then compulsively ask every woman who doesn’t meet arbitrary beauty standards how they have so much ‘confidence,’ as if it’s shocking to love oneself. We literally need to ask for reasoning and clarification when a woman dares to think she’s werkin et.

    Ladies, get naked and stand in front of the mirror tonight. List 2 things you love. Do it again tomorrow. And forever. Because you are tough, strong, and deserve to feel fine AF in the skin you’re in.

  20. Shannon says:

    I’m so the same way. I joke you can tell how I’m feeling inside by how I look outside. If I’m emotionally healthy, I’m eating well and I just don’t eat, like, hardly at all when I’m upset or stressed. When a relationship ended a couple of years ago I could barely keep anything down. People were like, “You look great!” And I was like, that’s funny because my whole world is falling apart and I can’t eat anything but whatever you say.

  21. Mina says:

    I kind of hate that every headline I see about Kelly Clarkson lately is about her weight. Why is she still being asked about it? Why should we care if she’s fat or thin? I can’t wait for the day when that is not an issue. She’s so talented and has a lot of other things to talk about. Same with other plus size celebrities, it seems that it’s so hard for some to imagine that someone who weights more can be successful and famous. It’s really annoying.

  22. Katrina says:

    I adore her